Twelve departmental machines — seven LaserJet Enterprise printers from the M604, M605 and M606 lines and five MFP M630 multifunctions — draw on a single black cartridge family that HP builds in two sizes: the 81A (CF281A, about 10,500 pages) and the high-yield 81X (CF281X, about 25,000). This store stocks each tier as a full ladder of six pack sizes, twelve offers in all, every one a compatible and every one carrying its markdown as this page is written. One fence runs through the whole family, and this page never lets it out of sight: the two M604 printers take the standard cartridge only, because HP fits them with no high-yield unit at all. For the other ten machines the arithmetic takes an unusual shape — a single high-yield cartridge, at 0.21¢ a page, already undercuts the deepest standard box on the shelf.
Run any of the twelve machines and the shelf below is everything this store stocks for it — but read the badge on your printer before you read the prices. Owners of the M604n and M604dn shop the standard ladder only: six pack sizes of the 81A, and nothing else fits. Owners of the other ten models shop both ladders, and for them this family’s money sits in the tier step rather than the pack step — the high-yield pair that fronts this page holds some 50,000 rated pages for $86.74, while even the standard cartridge’s largest box prints at a higher rate per page. No genuine HP cartridge stands on this shelf; HP’s own prices appear further down for scale. What follows sets the twelve offers side by side, walks the roster model by model, and reports the chip position in exactly the terms the listings leave it.
Two ladders, twelve offers — and one fence at the M604
The twelve listings divide by tier, and the tiers divide the roster. The standard ladder — single through 10-pack — feeds all twelve machines. The high-yield ladder mirrors it size for size and feeds ten, stopping at the M604 pair, for which HP publishes no high-yield cartridge. Within each ladder the per-cartridge price falls as the boxes deepen, from $42.90 down to $28.43 on the standard side and from $51.41 down to $36.94 on the high-yield side. Across the ladders the comparison inverts the usual pattern: the high-yield single’s page rate undercuts the standard 10-pack’s, so in this family the tier a buyer chooses matters more than the size of the box it arrives in.
Against HP’s shelf the pair’s arithmetic sharpens further: a genuine 81X costs $428.99, so two of them total $857.98 — $771.24 beyond this pair’s price. The rating behind the pair is also the shelf’s least contested figure: HP rates the CF281X at about 25,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19752, and the compatibles here state the same 25,000 in their own listings.
Shop the 81X 2-Pack →ALSO ON THE SHELF — THE STANDARD LADDER, FITTING ALL TWELVE MODELS
Ten cartridges at $28.43 each — the standard tier’s floor per cartridge and per page, and the deepest box an M604 can be fed from.
Shop the 81A 10-Pack →
Five at $30.04 apiece — half the big box’s depth at nearly its page rate, for stores rooms that turn stock over faster.
Shop the 81A 5-Pack →
Four cartridges at $30.84 each. This is one of the shelf’s newer-generation listings, and its text states the warranty cartridge by cartridge.
Shop the 81A 4-Pack →
Three at $32.18 each — one in the machine, one in the drawer, one behind it.
Shop the 81A 3-Pack →
Two at $34.86 each — the M604 owner’s pair, and the standard ladder’s natural starting size: a working cartridge and its replacement.
Shop the 81A 2-Pack →
A single standard cartridge carrying the same rating as the unit HP installs at the factory — HP’s genuine version is $260.99. On the ten machines that also accept the 81X, $8.51 more buys the high-yield single and more than twice the pages; on an M604, this is the only single there is.
Shop the 81A Single →ALSO ON THE SHELF — THE HIGH-YIELD LADDER, FITTING TEN MODELS (NOT THE M604N OR M604DN)
Ten at $36.94 each — the shelf’s cheapest page and its largest single order: a quarter of a million rated pages in one box.
Shop the 81X 10-Pack →
Five at $38.55 apiece, printing at the same 0.15¢ a page the big box reaches — the tier’s depth without its outlay.
Shop the 81X 5-Pack →
Four at $39.35 each — the high-yield side’s newer-generation listing, its warranty stated per cartridge in the text.
Shop the 81X 4-Pack →
Three at $40.69 apiece — a working cartridge, a spare and a buffer, at 0.16¢ a page.
Shop the 81X 3-Pack →
The high-yield cartridge on its own — and the page’s standing surprise: its 0.21¢ rate beats every standard-tier offer here, the 10-pack included. HP charges $428.99 for its genuine version at the same rating.
Shop the 81X Single →Read down either ladder and the reward for depth is steady but modest: the standard side moves from 0.41¢ a page at the single to 0.27¢ at the 10-pack, the high-yield side from 0.21¢ to 0.15¢. Read across them and the larger movement appears — the two ladders are offset by more than either ladder’s own slope, which is how a lone high-yield cartridge comes to outrun a ten-deep standard box. In cash terms, ten standard cartridges bought one at a time across ten orders total $429.00 against $284.29 in a single box; the same exercise on the high-yield side runs $514.10 against $369.38.
