null

0

Your cart is empty

Best HP 38A (Q1338A) Toner Cartridges

BUYING GUIDE CLEVER SUPPLIES · HP 38A · LASERJET 4200 WORKGROUP LASERJETS
Best HP 38A (Q1338A) Toner Cartridges

The LaserJet 4200 series was built for departments, not desksides — shared machines with duty cycles to match — and HP gave the whole series a single supply: the Q1338A, a 12,000-page cartridge sold here in boxes of one through five. There is no second size to graduate to and no high-yield sibling hiding in HP’s catalog; the only puzzle on this shelf is that the five-pack appears twice, under two names, at one identical price, drawing on one shared stock figure. This guide cards the plain listing, explains the twin in the open, and prices all five counts at the sale figures the register actually charges.

0.302¢ a page
The five-pack’s pooled rate over its 60,000 rated pages — the least expensive buyable page on this shelf
$181.48
Five cartridges at the sale price — $64.32 less than five singles bought one by one
12,000 pages
One rating for the cartridge, printed identically by HP’s user guide, the spec fields and the descriptions
9 printers
HP’s full LaserJet 4200 roster — some of the listings name as few as four of them
THE SHORT ANSWER

Start from what HP actually made: one cartridge, in one size, for one printer series. Every box on this page holds the Q1338A and nothing else, so the choice in front of a 4200 owner is a quantity, never a tier. Bought five at a time the cartridge runs 0.302¢ a page and undercuts five singles by $64.32; bought singly it costs $49.16 and 0.410¢ a page. The five-pack’s shelf twin — a second listing at the same price wearing a “Premium Quality” name — is handled in the panel next to the flagship rather than on a card of its own, because its own text claims no difference in specification, rating or terms. And because HP has discontinued the cartridge, no genuine price stands in this guide: there is no HP store figure to set beside the compatibles, and none is borrowed from elsewhere.

The five-pack, taken once

Sixty thousand rated pages is a departmental commitment, and the five-pack is where this family’s arithmetic bottoms out. Five singles at the sale price add up to $245.80; the box is $181.48; the $64.32 gap between those two numbers is the widest saving on the shelf. Divided across the pooled rating, a page costs 0.302¢ — against 0.410¢ for the cartridge bought alone. The card below is the plain listing; the panel beside it accounts for the box’s double.

★ THE FLAGSHIP · FIVE CARTRIDGES, ~60,000 RATED PAGES POOLED — SAVE $64.32 VS FIVE SINGLES
CS Compatible Replacement for HP Q1338A Toner Cartridge Black 5 Pack/ HP 38A Toner
Compatible HP Q1338A Toner Cartridges — Black, 5 Pack (38A)
Q1338A five times over · 12,000 rated pages a cartridge · the LaserJet 4200 workgroup family
$181.48
✓  Five Q1338A cartridges pooling roughly 60,000 rated pages — 0.302¢ a page, the lowest rate orderable in this family
✓  Five singles at $49.16 total $245.80; the box holds on to $64.32 of that
✓  Each cartridge is rated 12,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19752 — the only yield figure HP ever published for this platform

A five-pack suits a shared 4200 that prints through a cartridge in weeks rather than seasons, or a small fleet of them drawing on one supply shelf. Each unit stays sealed until its turn comes, and because the imaging drum is built into the cartridge itself, every change starts the new unit with a fresh drum surface as well as a full toner supply. For a machine whose low-toner light is a departmental event rather than a private errand, that depth is precisely the point.

Shop the 38A 5-Pack →
THE SECOND FIVE-PACK: ONE BOX, TWO LISTINGS
The same five-pack, wearing a “Premium Quality” name
An identical price · an identical stock figure · no claimed difference · set out in full
✓  The twin sells on the identical block — same list figure, same $181.48 at sale; not a cent separates the two listings
✓  Both listings read the same inventory, 44 — one pool of stock counted twice, once under each name
✓  Its own text claims no difference in specification, rating or terms; it frames “Premium Quality” as a line name, for buyers who reorder by the name printed on the box
✓  The store’s own records point the other way from usual: the Premium copy is filed as the primary listing and this plain one as the duplicate
✓  Nothing is lost by choosing either page at the register — but only one card is needed to say so, and it belongs to the plain listing

A duplicated box is not a deception in itself; the prices match, and the cartridge inside is the same. What it costs a buyer is clarity — two pages to compare that were never different. This guide therefore cards the standard listing and leaves the twin here, described in full and linked from nowhere.

