Seven departmental machines — three Color LaserJet Enterprise printers and four enterprise multifunctions — share this one cartridge family. Each of the four stations (black, cyan, yellow, magenta) is served at two depths: the standard 212A, rated by HP at roughly 5,500 pages in black and 4,500 per color, and the high-yield 212X, rated at roughly 13,000 in black and 10,000 per color. The store stocks the family in full: a dozen offers, six in each tier, organized around a set of four, a pair of blacks, and four singles sold on their own. No color is sold in a pack of its own — for colors, capacity beyond a single lives only in the sets. Every offer below is a compatible cartridge, and every one carries a sale price as this guide is published.
Workgroup printers burn black toner far faster than color, and this shelf is built around that habit. A department that prints steadily can restock all four stations with the 212A set at $235.96, a 1.24¢ blended page; a heavier floor steps up to the 212X set at $291.80 and watches the blended rate fall to 0.68¢ across some 43,000 rated pages. Two facts deserve attention before the cards. First, pricing inside a tier is flat — a black cartridge costs precisely what a color costs, although HP rates the black for more pages — so in each tier the black quietly returns the best value. Second, the chip story here runs in opposite directions at once: HP speaks about this platform’s security in unusually blunt terms, while the twelve listings never mention chips at all. Both sides are set out further down, in HP’s own words where they matter.
Two tiers, six shapes apiece — the complete 212 shelf
Enterprise families rarely stay this tidy, but this one does: each tier repeats the same six configurations, so the whole decision collapses into picking a depth and then a shape. Sets come first on the page because replacing all four stations at once is the purchase these printers most often need; black pairs follow, aimed at floors where the black station empties long before the colors stir; singles bring up the rear for single-station calls. Read the flagship first, then its eleven companions.
Assemble the same four stations from HP’s genuine singles and the bill reaches $1,082.96 — $227.99 for the black and $284.99 for each color. Against that basket, this set saves $847.00 at identical published ratings.
Shop the 212A 4-Color Set →THE OTHER ELEVEN OFFERS
The deep shelf in a single box: every station restocked at high yield, carrying well over twice the flagship’s rated pages.
Shop the 212X 4-Color Set →
A pair of standard blacks for the workgroup printer whose black station empties weeks ahead of its colors.
Shop the 212A 2 Black Pack →
Two high-yield blacks — roughly 26,000 rated pages of reports and records, and the lowest per-page figure in the family.
Shop the 212X 2 Black Pack →
The standard black by itself — the same full-size cartridge a new M554 or M578 starts its life on.
Shop the 212A Black Single →
A lone cyan at the flat tier price, for the one station the control panel is calling out.
Shop the 212A Cyan Single →
Yellow on its own — colors here are stocked singly, with any extra depth reserved for the sets.
Shop the 212A Yellow Single →
The magenta station alone, priced exactly like its three companions in the tier.
Shop the 212A Magenta Single →
High-yield black alone: about 13,000 rated pages at 0.65¢ — more than double the standard black’s run for $13.96 more.
Shop the 212X Black Single →
One high-yield cyan — roughly 10,000 rated pages, past two standard cyans’ worth inside a single unit.
Shop the 212X Cyan Single →
High-yield yellow by itself, carrying the one price every 212X single shares.
Shop the 212X Yellow Single →
Magenta in high yield — about 10,000 rated pages before that station asks again.
Shop the 212X Magenta Single →Study the step between tiers for a moment, because it is where this family rewards attention. An X cartridge costs about a fifth more than its A counterpart — $85.01 against $71.05 as singles — yet HP credits it with well over twice the pages: 13,000 against 5,500 in black, 10,000 against 4,500 in each color. The consequence shows up in every row of the table below: there is no slot in which the standard tier wins the per-page contest.
Every figure on this page is worked from sale prices — what the checkout actually charges today. Several of the linked product pages do their own arithmetic from list prices inside their text, which pushes their printed per-page numbers higher; the note closing this guide spells out which basis applies in each place.
