Some toner families need a detective. This one needs a calculator. The Color LaserJet 5500 and 5550 workgroup printers run on exactly four cartridges — C9730A black, C9731A cyan, C9732A yellow, C9733A magenta — all wearing the single badge 645A. HP never built a high-yield sibling for any of them, so there is no X tier to hunt for, no standard tier to confuse it with, and nothing on this shelf belongs to another family. Eight offers cover the whole range: a four-color set, a colors-only set, four singles priced to the cent identically, and two packs of black. The yields need no arbitration either — the listings say 13,000 pages for black and 12,000 for each color, and HP’s own published figures say precisely the same. What follows is the arithmetic of a big, honest platform: what each box costs, what each page costs, and how far the compatible shelf sits below the $2,443.96 that HP charges for the same four cartridges bought one at a time.
Start with the four-color set at $531.23: it undercuts the four singles bought separately by $48.25 and works out to 1.08¢ for each of its 49,000 rated pages. When only the color side is spent, the tri-color set at $402.44 does the same job for three stations and saves $32.17. Singles hold the family’s signature — $144.87 at every station, no exceptions — and the black packs shave the black page from 1.11¢ down to 1.03¢. Against all of it stands the genuine shelf: HP lists the black at $469.99 and each color at $657.99, so a full genuine change totals $2,443.96, and HP offers no genuine set to soften that. Nothing here carries a warning label, because nothing here earned one.
Eight offers, one tier, nothing to decode
The shelf runs in the order a workgroup actually buys: the complete four-cartridge change first, then the colors as a set of their own, the four singles in code order, and black by the pack at the end for the mono-heavy machines. Every composition below is stated outright on its own listing — counted cartridges, named codes — so each saving is measured against a box whose contents are not in question. Ratings are the agreed ones: about 13,000 pages from the C9730A black and about 12,000 from each of the three colors, the figures the store’s listings and HP’s data hold in common.
Set this beside the genuine alternative and the family’s economics come into focus: HP’s four singles total $2,443.96, so this one carton lands at a little over a fifth of the genuine bill while covering the same four stations for the same rated pages.
Shop the 4-Color Set →THE REMAINING SEVEN OFFERS
The complete color side in a single box, black deliberately left out for machines whose C9730A still has ground to cover. Bundling the trio trims $32.17 off the three singles and pulls the color page down from 1.21¢ to 1.12¢.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
The hardest-working cartridge in the family and the unit both black packs are built from. Its 13,000-page rating is the highest of the four, yet the price is the family’s shared $144.87 — the black station charges no premium for its extra thousand pages.
Shop the Black Single →
Cyan on its own terms — which happen to be the same terms as everything else here: $144.87, roughly 12,000 rated pages. Set against HP’s $657.99 genuine cyan, the single is where the compatible shelf’s advantage is widest in dollars per cartridge.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Yellow, singly — $144.87 and about 12,000 rated pages, matching its cyan and magenta neighbors to the cent and to the page rating. There is no station on this shelf where the refill arithmetic changes.
Shop the Yellow Single →
The magenta cartridge, completing a row of four singles that share one price without sharing one rating — black carries a thousand extra pages at the same money. Whichever station runs dry, the replacement decision is the same $144.87.
Shop the Magenta Single →
One black working, one black waiting: the pair lands $16.08 under two singles and eases the black page from 1.11¢ to 1.05¢. For a machine that prints documents far more than pictures, it is the natural restock rhythm.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →
Three blacks in one order, $32.17 below the three singles — and the bottom rung of the family’s ladder, holding the cheapest page this guide can quote at 1.03¢. Roughly 39,000 pages of black between orders.
Shop the 3 Black Pack →Read the row of singles again, because it is the family in miniature: four cartridges, four different jobs, one price. Parity like that removes a whole layer of shopping friction — no station is the expensive one, no color is penalized, and a budget drawn up for one refill holds for all of them. The sets then do the only other thing a shelf can do: reward the buyer who takes more than one cartridge home at a time.