Every figure on this page is worked from the sale price — the amount checkout actually charges. The markdown is running at roughly thirteen percent under list across the twelve listings as this page is written, while the product pages still run their own per-page sums from list prices; that one difference explains why their rates read higher than the ones printed here.
Twelve offers at sale prices — the table
For both tiers the yield column carries HP’s published ratings — approximate averages under ISO/IEC 19752, with real output moving according to how much of each page gets covered. A pack’s total is the sum of its cartridges’ ratings, and its rate is the sale price spread over that sum; blended marks the rows where the rate is averaged across a whole box. The fits column is where this family’s one restriction lives: standard rows read all twelve models, while high-yield rows name the ten and leave the M604 pair out.
| Offer | Fits | Sale price | Rated yield per cartridge | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 81X 2-Pack — the flagship | 10 models — not M604n/M604dn | $86.74 | Up to ~25,000 pages each | 0.17¢ blended | SAVE $16.08 |
| 81X 10-Pack | 10 models — not M604n/M604dn | $369.38 | Up to ~25,000 pages each | 0.15¢ blended | SAVE $144.72 |
| 81X 5-Pack | 10 models — not M604n/M604dn | $192.73 | Up to ~25,000 pages each | 0.15¢ blended | SAVE $64.32 |
| 81X 4-Pack | 10 models — not M604n/M604dn | $157.40 | Up to ~25,000 pages each | 0.16¢ blended | SAVE $48.24 |
| 81X 3-Pack | 10 models — not M604n/M604dn | $122.07 | Up to ~25,000 pages each | 0.16¢ blended | SAVE $32.16 |
| 81X Single | 10 models — not M604n/M604dn | $51.41 | Up to ~25,000 pages | 0.21¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 81A 10-Pack | All 12 models | $284.29 | Up to ~10,500 pages each | 0.27¢ blended | SAVE $144.71 |
| 81A 5-Pack | All 12 models | $150.19 | Up to ~10,500 pages each | 0.29¢ blended | SAVE $64.31 |
| 81A 4-Pack | All 12 models | $123.36 | Up to ~10,500 pages each | 0.29¢ blended | SAVE $48.24 |
| 81A 3-Pack | All 12 models | $96.54 | Up to ~10,500 pages each | 0.31¢ blended | SAVE $32.16 |
| 81A 2-Pack | All 12 models | $69.72 | Up to ~10,500 pages each | 0.33¢ blended | SAVE $16.08 |
| 81A Single | All 12 models | $42.90 | Up to ~10,500 pages | 0.41¢ | Bought one at a time |
Two comparisons do this page’s work. The flagship pair against the standard pair: $86.74 buys about 50,000 rated pages where $69.72 buys about 21,000 — $17.02 more, well over twice the pages, on any machine that accepts both. And the high-yield single against the standard 10-pack: the single is the cheaper page of the two, 0.21¢ against 0.27¢, despite being the smallest purchase on the shelf — the clearest statement of how this family prices its tiers.
Where the page rate is actually won
Most two-tier families reward the buyer twice — once for stepping up a tier, once for deepening the box. Here the rewards are lopsided. Stepping from the standard single to the high-yield single moves the rate from 0.41¢ to 0.21¢, nearly halving it, for $8.51 of extra outlay. Deepening inside the high-yield tier, single to 10-pack, moves it from 0.21¢ to 0.15¢. The tier step is worth more than the whole pack slope on either ladder — on the ten machines where both tiers are open.
The M604 pair reads a shorter table. Their only ladder is the standard one, and its slope — 0.41¢ easing to 0.27¢ — is the whole of their optimization: depth is the one lever they hold, and the 10-pack pulls it fully. For the other ten models, the standard ladder’s remaining case is outlay rather than rate: its 10-pack is the cheapest ten cartridges here at $284.29, $85.09 under the high-yield box, holding 105,000 rated pages against 250,000 — a sensible trade for a machine whose remaining service is measured in months rather than years.
Two ratings on one measuring standard
HP rates the CF281A at about 10,500 pages and the CF281X at about 25,000, and frames both the same way on its printer pages: a declared yield value in accordance with ISO/IEC 19752, with actual yields varying considerably according to the images printed. Every listing on this shelf states those two figures exactly — the standard texts at 10,500, the high-yield texts at 25,000 — and the pack totals quoted in the listings are plain sums of them: 21,000 for the standard pair, 125,000 for the high-yield 5-pack, and so on up both ladders. No second, competing figure attaches to either rating anywhere in this family’s paperwork.
The cartridge a new machine arrives with deserves its own sentence, because enterprise printers so often ship with a shortened starter. These do not. HP’s pages for the M604n and the M605n describe the pre-installed cartridge as an 81A rated at about 10,500 pages — the full replacement rating — and the M630 series datasheet lists a black print cartridge of 10,500 pages in the box contents of each of its multifunctions. A new owner therefore starts a full cartridge’s life away from the first reorder, with time to learn the machine’s real monthly appetite before choosing a ladder and a depth.
For scale, HP’s own store prices the genuine 81A at $260.99 and the genuine 81X at $428.99, both shown in stock on the day this page was written — roughly six and eight times the compatible singles’ sale prices respectively, at the same published ratings.