All twelve offers, side by side
Ratings in the table are HP’s own, declared under ISO/IEC 19798; real output drifts with page coverage, so treat them as planning figures. A set’s total simply adds the ratings of the cartridges inside it, and its blended rate divides the sale price by that total. Compatibility needs no column — each row below fits each of the seven printers named later on this page, in whichever tier you choose.
| Offer | Price (sale) | Box contents | Cost per page | Saving against singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 212A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $235.96 | One of each station · ~19,000 pages | 1.24¢ blended | SAVE $48.24 |
| 212X 4-Color Set | $291.80 | 1 of each station, high yield · ~43,000 pages | 0.68¢ blended | SAVE $48.24 |
| 212A 2 Black Pack | $126.02 | 2 black · ~11,000 pages | 1.15¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 212X 2 Black Pack | $153.94 | 2 black, high yield · ~26,000 pages | 0.59¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 212A Black Single (W2120A) | $71.05 | 1 black · ~5,500 pages | 1.29¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 212A Cyan Single (W2121A) | $71.05 | 1 cyan · ~4,500 pages | 1.58¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 212A Yellow Single (W2122A) | $71.05 | 1 yellow · ~4,500 pages | 1.58¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 212A Magenta Single (W2123A) | $71.05 | 1 magenta · ~4,500 pages | 1.58¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 212X Black Single (W2120X) | $85.01 | 1 black, high yield · ~13,000 pages | 0.65¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 212X Cyan Single (W2121X) | $85.01 | 1 cyan, high yield · ~10,000 pages | 0.85¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 212X Yellow Single (W2122X) | $85.01 | 1 yellow, high yield · ~10,000 pages | 0.85¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 212X Magenta Single (W2123X) | $85.01 | 1 magenta, high yield · ~10,000 pages | 0.85¢ | Bought one at a time |
Linger on the bottom black row’s neighbor: the 212X 2 Black posts 0.59¢, the family’s floor, from a box containing no color at all — on machines bought for color, the document stream still pays the bills. The sets tell the second story: $55.84 separates the X set from the A set, and that difference buys an extra 24,000 rated pages.
One price for every station — and the bargain it hands to black
Manufacturers usually charge a premium for color, and HP is no exception: its genuine colors sit $57.00 above its genuine black in the standard tier and a striking $137.00 above it in high yield. This store declines to follow. A 212A single costs $71.05 whichever slot it fills, and a 212X single costs $85.01 on the same terms. Set that flat price against HP’s uneven ratings — black outruns each color by 1,000 pages in A and by 3,000 in X — and the black becomes each tier’s value pick almost by accident: 1.29¢ a page against 1.58¢ in A, 0.65¢ against 0.85¢ in X.
In practice, a department’s month splits in two. Document volume rides the black ladder, where the 212X 2 Black drives the rate down to 0.59¢ — comfortably under a cent at rated output. Color volume rides the sets, where blending four stations produces 1.24¢ in A and 0.68¢ in X. Whichever stream dominates your printer, the depth decision matters more than the box decision: every X offer undercuts every A offer per page.
The ratings, the cartridges a new machine starts on, and the bottle in the crate
HP’s published ratings run about 5,500 pages for the 212A black and 4,500 for each 212A color; about 13,000 for the 212X black and 10,000 for each 212X color — color figures being ISO/IEC 19798 composite averages under continuous printing. Treat them as budgeting anchors, not promises: dense graphics will drain a color station early, while plain text runs can outlast the rating. Notably, all twelve listings on this shelf quote HP’s figures exactly, so the product pages and this guide tell one consistent story.
A new M554, M555 or M578 does not start life evenly loaded. HP’s own box-contents lists describe four preinstalled cartridges in which the black is a full retail-size unit at roughly 5,500 pages, while cyan, magenta and yellow arrive as reduced introductory fills of about 3,500 pages composite — short of their 4,500-page retail rating. Expect the colors, not the black, to call for their first replacements. One footnote is worth passing on: HP notes that machines built before 2021 may have shipped with higher-yield color cartridges in the box, so an older unit’s first color change may have come later than this pattern suggests.
There is no drum budget to plan for here: these cartridges are all-in-one units with the drum built in, so a cartridge change renews both at once. The platform’s only other consumable, a toner collection unit that gathers waste toner, arrives inside the crate with the printer. On genuine pricing, HP’s US store lists the 212A black at $227.99 and each color at $284.99; the 212X black at $328.99 and each X color at $465.99 — all in stock when checked. Adding those singles into full sets gives $1,082.96 in A and $1,726.96 in X, against $235.96 and $291.80 for the sets leading this page.
Seven enterprise machines, one cartridge family
HP’s compatibility documents assign this family to seven machines in the Color LaserJet Enterprise range, and the fit could not be simpler: HP’s page for each model names the same eight replacement cartridges, spanning both tiers and all four stations. No printer in the line is confined to the standard tier, and none is shut out of high yield.