Every figure on this page is built from sale prices, the amounts actually charged at checkout. That basis matters here because the listings’ own texts sometimes quote their higher list prices in passing; where a number on a product page differs from its counterpart here, the closing note explains the ground rules used throughout.
All eight offers, one table
Ratings come from the standard test method, so read them as planning figures rather than guarantees: heavy coverage empties a cartridge sooner, light coverage later. Each box’s page total is the sum of its cartridges’ ratings, and each rate is the sale price divided by that total. There is no fit column, because all eight rows serve the same ten machines listed further down.
| Offer | Sale price | What is in the box | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 645A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $531.23 | Black, cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~49,000 pages | 1.08¢ blended | SAVE $48.25 |
| 645A Tri-Color Set | $402.44 | Cyan, yellow and magenta · ~36,000 pages | 1.12¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
| 645A Black Single (C9730A) | $144.87 | 1 black · ~13,000 pages | 1.11¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 645A Cyan Single (C9731A) | $144.87 | 1 cyan · ~12,000 pages | 1.21¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 645A Yellow Single (C9732A) | $144.87 | 1 yellow · ~12,000 pages | 1.21¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 645A Magenta Single (C9733A) | $144.87 | 1 magenta · ~12,000 pages | 1.21¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 645A 2 Black Pack | $273.66 | 2 black · ~26,000 pages | 1.05¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 645A 3 Black Pack | $402.44 | 3 black · ~39,000 pages | 1.03¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
Eight rows is the whole table — there is no second tier hiding below it and no alternate listing repeating a row at a different price. Note where the rates cluster: everything on the shelf lives between 1.03¢ and 1.21¢ a page, a spread of less than a fifth of a cent from the cheapest black pack to a lone color single.
What a page costs, and what a genuine page costs
Black is the cheaper page in this family despite the shared price tag, because the C9730A carries a thousand more pages than its color siblings: 1.11¢ as a single, 1.05¢ from the two-pack, 1.03¢ from the three-pack. A lone color page runs 1.21¢, and the tri-color set brings it to 1.12¢. A full four-station change from the flagship set blends to 1.08¢. In monthly terms, 10,000 black pages cost about $111 in singles and about $103 from the three-pack; 10,000 color pages cost about $121 as singles and about $112 through the tri-color set.
The genuine shelf runs the same arithmetic at very different altitude. HP’s black single, $469.99 for the same rated 13,000 pages, works out near 3.62¢ a page; each genuine color, $657.99 for 12,000 pages, sits near 5.48¢. So a page printed with genuine cartridges costs roughly three to four and a half times its compatible counterpart — and since HP sells no genuine four-pack, there is no genuine bundle that narrows the gap the way the flagship set narrows it here.
Scale the comparison up to a workgroup year and it stops being a per-page curiosity. A hundred thousand black pages run about $1,030 from the three-black pack against roughly $3,620 on genuine singles; a hundred thousand color pages run about $1,120 through the tri-color set against roughly $5,480 genuine. Machines of this class routinely print at that scale, which is why the family’s flat, agreed arithmetic matters: the saving is not a rounding difference on one cartridge but a multiple on every page the printer will ever produce.
One set of yield figures, agreed by everyone
Guide math usually has to pick a side, because a listing’s declared yield and the manufacturer’s current figure so often drift apart. Not here. The C9730A black is rated at roughly 13,000 pages and each color at roughly 12,000 under ISO/IEC 19798 — in the listings’ descriptive text, in their structured page-yield fields, and in HP’s own published data alike. No listing disagrees with its siblings, no field disagrees with its text, and HP’s present-day figures are the same ones the family launched with. The wholesaler’s numbers and the manufacturer’s numbers are one set of numbers, so every rate on this page stands on both.
The machines also start at full strength. HP’s 5550 series datasheet lists the box contents as the printer plus cyan, magenta, yellow and black print cartridges, and rates those cartridges in the same document at the full ~13,000 and ~12,000 pages — no introductory or starter qualifier appears anywhere. A new owner’s first replacement was therefore a full-size cartridge from day one, and the per-page figures above describe the machine’s whole working life, not a cheaper second act.
