Thirteen Enterprise machines stand behind this family — five print-only LaserJets and eight multifunctions — and one black cartridge platform serves them all, wound at three yields: the 147A (W1470A) at about 10,500 pages, the 147X (W1470X) at about 25,200, and the 147Y (W1470Y) at about 42,000. Unusually, all three tiers are stocked here as compatibles, each sold three ways — single, 2-pack and 4-pack — and all nine listings were on sale when this page was prepared, so the figures below are sale figures throughout, each divided out of the price a buyer actually pays at checkout, not out of the higher list prices the product pages do their sums from. One finding up front, because it runs against instinct: the biggest cartridge on this shelf is not the cheapest page on it. The Y tier earns its place a different way, and the tier section shows the arithmetic.
If your machine is one of HP’s thirteen — the LaserJet Enterprise M610dn, M611dn, M611x, M612dn or M612x printers, or the LaserJet Enterprise MFP M634dn, M634h, M634z, M635h, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M635fht, Flow MFP M635z, M636fh or Flow MFP M636z multifunctions — the nine compatibles below are the whole of its shelf in this store; no genuine HP 147 cartridge is stocked here. Leading the page is the 147X 2-pack at $165.09: near the family’s cheapest pages, bought two cartridges at a time so a spare is always on site. The deepest page rate sits in the 147X 4-pack at $314.10. The 147A line, opening at $75.68, covers machines whose volume is modest, and the 147Y line — built around a 42,000-page cartridge — is here for machines whose real cost is the swap itself; it is priced honestly below, per page and per interval. Ahead: the nine offers in a table, the three yields taken apart, the cartridge the printer shipped with, the roster taken model by model, and a chip section that starts from a plain fact — not one of the nine product pages mentions a chip.
The high-yield pair leads; volume and interval place the other seven
Fit is not the contest here — HP rates all three cartridges across the whole roster — so the order below is set by two measures: what a page costs, and how often someone has to open the machine. The 147X pair wins the first measure nearly outright and keeps a spare in the building, which is why it leads. The same cartridge’s four-box follows, for fleets that reorder by the quarter. Then comes the long-run tier, three Y offers bought for interval rather than economy, and the standard-yield trio brings up the rear, sized for the machines that print least.
Against HP’s own shelf the contrast is blunt: two genuine 147X cartridges total $817.98 at HP’s store. This pair does the same rated work for $165.09 — $652.89 less on a single order.
Shop the 147X 2-Pack →THE REST OF THE SHELF — THE HIGH-YIELD LINE COMPLETED, THEN THE LONG-RUN TIER, THEN THE STANDARD LINE
The high-yield cartridge on its own, for a machine restocked only as it empties. Against HP’s $408.99 for the genuine article, the compatible single is $90.58 at its sale price — and at 0.36¢, its page is the cheapest single-cartridge page on the shelf.
Shop the 147X Single →
The lowest page rate on the shelf, with cartridges at $78.53 apiece. Worth pausing on: the whole box — four cartridges, roughly 100,800 rated pages — costs $94.89 less than a single genuine 147X at HP.
Shop the 147X 4-Pack →
Bought for interval, not economy: its page costs more than the 147X’s, and what the premium buys is time — about 42,000 pages between swaps. HP charges $555.99 for the genuine cartridge of this rating.
Shop the 147Y Single →
Two long-run cartridges at $209.38 each: roughly 84,000 rated pages under one order, for the machine that must not stop. The pair trims the Y page rate to 0.50¢ — still above every 147X figure, as the table shows.
Shop the 147Y 2-Pack →
The deepest box: four cartridges at $205.36 apiece and about 168,000 rated pages — a year of heavy printing for some fleets, bought in one order and swapped only four times.
Shop the 147Y 4-Pack →
The smallest outlay on the shelf, sized for the Enterprise machine that idles more than it works. The genuine cartridge of this rating costs $256.99 at HP; the compatible is $75.68 at its sale price.
Shop the 147A Single →
Two standard cartridges at $67.65 each, totalling about 21,000 rated pages — close to a single 147X’s rating, delivered across two swaps instead of one.
Shop the 147A 2-Pack →
The standard line’s deepest box holds four cartridges at $63.62 apiece, and the 147A’s best page rate. Its rated total equals one 147Y cartridge — the same pages, four swaps against one, for $37.07 more; the tier section takes that trade apart.
Shop the 147A 4-Pack →Nine offers for one cartridge slot looks like abundance until the two buying habits behind them are separated. One habit restocks on failure: the machine stops, a cartridge is needed today, and the single answers. The other restocks on schedule: a quarter’s volume is estimated, the order is placed once, and the packs answer — with a lower page rate and a warranty that runs per cartridge, so the last unit out of the box is covered like the first. Both shapes stay on the shelf because real stockrooms run both habits.