Four more counts of the same cartridge

Below the flagship the ladder descends in even steps: 0.309¢ a page for the four-pack, 0.320¢ for the three-pack, 0.343¢ for the two-pack and 0.410¢ for the single, and every pack beats its own count of singles — by $48.24, $32.16 and $16.08 on the way down. The cartridge does not change as the boxes shrink; code, rating and all-in-one construction are constant from the single to the five-pack. What changes is only how often the supply shelf needs restocking, and how much cash sits on it in the meantime.

Two of the counts carry catalog quirks worth knowing before the cards. The four-pack is a genuine shelf item with a genuine card below, yet it is filed in the store’s color LaserJet tree and appears in neither the family category nor any monochrome model category — a buyer browsing the 4200 pages the ordinary way would never meet it. And the five-pack, as the panel above sets out, exists twice; the card in the flagship position belongs to the plain listing, and the “Premium Quality” copy is covered in words only.

THE REMAINING COUNTS

SAVE $48.24 VS FOUR SINGLES
Compatible HP 38A (Q1338A) Toner Cartridge 4 Black
38A 4-Pack · Q1338A
▦ Four cartridges · ~48,000 rated pages pooled · 0.309¢ a page · nine roster models
$148.40

The count the catalog nearly hides: filed among the color cartridges, absent from the family category and from every monochrome model page, yet a regular buyable box once found. Four singles would cost $196.64, so the pack keeps $48.24, and its pooled 48,000 rated pages price out at 0.309¢ apiece — within a whisker of the flagship’s rate.

Shop the 38A 4-Pack →
SAVE $32.16 VS THREE SINGLES
CS Compatible Replacement for HP Q1338A Toner Cartridge Black 3 Pack/ HP 38A Toner
38A 3-Pack · Q1338A
▦ Three cartridges · ~36,000 rated pages pooled · 0.320¢ a page · nine roster models
$115.32

A working quarter for a busy department in one box: roughly 36,000 pooled rated pages at 0.320¢ a page. Three singles total $147.48, so the pack saves $32.16 — and with the drum renewed at every change, the last cartridge in the box prints on as fresh a surface as the first.

Shop the 38A 3-Pack →
SAVE $16.08 VS TWO SINGLES
CS Compatible Replacement for HP Q1338A Toner Cartridge Black 2 Pack/ HP 38A Toner
38A 2-Pack · Q1338A
▦ Two cartridges · ~24,000 rated pages pooled · 0.343¢ a page · nine roster models
$82.24

One cartridge in the machine and its successor already on the shelf: about 24,000 pooled rated pages at 0.343¢ a page. Two singles come to $98.32, so the pair saves $16.08 against buying the spare when the low-toner warning appears.

Shop the 38A 2-Pack →
CS Compatible Replacement for HP Q1338A Toner Cartridge Black/ HP 38A Toner
38A Single · Q1338A
▦ One cartridge · 12,000 rated pages · 0.410¢ a page · nine roster models
$49.16

The measure every badge on this page is taken against: one Q1338A at $49.16, rated 12,000 pages, at the shelf’s highest per-page figure of 0.410¢ and its lowest outlay. For a single 4200 with modest volume — or a first purchase before committing to depth — it is the whole decision in one box.

