Most cartridge families make you pay for capacity. This one barely does. The Color LaserJet Pro M254 printers and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M280 and M281 multifunctions run on eight cartridges — four standard-yield 202A and four high-yield 202X, one per tier for each of the black, cyan, yellow and magenta stations — and the store stocks the arrangement in full: twenty-four offers, twelve per tier, each tier repeating the same ladder of sets, singles and black packs. The oddity worth building a guide around sits in the price tags. Stepping from a standard cartridge up to its high-yield twin costs almost nothing here — nine cents on a color single, $1.74 on the whole four-color set — while the rated output roughly doubles. The pages that follow work through both ladders box by box, price the page each one delivers, and set HP’s genuine shelf alongside for scale.
Start where the arithmetic points. The 202X four-color set at $61.94 restocks every station at high yield — some 10,700 rated pages at 0.58¢ blended — and it costs $1.74 more than the standard-tier set carrying half the pages. Owners who genuinely print lightly can take the 202A set at $60.20 and pocket the difference, but nobody should buy the standard tier expecting it to be the thrifty one: at these prices the thrifty tier is X, in every configuration on the shelf. One caution travels with the bigger boxes. The five-, six- and eight-cartridge sets in both tiers leave part of their contents to the carton labels, so this guide prices those six boxes exactly as sold and claims no saving and no per-page rate for them.
The high-yield set leads — the complete twenty-four-offer shelf
The flagship comes first, then the standard set it outvalues, then the rest of each ladder in the same order: tri-color set, the three larger boxes whose contents are only partly spelled out, the four singles, and the black packs. Where a box’s contents are stated cartridge by cartridge, the saving against those same cartridges bought singly is printed right on the card; where they are not, the card says so plainly and prints neither a saving nor a rate.
Set it beside the genuine shelf and the gap widens sharply: HP’s four 202X singles add up to $557.96, so this one carton covers the same four stations for $496.02 less, at the same published ratings.
Shop the 202X 4-Color Set →THE OTHER TWENTY-THREE OFFERS
The standard-tier full restock: all four stations renewed at once, $48.22 below the same cartridges bought singly. It stands second on this page only because the flagship above it carries twice the pages for $1.74 more.
Shop the 202A 4-Color Set →
The three colors as a single purchase, for a machine whose black still has life in it. Bought apart, the same three high-yield colors cost $81.48.
Shop the 202X Tri-Color Set →
A five-cartridge box whose listing confirms the count but leaves the fifth cartridge’s identity to the carton. It is priced here exactly as sold, with no saving claimed against contents that are not fully stated.
Shop the 202X 5-Color Set →
Colors only, six deep, for a color-heavy desk that handles its black separately. The listing states the colors-only makeup plainly but never the split among the three colors, so no per-page rate is quoted for this box.
Shop the 202X 6-Color Set →
The deepest box in the tier: eight cartridges across the four stations, with the per-code split left to the carton labels. Sold and priced as listed; this guide claims no saving for it.
Shop the 202X 8-Color Set →
The high-yield black on its own costs $1.47 more than the standard black and is rated for some 1,800 pages beyond it — the tier step in its purest form.
Shop the 202X Black Single →
High-yield cyan for nine cents more than its standard twin, carrying close to twice the standard cyan’s rated output.
Shop the 202X Cyan Single →
Yellow in the deep tier: $27.16 buys roughly 2,500 rated pages where the standard yellow offers about 1,300 for $27.07.
Shop the 202X Yellow Single →
Magenta at the tier’s shared color price, with the high-yield rating of about 2,500 pages standing behind it.
Shop the 202X Magenta Single →
A working black and a spare, both high yield: $16.07 below the pair bought singly, with the black rate easing from 0.90¢ to 0.65¢.
Shop the 202X 2 Black Pack →
Three deep blacks for the document-heavy machine — nearly ten thousand rated pages of black in a single order, $32.14 under three singles.
Shop the 202X 3 Black Pack →
The family’s cheapest black page: five high-yield cartridges pull the rate under half a cent, $64.29 below the five bought one at a time.
Shop the 202X 5 Black Pack →
The standard colors in one carton, $32.14 under the three singles — the restock for a machine whose black station is still going strong.
Shop the 202A Tri-Color Set →
Five cartridges over the four codes, with the spare’s identity printed on the carton rather than stated in the listing. Priced here as sold; no saving is claimed for it.
Shop the 202A 5-Color Set →
Six color cartridges and no black, for desks that burn through color and feed black from its own packs. The listing confirms the colors-only makeup; the count per color stays on the carton labels.
Shop the 202A 6-Color Set →
Eight standard cartridges across all four codes — the tier’s biggest box, with the per-code counts not enumerated anywhere in the listing.
Shop the 202A 8-Color Set →
The standard black alone — the full-size cartridge the M280/M281 machines start life on, and the lightest black this family sells.