One caution: the figures are sale figures, not resting ones. Every listing on this shelf is currently marked down — each one priced about thirteen percent under its list price — while the product pages still run their own per-page sums from the list figures, which is why their cents-per-page numbers read higher than this page’s. Everything below is divided out of the sale prices — the amounts a buyer actually pays at checkout for as long as the markdown lasts.
Nine offers at sale prices — the table
Every yield quoted here is HP’s rating for the cartridge, on the basis HP prints for this family: an approximate average yield under ISO/IEC 19752, with actual output varying with what the pages carry. Pack totals are arithmetic, not fresh ratings: a 4-pack simply carries four cartridges’ worth of its tier’s figure. The per-page column divides each sale price by the pages that price buys, and flags the pack rows “blended”, since a pack’s rate averages its cartridges.
| Offer | Fits | Sale price | Rating per cartridge | Cost per page | Against the singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 147X 2-Pack — the flagship | All thirteen models | $165.09 | Up to ~25,200 pages each | 0.33¢ blended | SAVE $16.07 |
| 147X Single | All thirteen models | $90.58 | Up to ~25,200 pages | 0.36¢ | The high-yield slot, singly |
| 147X 4-Pack | All thirteen models | $314.10 | Up to ~25,200 pages each | 0.31¢ blended | SAVE $48.22 |
| 147Y Single | All thirteen models | $217.42 | Up to ~42,000 pages | 0.52¢ | The interval slot, singly |
| 147Y 2-Pack | All thirteen models | $418.76 | Up to ~42,000 pages each | 0.50¢ blended | SAVE $16.08 |
| 147Y 4-Pack | All thirteen models | $821.44 | Up to ~42,000 pages each | 0.49¢ blended | SAVE $48.24 |
| 147A Single | All thirteen models | $75.68 | Up to ~10,500 pages | 0.72¢ | The entry point |
| 147A 2-Pack | All thirteen models | $135.29 | Up to ~10,500 pages each | 0.64¢ blended | SAVE $16.07 |
| 147A 4-Pack | All thirteen models | $254.49 | Up to ~10,500 pages each | 0.61¢ blended | SAVE $48.23 |
Read down the per-page column and the shelf sorts itself into three bands. The 147X band runs lowest — 0.36¢, 0.33¢, 0.31¢ from single to four-pack. The 147Y band sits in the middle — 0.52¢, 0.50¢, 0.49¢ — above every X figure despite carrying the family’s largest cartridges. The 147A band runs highest, 0.72¢ down to 0.61¢, which is the ordinary price of small fills bought in small boxes. One crossover deserves its own sentence: the 147A 4-pack and the 147Y single promise the same roughly 42,000 rated pages, and they sit $37.07 apart — four swaps against one, at $37.07 more for the box; which side of that trade suits a machine depends on who has to open it, and how often they mind doing so.
Three yields — and the biggest is not the cheapest
The slot in every machine on the roster takes any of the three fills without adjustment. The standard cartridge, the 147A (W1470A), is rated at about 10,500 pages. The high-yield cartridge, the 147X (W1470X), more than doubles that to about 25,200 in the same housing. The extra-high cartridge, the 147Y (W1470Y), stretches the same housing to about 42,000 — four standard fills’ worth of pages in a single unit.
Here is where this family’s arithmetic surprises. Stepping up in size does not step down in page cost all the way. The move from A to X behaves as buyers expect: $14.90 more per single buys about 14,700 extra rated pages, and the page rate falls from 0.72¢ to 0.36¢ — it halves. The move from X to Y reverses the direction: the Y single costs $126.84 more than the X single, carries about 16,800 extra rated pages, and yet its page prices at 0.52¢ against the X’s 0.36¢. The biggest cartridge is the most expensive way to buy a page on this shelf. What the Y premium actually purchases is interval: one swap where the X needs nearly two and the A needs four — on a machine printing ten thousand pages a month, one change every four months or so, against one every ten weeks on the X and one a month on the A.
Set against HP’s own prices, all three tiers sit far underneath: HP’s US store asks $256.99 for the genuine 147A, $408.99 for the genuine 147X and $555.99 for the genuine 147Y, leaving the compatible singles cheaper by $181.31, $318.41 and $338.57 respectively at today’s sale prices. One figure concentrates the point: the compatible 147X 4-pack — four cartridges, roughly 100,800 rated pages — costs $314.10, which is $94.89 less than HP asks for one genuine 147X.
No shortened starter hides in this family’s box
A shortened starter cartridge is the usual Enterprise welcome. Not here. HP’s own page for the M610dn states what the box contains — an original black cartridge rated at about 10,500 pages — and its specification for setup and in-box cartridges repeats the same figure; the M611dn’s page agrees. The cartridge these printers ship with is a complete 147A rating, not a fraction of one.
The consequence is that this page’s arithmetic runs from day one. The first replacement decision arrives only after a full 10,500-page run — time enough for a machine’s true monthly volume to declare itself in the page counter, which is exactly the evidence the A-versus-X-versus-Y choice should be made on.