The printers: the Color LaserJet Enterprise M554dn, the Color LaserJet Enterprise M555dn and the Color LaserJet Enterprise M555x.
The multifunctions: the Color LaserJet Enterprise Flow MFP M578c, the Color LaserJet Enterprise MFP M578dn, the Color LaserJet Enterprise MFP M578f and the Color LaserJet Enterprise Flow MFP M578z — the same four-cartridge engine, wrapped in scanning, copying and fax hardware.
When a station runs dry, the check that settles everything is the label on the cartridge coming out. Any code from W2120 through W2123, closed by either an A or an X, names a cartridge this page replaces — and the label prints its station color beside the code.
The chip question, answered in HP’s own wording
Start with what HP prints on its own product pages, because it leaves little room for interpretation. The M554dn page carries this disclaimer word for word: “Dynamic security enabled printer. Only intended to be used with cartridges using an HP original chip. Cartridges using a non-HP chip may not work, and those that work today may not work in the future.” The M578 pages phrase the same policy at greater length — printers built for cartridges carrying a new or reused HP chip, dynamic security measures standing guard against any cartridge without one, and periodic firmware updates keeping those measures current, updates HP warns may stop cartridges that worked previously. HP even markets “cartridge chip security” as a selling point of its genuine cartridges. The manufacturer’s stance, in short, is neither hidden nor softened.
Against that, weigh what the twelve listings on this shelf actually say — which is nothing on the subject whatsoever. Search their full text for chip, firmware, dynamic or security and every search comes back empty. No listing asserts that its cartridges carry any particular chip, and none promises the printer will recognize them. This guide will not manufacture such a claim on their behalf.
What a buyer can hold onto, then, is the commitment the listings do make in writing: each of the twelve is backed in writing by twelve months of warranty cover and free returns across the same span. The honest proposition is the price distance from genuine cartridges — hundreds of dollars per full restock — traveled with a full year in which any disappointing cartridge can go back.
The terms standing behind the shelf
Picking among the twelve
What M554, M555 and M578 owners ask
Both, in any of the seven printers — HP names each tier as a replacement for the entire line, and tiers can be mixed from station to station. The numbers lean toward X wherever the printer works hard: an X cartridge runs about 20% dearer than its A equivalent yet returns roughly 2.4 times the black pages and 2.2 times the color pages, which is why X posts the lower rate in all six configurations. The standard tier’s argument is the invoice — a complete A restock is $235.96 against $291.80.
Half and half, on HP’s own account. Its box-contents lists put a full retail-size black — about 5,500 pages — in the machine, alongside introductory colors of roughly 3,500 pages composite against the 4,500-page retail rating; a toner collection unit rides in the crate as well. HP adds that units manufactured before 2021 may have carried higher-yield colors in the box. Either way, plan on the colors reaching their first replacement ahead of the black, and know that every cartridge on this shelf is filled to its full retail rating.
Because this store prices the family flat: $71.05 for any 212A single and $85.01 for any 212X single, regardless of station. HP’s genuine shelf runs the opposite way — its colors cost $57.00 more than its black in the A tier and $137.00 more in X. Lay the flat price over HP’s higher black ratings and black turns into the bargain of each tier: 1.29¢ a page against 1.58¢ in A, and 0.65¢ against 0.85¢ in X.
An honest answer has to hold two facts together. The listings here never mention a chip at all — the word is absent from every one of them. HP, meanwhile, labels these printers dynamic-security enabled, warns that a cartridge using a non-HP chip may not work at all, and says firmware updates will keep the blocking measures effective — including against cartridges that worked before an update. This page cannot promise a recognition the sellers themselves never claim. What does stand behind every offer is the written cover: warranty protection and free returns, each running twelve months.
They cannot. Cyan, yellow and magenta exist as singles only, in both tiers. Color capacity past a single cartridge lives inside the two four-color sets — the 212A set for a standard round at all four stations, the 212X set for a high-yield round. Black is the sole cartridge in the family offered in a pack.
No separate drum exists for this platform. Toner and drum are built into a single cartridge unit, so fitting a fresh cartridge renews the drum at the same time, and there is no drum counter or drum bill to track. The one other consumable is the toner collection unit that collects waste toner — and that ships inside the box with the printer.