Shop the 38A Single →

All five counts on a single price basis

Five rows, all compatible: HP has discontinued the Q1338A, so no genuine row can be priced from HP’s own store, and none is invented from a third party. Every price below is the sale figure; pages are HP’s 12,000 per cartridge, pooled across the sealed units in each box:

Configuration Price (sale) Rated pages Cost / page Printer fit
38A 5-Pack — the flagship $181.48 5 cartridges · ~60,000 pages 0.302¢ pooled All 9 models
38A 4-Pack $148.40 4 cartridges · ~48,000 pages 0.309¢ pooled All 9 models
38A 3-Pack $115.32 3 cartridges · ~36,000 pages 0.320¢ pooled All 9 models
38A 2-Pack $82.24 2 cartridges · ~24,000 pages 0.343¢ pooled All 9 models
38A Single $49.16 1 cartridge · 12,000 pages 0.410¢ All 9 models

Read the table from the bottom up. The single sets the family’s unit price — $49.16 for 12,000 rated pages — and every row above it is that same cartridge bought with more commitment and less per-page cost. The whole spread from single to five-pack is about a tenth of a cent a page, which on a 12,000-page cartridge is the difference between paying full rate for a department’s toner and paying roughly three-quarters of it. There is no wrong row here; there is only the question of how deep a stock a shared printer justifies.

Nine LaserJet 4200 models, one cartridge between them

HP’s 4200 series spans base machines, networked variants and the regional L line, and the Q1338A serves every member of it: the 4200, 4200n, 4200tn, 4200dtn, 4200dtns, 4200dtnsl, 4200L, the regional 4200Ln, and the 4200Lvn. Two clarifications belong with the list. The long suffixes are real models, not catalog noise: the 4200dtns and 4200dtnsl stand in HP’s own user guide. And there is no 4200dn in this series — duplexing arrives through the dtn models, so a listing or a memory that offers one is mistaken. In the store’s catalog the family is gathered under the HP Q1338A category.

The roster also explains the shelf’s shape. These are not personal printers: the 4200 line was sold as departmental infrastructure, expected to absorb in a month what a home machine might print in a year, which is why the cartridge carries a 12,000-page rating and why the counts on this page run as deep as five. A single corridor 4200 can consume in a season what a desk printer consumes in its lifetime.

Where the listings err on fit, they err by saying too little. The packs’ shared compatibility prose names seven of the nine models and drops the 4200tn; the five-pack’s twin names only four; several fit answers manage five. The omissions are in the prose, not in the cartridge — HP’s roster is the nine above, and every card on this page fits every one of them, the 4200tn included. A 4200tn owner reading only the packs’ prose could reasonably conclude the cartridge is not for their machine; it is, and the category tree — which files these products under the 4200tn — quietly says so.

Identification is a ten-second job: the cartridge coming out of the printer is marked Q1338A, or 38A in short form, and either marking matches every card here. No other code belongs to this series — a box printed with anything else is not a 4200 supply, whatever its title suggests.

A single rating, repeated without drift

However the question is put — to HP, to the spec fields or to the descriptions — the answer comes back 12,000 pages. HP’s user guide for the 4200 series specifies the Q1338A as its 12,000-page cartridge, measured under ISO/IEC 19752, the yardstick the industry uses for rating monochrome LaserJet yields, and the listings carry the same number in their fields and repeat it in their prose. The per-page arithmetic throughout this page starts from that rating: sale price divided by 12,000, then multiplied out over however many sealed cartridges a box contains.

In working terms, 12,000 rated pages is on the order of twenty-four standard reams of paper from a single cartridge — the reason a department can treat toner as a quarterly decision rather than a weekly errand. Actual yields move with coverage, as they do on any cartridge: dense graphics and heavy pages spend the rating faster, plain text slower. The rating is a planning figure, not a promise, but it is the same planning figure on every page of this family, which is what makes the counts honestly comparable.

Nor is there a larger size to hunt for. HP issued this cartridge at one capacity; the only other form in HP’s own catalog was a dual pack of the same cartridge, the Q1338D, which no listing here sells. A page promising a high-yield 38X or an extended-life variant is describing something HP never manufactured.

The drum question the listings never raise

Search the family’s descriptions for the word “drum” and it does not appear — not once, on any listing. The architecture has to be taken from HP instead, and HP’s design is unambiguous: the Q1338A is a single print cartridge, toner and imaging drum in one unit, replaced together at every change. No separate drum exists for the 4200 series under any other code, so the prices on this page are the platform’s whole consumable cost; there is no second part to budget for, stock or time. It also means a cartridge change is the platform’s complete service event: there is no drum counter to reset and no second consumable quietly aging alongside the toner.

