MFC-L5800DW
The Brother MFC-L5800DW is a monochrome laser all-in-one with two black toner cartridges to choose from. The standard-yield TN820 covers about 3,000 pages, and the high-yield TN850 covers about 8,000 pages for offices that print and copy every day. Both run in the DR820 (DR-820) drum unit, rated at about 30,000 pages on single-page jobs and up to about 50,000 pages when work runs three pages per job. The listings below hold both cartridges in compatible and genuine Brother form — singles and multipacks — and the drum units in sizes from one to five.
The step-up all-in-one in a small office tends to inherit every job the smaller machines cannot finish, which makes its cartridge consumption the least predictable in the building. One week is contracts and copying, the next is a single trickle of faxes. A two-rung cartridge ladder suits that life: the big cartridge carries the heavy weeks cheaply, and the purchasing never has to guess exactly which week is coming, because both sizes fit the same machine and the same drum.
Toner Cartridges for MFC-L5800DW
| Cartridge | Color | Page Yield |
|---|---|---|
| TN820 — compatible black, individual cartridge | Black | 3,000 pages |
| TN820 — genuine Brother black, individual cartridge | Black | 3,000 pages |
| TN850 — compatible black, individual cartridge | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — genuine Brother black, individual cartridge | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN820 — compatible black, two-pack | Black | 3,000 pages |
| TN820 — compatible black, three-pack | Black | 3,000 pages |
| TN820 — compatible black, five-pack | Black | 3,000 pages |
| TN820 — compatible black, ten-pack | Black | 3,000 pages |
| TN850 — compatible black, two-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — compatible black, two-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — genuine Brother black, two-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — compatible black, three-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — genuine Brother black, three-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — genuine Brother black, four-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — compatible black, five-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — compatible black, five-pack, premium quality | Black | 8,000 pages |
| TN850 — compatible black, ten-pack | Black | 8,000 pages |
Drum units stocked for this model, single through five-pack, compatible and genuine:
- DR820 — compatible drum, individual cartridge
- DR820 — compatible drum, individual cartridge
- DR820 — compatible drum, individual cartridge
- DR820 — compatible drum, individual cartridge
- DR820 — compatible drum, individual cartridge
- DR820 — compatible drum, individual cartridge (alternate listing)
- DR820 — compatible drum, two-pack (alternate listing)
- DR820 — compatible drum, individual cartridge (alternate listing)
- DR820 — genuine Brother drum, individual cartridge
Which cartridge should you buy?
Decide by monthly volume rather than by the week in front of you. Offices putting a few thousand pages a month through this machine belong on the TN850: about 8,000 pages per cartridge, the lower cost per page, and swaps measured in months. The TN820 is the right buy where the MFC-L5800DW is a secondary device — a few hundred pages a month makes the high-yield cartridge's advantage theoretical. Either way, hold one spare; a shared all-in-one with an empty cartridge blocks copying and faxing too, not just printing. The DR820 drum runs on its own count — about 30,000 pages for short-job offices — and arrives in the listings below whenever its turn comes.
Chip, toner and everyday use
Yield ratings for both cartridges assume about 5% page coverage, the density of an ordinary letter or form. Copying dark originals and printing dense documents will use toner faster; the chip in each cartridge tracks the real consumption and reports it to the machine, so trust the gauge over the calendar. A cartridge nearing empty often prints a few faded pages before it stops — that is toner distribution, not a machine fault; a gentle rock of the cartridge levels what remains. Fit spares promptly when the machine asks, and keep unopened cartridges away from radiators and sunny shelves.
Frequently Asked Questions
TN820 or TN850 — how do I choose for the MFC-L5800DW?
By volume. The TN850, at about 8,000 pages, is the economical default for a machine in daily shared use. The TN820, at about 3,000 pages, costs less per box and makes sense where this all-in-one is a light-duty or backup device.
Is the drum a separate purchase on this model?
Yes. The DR820 drum unit is separate from both toner cartridges and is rated at about 30,000 pages — up to about 50,000 for longer documents. It is listed here in compatible and genuine versions, singly and in multipacks.
What warranty covers the compatible cartridges?
The compatible listings on this page carry a 1-year warranty and 1-year returns. The genuine Brother cartridges and drum are covered by Brother's own warranty.
Which cartridge gives the lowest cost per page here?
The TN850. Its roughly 8,000-page rating spreads the cartridge cost over more than two and a half times the pages of the standard TN820 — the reason it is the default recommendation for this machine's heavier users.
More printers that use the same cartridges
This model's cartridges are shared across the family — here is the whole list: HL printers: HL-5100, HL-5130, HL-5140, HL-5140LT, HL-5150, HL-5150D, HL-5150DLT, HL-5170, HL-5170D, HL-5170DLT, HL-5170DN, HL-5170DNLT, HL-5170N, HL-L5000, HL-L5000D, HL-L5100, HL-L5100DN, HL-L5200, HL-L5200DW, HL-L5200DWT, HL-L6200, HL-L6200DW, HL-L6200DWT, HL-L6250, HL-L6250 DN, HL-L6250DW, HL-L6300, HL-L6300 T, HL-L6300DW, HL-L6400, HL-L6400DW, HL-L6400DWG, HL-L6400DWT, HL-L6400DWX MFC all-in-ones: MFC-8120, MFC-8120NCH, MFC-8220, MFC-8220N, MFC-8440, MFC-8440D, MFC-8440DN, MFC-8640, MFC-8640D, MFC-8840, MFC-8840D, MFC-8840DN, MFC-8840DTN, MFC-L5700, MFC-L5700DN, MFC-L5700DW, MFC-L5750DW, MFC-L5800, MFC-L5850, MFC-L5850DW, MFC-L5900, MFC-L5900DW, MFC-L6700, MFC-L6700DW, MFC-L6750, MFC-L6750DW, MFC-L6800, MFC-L6800DW, MFC-L6900, MFC-L6900DW, MFC-L6900DWG, MFC-L6900DWX DCP models: DCP-8040, DCP-8040D, DCP-8045, DCP-8045D, DCP-8045DN, DCP-L5500, DCP-L5500DN, DCP-L5600, DCP-L5600DN, DCP-L5650, DCP-L5650DN, DCP-L6600 Cartridge code pages: Brother-TN570, Brother-TN820, Brother-TN850, Brother-TN880