The figure still carries the standard caution: it is a rating under standard coverage, and a first cartridge partly spent on setup, calibration and dense early work will fall short of it in impressions. Short by circumstance, perhaps — never short by design.
The listings say nothing about chips — this page says exactly that much
Read the nine listings on this shelf from top to bottom and a word is missing entirely: chip. No listing states that a chip is fitted, none describes moving one across from the spent cartridge, and none says anything about firmware at all. This guide will not borrow another family’s language to fill that gap: the absence is reported as found.
The omission is worth dwelling on because HP is not silent about these machines. In HP’s own framing, the M610 and M611 lines are dynamic-security printers: HP’s pages for them state that they are intended to work only with cartridges carrying a new or reused HP chip, and that dynamic security measures are used against cartridges that do not. Owners who want this family’s chip position followed properly can find the W1470 family covered on our HP monochrome toner chip compatibility page, which tracks cartridges and firmware across the whole monochrome range.
What a buyer here actually holds, in the listings’ own terms, is not a chip statement but cover. Each cartridge is warranted for a year — in the packs the year runs cartridge by cartridge, so a spare fitted months later is still inside it — and returns are free for a year. A cartridge the printer refuses, or one that fails early, goes through that warranty-and-returns process; support answers Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central. Nothing beyond that is promised on this point, and nothing beyond it is printed here.
Thirteen Enterprise models, one black cartridge
HP’s documents name thirteen models — the W1470A datasheet states compatibility at series level for the M610, M611 and M612 printers and the M634, M635 and M636 multifunctions, the MFP user guide’s model table fills in each machine, and HP’s printer pages list all three cartridges, W1470A, W1470X and W1470Y, as the replacements across the line. What separates the thirteen is machine hardware — speed, trays, finishing, scanning, fax — never the cartridge, which stays one shared platform across the thirteen.
The print-only five: LaserJet Enterprise M610dn, LaserJet Enterprise M611dn, LaserJet Enterprise M611x, LaserJet Enterprise M612dn and LaserJet Enterprise M612x.
The multifunction eight: LaserJet Enterprise MFP M634dn, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M634h, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M634z, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M635h, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M635fht, LaserJet Enterprise Flow MFP M635z, LaserJet Enterprise MFP M636fh and LaserJet Enterprise Flow MFP M636z.
One roster note, made plainly: two of the thirteen — the M634dn and the M635fht — stand in HP’s user-guide model table, but this store keeps no category page for either, so they are named above without links. The other eleven link to their model pages. However you arrive — by the name on the machine’s badge, or by the code on the cartridge you just pulled — the shelf you land on is the same nine offers.
The terms behind every listing
Five checks before ordering for a fleet machine
Questions this family raises
Not on this shelf. As singles, the 147Y costs $217.42 against the 147X’s $90.58, and while it carries about 16,800 more rated pages, its page works out at 0.52¢ against the X’s 0.36¢. The Y is not an economy cartridge; it is an interval cartridge. Its premium buys about 42,000 pages between swaps — one change where the X needs nearly two — and for a machine whose downtime costs more than its toner, that is the right purchase. For every other machine, the X is where the money is.
Because most machines live in two states — printing, or waiting on a cartridge — and the pair covers both: one unit in the machine, its successor on site. It carries the high-yield rating at $82.55 a cartridge, and puts roughly 50,400 rated pages under one order at $165.09. The 147X 4-pack takes the page rate a little lower — 0.31¢ against 0.33¢ — and suits fleets that buy by the quarter, but it asks $314.10 today. The pair is the balance point; the four-box is for stockrooms that buy by the quarter.
It should put you on notice, which is not the same as putting you off. Across all nine listings there is no chip statement of any kind — nothing about one being fitted, nothing about transfer, nothing promised on firmware — and this guide reports that silence instead of decorating it. In HP’s own description these are dynamic-security machines, so the subject is a live one for this family; the store follows the W1470 position on its HP monochrome chip compatibility page. What the listings commit to instead is the remedy if a cartridge fails or is refused: a year’s warranty and a year of free returns behind every offer on the shelf.
Because the two sets of sums begin from different prices. The listings divide by their list prices — $104.17 for the 147X single, for instance. Every listing is currently on sale, though, and this guide divides by the sale prices checkout charges: $90.58 for that single, which is where its 0.36¢ comes from. When the markdown ends, the listings’ arithmetic becomes the true one again — the price on the product page governs, as the note below explains.
The listings answer with a process rather than a workaround. A failed or refused cartridge goes back under the 1-year warranty, 1-year free returns stand behind the order, and support is there on Central hours — 9 to 5, Monday to Friday. Pack buyers hold the same cover on every unit: the warranty runs cartridge by cartridge, so the spare fitted in spring is covered exactly as the first was in winter. Hold on to the packaging until the cartridge has printed cleanly — returns travel better in it.