Genuine pricing, for once, is quotable in full: unlike some older families whose codes HP has delisted, all four 645A cartridges remain listed and in stock at HP’s US store — the black at $469.99 and each color at $657.99, $2,443.96 for a complete set of singles. What HP does not sell is a genuine four-pack; the set discount exists only on the compatible side of the shelf.
There is no second cartridge to budget for. Each 645A cartridge is an all-in-one unit — the imaging drum is built into it, so a toner change is a drum change as well. The platform’s remaining consumables are an image transfer kit and fuser kits — service parts, not shelf items — and no drum is stocked or sold for these printers.
Ten workgroup printers, one shared shelf
HP built this platform in two generations — the 5500 series from 2002 and the 5550 series from 2004 — and five equipment levels in each, from the base machine through networked and duplex variants up to the fully fitted hdn. All ten take all four cartridges; there are no model-specific restrictions anywhere in the family.
The 5500 generation: the Color LaserJet 5500, Color LaserJet 5500n, Color LaserJet 5500dn, Color LaserJet 5500dtn and Color LaserJet 5500hdn. The 5550 generation: the Color LaserJet 5550, Color LaserJet 5550n, Color LaserJet 5550dn, Color LaserJet 5550dtn and Color LaserJet 5550hdn.
Any of those ten names on the front panel means the eight offers above belong to that machine — every one of them. And if the panel cannot be seen, the cartridge that slides out settles the question: C9730A, C9731A, C9732A or C9733A belongs to this family alone.
Chips: the subject this family never raises
Across all forty-one listings in this family — names and full texts alike — the word “chip” does not appear once. The listings describe cartridges working with HP’s smart printing system technology, and that is the extent of the electronics talk. There is no chip claim on this shelf to repeat, so this guide repeats none.
HP’s side is equally quiet, and for a structural reason: the 5500 and 5550 date from 2002 and 2004, long before dynamic security existed, and HP’s current pages for these four cartridges carry no dynamic-security language. The era’s user guide does note that the printer authenticates its cartridges automatically — a recognition step from the platform’s own time, not a blocking statement. The practical ground for a buyer is the same as it is everywhere in this store: the warranty and returns cover spelled out in the next band.
What stands behind every cartridge here
Choosing by the way the machine is used
Questions the 5500 and 5550 platform raises
No. HP made this family in a single tier — the four 645A cartridges are the whole lineup, and no C9730X through C9733X exists at HP or in this store. The ratings are simply large to begin with: about 13,000 pages for black and 12,000 for each color.
Yes — $144.87 at every station, black included, verified on each product’s own page. The parity is exact, so the only difference between the singles is the work they do: the black carries roughly a thousand more rated pages than each color.
Ten: the Color LaserJet 5500, 5500n, 5500dn, 5500dtn and 5500hdn, and the Color LaserJet 5550, 5550n, 5550dn, 5550dtn and 5550hdn. All four cartridges fit all ten models, with no model-specific exceptions.
Full-size ones. HP’s datasheet for the series lists standard black, cyan, magenta and yellow print cartridges in the box, rated at the same ~13,000 and ~12,000 pages as the cartridges sold here — there is no smaller introductory cartridge in this platform’s life.
No. Drum and toner live inside the same all-in-one cartridge on this platform, so swapping the cartridge swaps the drum too. The platform’s remaining consumables are transfer and fuser kits — service parts, not shelf items.
The platform predates HP’s dynamic-security era by well over a decade, and HP publishes no dynamic-security language for these cartridges. The listings themselves never mention a chip at all. What backs the purchase is the store’s cover: a year of warranty and free returns for the same twelve months.
It is covered by the store’s compatible terms — twelve months of warranty, free returns throughout that year, and weekday support from 9 AM to 5 PM Central to arrange the exchange. Hold on to the carton until the replacement is printing cleanly.