Twelve machines, one split roster
The roster below is HP’s, assembled from its own documents — the model table of the M604/M605/M606 user guide for the printers, the M630 series datasheet for the multifunctions, and the M630 user guide for one model the datasheet leaves out. The split running through it is the family’s defining fact: the standard cartridge serves all twelve machines, while the high-yield cartridge serves the ten that are not M604s. HP’s page for the M604n names the CF281A as its replacement cartridge and nothing else, and HP’s page for the 81X itself lists the M605, M606 and M630 series while leaving the M604 out.
The printers: LaserJet Enterprise M604n and LaserJet Enterprise M604dn — the standard-only pair — then the LaserJet Enterprise M605n, LaserJet Enterprise M605dn, LaserJet Enterprise M605x, LaserJet Enterprise M606dn and LaserJet Enterprise M606x, each of which takes both cartridges.
The multifunctions: LaserJet Enterprise MFP M630dn, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M630h, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M630f and LaserJet Enterprise Flow MFP M630z, all four taking both tiers — plus the LaserJet Enterprise Flow MFP M630h, which stands on HP’s roster in its M630 user guide (product number P7Z47A) but has no category in this store and is named by no listing here, so it appears in this roster without a link.
One caution, because it can cost a buyer real money. Listings elsewhere in this store are titled for the M604 models with the high-yield code in their names, and one of them answers its own compatibility question by naming the 81X as the cartridge that belongs in the M604n. Against HP’s documents that is simply wrong — the M604 pair takes the CF281A only — and this guide neither carries nor links those listings. Whatever the source, the check that settles fit is the code printed on the cartridge coming out of the machine: CF281A fits all twelve models on this roster; CF281X fits the ten that are not M604s.
Chips: one clause in a parts list, on a platform older than blocking
Ten of the twelve listings on this shelf use the word chip exactly once, inside a sentence cataloguing how the cartridge is built — new parts throughout, with OPC drums, wiper blades and a smart chip among them. The two 4-pack listings do not use the word at all. That is the whole of the shelf’s position: the sentence inventories components, firmware is never mentioned anywhere on the shelf, and a parts list is not a promise about how a printer will respond to a cartridge.
From HP’s side there is nothing further to report, and this page reports exactly that. These machines date from 2014, ahead of the dynamic-security program HP later fitted to other LaserJets, and HP’s pages for the M604n and M605n carry no dynamic-security cartridge language at all — no warning to pass on, and no basis for a blocking claim in either direction. What the listings commit to instead is remedy: a year of warranty and a year of free returns standing behind every offer. Both of this family’s codes, CF281A and CF281X, are covered on the store’s HP monochrome toner chip compatibility page, alongside the rest of the monochrome range.
What stands behind the twelve listings
Which of the twelve to buy
Questions buyers ask about this family
No. HP’s page for the M604n names exactly one replacement cartridge — the CF281A, the 81A — and HP’s page for the 81X itself lists the M605, M606 and M630 series while leaving the M604 out. M604 owners shop the standard ladder on this page, where the deepest box still reaches 0.27¢ a page. One warning travels with the answer: listings elsewhere in this store are titled for the M604 models with the 81X code in their names, and one answers its own fit question wrongly. HP’s documents govern; those listings are not carried here.
By division. The 81X single spreads $51.41 across about 25,000 rated pages and lands at 0.21¢; the 81A 10-pack spreads $284.29 across about 105,000 and lands at 0.27¢. The tier carries close to two and a half times the standard cartridge’s pages for about a fifth more money at the single size, so the tier step outruns ten steps of pack discount. The catch is the fence: the comparison only exists on the ten models that accept both cartridges.
No. HP’s pages for the M604n and M605n describe the pre-installed cartridge at about 10,500 pages — the 81A’s full replacement rating — and the M630 datasheet’s box contents give the same 10,500-page cartridge for each of its multifunctions. The first reorder is a full cartridge’s life away, which leaves room to measure a month or two of real volume before committing to a tier and a pack size.
The two sets of figures start from different prices. Every rate here divides the sale price by rated pages — $42.90 for the standard single, giving 0.41¢ a page — while each product page runs its sums from list, $49.34 for that same cartridge. Neither set is wrong; they are answers at different prices. While the markdown runs, the sale-based figures describe the money that actually changes hands; if it ends, the list-based figures on the product pages become the operative ones again.
No. HP’s retail range for this family is exactly two cartridges, standard and high yield. A contract variant of the high-yield cartridge exists in HP’s channel under the code CF281XC, carrying the same 25,000-page rating rather than a larger one, and this store does not stock it. Beyond the 81X, the only step up in capacity is a bigger box of the same cartridge.
Return it. Every offer on this page carries a year of warranty and a year of free returns, and inside a pack the cover runs per cartridge — the last unit out of a 10-pack is protected from the day it is installed, not the day the box arrived. Support is available Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central, while a return is arranged. Keep the packaging until the cartridge has proven itself; returns travel better in it.