On recognition, these cartridges ship with the current chip generation fitted as standard across the store’s compatible range, and the record behind that is uncomplicated: chip recognition has never given trouble with this supply. Fitting one is a mechanical act: the cartridge slides in, the cover closes, and the machine acknowledges it and reports its level; nothing is salvaged from the spent unit, and no chip changes hands. The limit of that assurance deserves stating plainly — it covers these printers and their firmware in their current state, and says nothing about releases that have not been written yet.

The terms that stand behind the cards

All five carded listings stand behind the same terms, and — worth noting in this catalog — each page states them the same way, with no listing contradicting another. In operative form they are:

✓ 1-Year Warranty
Twelve months of cover against a cartridge that fails in service, on the terms printed on its own product page
✓ 1-Year Free Returns
Returns run for a full year on these compatibles — the wrong count, a retired printer or an unopened box all qualify under the terms on the product page
✓ Weekday Support
The store’s own staff answer on weekdays, 9 AM to 5 PM Central
✓ Four US Warehouses
Stock ships from Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and California — the nearest warehouse to the delivery address handles the order

Matching a count to a department’s appetite

The counts differ in depth, not in kind — every box below holds the same 12,000-page cartridge — so the matching is a question of volume, shelf space and how often a shared machine may be allowed to run dry:

✓A shared 4200 printing through cartridges quickly, or several of them: the five-pack. $181.48 — 0.302¢ a page pooled, $64.32 saved against five singles, and 60,000 rated pages between restocking decisions.
✓Heavy use with a shallower shelf: the four-pack. $148.40 — 0.309¢ a page and $48.24 saved against four singles; the rate nearly matches the flagship’s.
✓A steady departmental rhythm: the three-pack. $115.32 — roughly 36,000 pooled rated pages at 0.320¢, saving $32.16 against three singles.
✓One printer, one spare, no drama: the two-pack. $82.24 — a cartridge working and a cartridge waiting, $16.08 below two singles bought apart.
✓Modest volume or a first order: the single. $49.16 — the shelf’s dearest page at 0.410¢, and the smallest sum committed.
✓You are comparing the two five-pack pages and wondering which is better: neither. Same box, same price, same stock figure; the plain listing holds the card here, and the “Premium Quality” copy is the same offer under a line name.

Questions from LaserJet 4200 owners

Is there a high-yield version of the 38A?

No. HP made the Q1338A at one capacity — 12,000 pages — and published no X or extended-life variant for the 4200 series. The only other form in HP’s catalog was a dual pack of this same cartridge (the Q1338D), which is not sold here. Every box on this page holds the standard cartridge; the packs differ in count, never in what a cartridge yields.

Why does the five-pack appear twice at the same price?

Because the box is listed under two names: a plain listing, which holds the card on this page, and a “Premium Quality” listing at the identical $181.48, reading the identical stock figure of 44. The twin’s own text claims no difference in specification, rating or terms — it presents the phrase as a line name for buyers who reorder by the name on the box. Either page sells the same five cartridges; only one card was needed to say so.

Can I still buy the genuine HP cartridge?

Not from HP. The manufacturer has discontinued the Q1338A, and HP’s US store carries no page with a price for it — which is why this guide prints no genuine figure rather than borrowing one from a third-party seller. What remains buyable, new and under the store’s own one-year terms, is the compatible shelf above. Resale stock of the genuine cartridge does circulate, but its price there is set by individual sellers rather than by HP, and this guide does not quote it.

The pack pages don’t mention the 4200tn. Does this cartridge fit it?

It does. HP’s roster for the Q1338A covers the full 4200 series, 4200tn included, and the store files these products under a 4200tn category. The gap is in the packs’ shared compatibility prose, which names seven of the nine models; the cartridge itself fits all nine, and every card on this page is the same cartridge.

Why do the product pages quote higher prices than this guide?

Because the descriptions do their sums on the list price. Ask one of them what a pack costs, what a single cartridge works out to, or what a printed page runs, and the answer is assembled from the list figure every time; the amount the register actually charges is nowhere in their text. The single’s page-cost answer — “about 0.47 cents” — is exactly that habit at work: charge the $49.16 the register asks and the honest figure is 0.410¢. Here, everything is priced at sale; the list numbers are set out in the closing note, marked as belonging to the descriptions.

Is there a separate drum unit to replace on a 4200?

No — and the listings never mention one, because there is nothing to mention. The Q1338A is an all-in-one print cartridge by HP’s design: the imaging drum and the toner supply share one shell and are swapped out as a unit. No drum exists for this series under a separate code, so when a 4200 starts to fade, the cartridge change is the service — there is no second part to order.

Price and disclosure note: The prices printed above are sale prices, taken from the carded listings on November 18, 2026; where a product page disagrees today, the product page governs. Sale is the basis because sale is what the register charges. The descriptions work from list instead — $56.53 (single), $94.58 (two-pack), $132.62 (three-pack), $170.66 (four-pack), $208.70 (five-pack, both copies) — and no description anywhere quotes the sale figure. Badges compare sale with sale: two singles at $98.32 against the two-pack’s $82.24; three at $147.48 against $115.32; four at $196.64 against $148.40; five at $245.80 against $181.48. No genuine price appears, because HP has withdrawn the Q1338A and publishes no price for it at its US store, and a third-party figure is not substituted. The yield behind every division is 12,000 pages per cartridge — HP’s published rating under ISO/IEC 19752, carried identically by the listings’ fields and their prose. Fit follows HP’s published list: LaserJet 4200, 4200n, 4200tn, 4200dtn, 4200dtns, 4200dtnsl, 4200L, 4200Ln, 4200Lvn. What the catalog itself gets untidy about follows, item by item.

First, the list-price habit detailed above: not one prose price in the family is the figure a buyer is charged, a pattern that runs down to the single’s per-page answer of “about 0.47 cents”, where the sale basis gives 0.410¢. Second, the duplicated five-pack: the box is listed twice on one price block, and both copies read the same stock figure of 44, so one pool of inventory stands behind two pages; the store’s own records, unusually, treat the “Premium Quality” copy as the primary listing and the plain copy as the duplicate — the reverse of the arrangement used elsewhere in this catalog — while the Premium text claims no specification, rating or term the plain listing lacks. The card on this page follows the plain listing. Third, a misfiling: the four-pack is shelved in the store’s color LaserJet tree and is absent from the family category and from every monochrome model category its siblings sit in, so browsing the 4200 pages in the ordinary way never surfaces it; its card above links its own product page directly. Fourth, stock figures that repeat: 229 is read by two listings in the family and 44 by both copies of the five-pack. Fifth, fit under-naming: the packs’ compatibility prose omits the 4200tn, the twin’s fit line names four of the nine roster models, and several fit answers name five — against HP’s nine, which this guide rosters in full. Sixth, the weight fields stand the shelf on its head: a single cartridge is recorded at 6 units, every pack at 2 and the four-pack at 3. Seventh, the series pages above the family are broken in the live store: both the monochrome LaserJet series page and the color LaserJet series page answer with a server error, and neither is linked from this page. The defect classes searched for and not found are recorded as well: no leaked production or prompt text sits in any description; no “Lifetime” warranty language appears — the one-year warranty and returns terms hold consistently and are the terms printed above, while the spec strip’s warranted-against-defects wording is the manufacturer’s boilerplate for its genuine product, not a lifetime promise; no phantom printer is claimed by any listing, and the monochrome category tree contains no invented or garbled model; the yield stands at one figure in fields, in prose and in HP’s own publications alike.

The buyable shelf is carried by five cards, one per distinct product; the five-pack’s second listing is handled in prose, set out where a reader can judge it and never presented as a second offer. Everything claimed above stays inside HP’s roster: nine printers, a single genuine cartridge made in a single size, five counts of it on sale, and no genuine price to print because the manufacturer has withdrawn its own. Underneath stand the family’s own stated terms — one year of warranty, one year of free returns, weekday support from 9 AM to 5 PM Central, and dispatch out of Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and California.