Shop the 202A Black Single →
Standard cyan at the tier’s color price — cyan, yellow and magenta all carry the identical $27.07 tag in this tier.
Shop the 202A Cyan Single →
Yellow on the same terms as its color companions: $27.07 and roughly 1,300 rated pages.
Shop the 202A Yellow Single →
The magenta station’s standard refill, priced in lockstep with the other two colors in the tier.
Shop the 202A Magenta Single →
Two standard blacks — one in the machine, one in reserve — for $16.08 less than the same pair bought apart.
Shop the 202A 2 Black Pack →
A three-deep black reserve at the standard depth, trimming the black page from 1.94¢ down to 1.18¢.
Shop the 202A 3 Black Pack →
The standard ladder’s best black rate: five blacks bring the page to just over a cent, $64.32 below five singles.
Shop the 202A 5 Black Pack →Read the two ladders against each other and the family’s lesson repeats at every rung: the deeper tier adds pennies and returns pages. A color single gains about 1,200 rated pages for nine cents. The four-color set gains 5,400 pages for $1.74. Even the five-black pack, the widest price gap on the shelf, adds $7.38 and returns 9,000 pages. There is no rung where the standard tier wins on cost per page — its entire case rests on the smaller invoice.
Every price printed in this guide is a sale price, the figure the checkout actually charges. The product pages themselves do their prose arithmetic from the higher list prices, so a number quoted inside a listing can sit above the one on its card here; the note closing this guide sets out the basis behind each kind of figure.
All twenty-four offers in one table
The ratings below are the figures the listings and HP publish side by side, declared under ISO/IEC 19798; real output drifts with page coverage, so plan with them rather than promise by them. A stated set’s total adds the ratings of the cartridges inside it, and its blended rate divides the sale price by that total. Six rows quote no rate at all — the five-, six- and eight-cartridge sets, whose listings leave part of the contents to the carton labels. Fit needs no column: every row fits every printer in the roster further down.
| Offer | Price (sale) | Box contents | Cost per page | Saving against singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 202X 4-Color Set — the flagship | $61.94 | One of each station, high yield · ~10,700 pages | 0.58¢ blended | SAVE $48.22 |
| 202A 4-Color Set | $60.20 | One of each station, standard yield · ~5,300 pages | 1.14¢ blended | SAVE $48.22 |
| 202X Tri-Color Set | $49.34 | Cyan, magenta and yellow, one each · ~7,500 pages | 0.66¢ | SAVE $32.14 |
| 202X 5-Color Set | $74.55 | Five cartridges across the four codes — doubled code not identified | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 202X 6-Color Set — colors only | $82.60 | Six cartridges in the three color codes, no black — per-color counts not stated | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 202X 8-Color Set | $107.81 | Eight cartridges across the four codes — per-code counts not enumerated | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 202X Black Single (CF500X) | $28.68 | 1 black, high yield · ~3,200 pages | 0.90¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202X Cyan Single (CF501X) | $27.16 | 1 cyan, high yield · ~2,500 pages | 1.09¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202X Yellow Single (CF502X) | $27.16 | 1 yellow, high yield · ~2,500 pages | 1.09¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202X Magenta Single (CF503X) | $27.16 | 1 magenta, high yield · ~2,500 pages | 1.09¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202X 2 Black Pack | $41.29 | 2 black, high yield · ~6,400 pages | 0.65¢ | SAVE $16.07 |
| 202X 3 Black Pack | $53.90 | 3 black, high yield · ~9,600 pages | 0.56¢ | SAVE $32.14 |
| 202X 5 Black Pack | $79.11 | 5 black, high yield · ~16,000 pages | 0.49¢ | SAVE $64.29 |
| 202A Tri-Color Set | $49.07 | Cyan, magenta and yellow, one each · ~3,900 pages | 1.26¢ | SAVE $32.14 |
| 202A 5-Color Set | $71.33 | Five cartridges across the four codes — doubled code not identified | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 202A 6-Color Set — colors only | $82.06 | Six cartridges in the three color codes, no black — per-color counts not stated | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 202A 8-Color Set | $104.32 | Eight cartridges across the four codes — per-code counts not enumerated | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 202A Black Single (CF500A) | $27.21 | 1 black · ~1,400 pages | 1.94¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202A Cyan Single (CF501A) | $27.07 | 1 cyan · ~1,300 pages | 2.08¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202A Yellow Single (CF502A) | $27.07 | 1 yellow · ~1,300 pages | 2.08¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202A Magenta Single (CF503A) | $27.07 | 1 magenta · ~1,300 pages | 2.08¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 202A 2 Black Pack | $38.34 | 2 black · ~2,800 pages | 1.37¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 202A 3 Black Pack | $49.47 | 3 black · ~4,200 pages | 1.18¢ | SAVE $32.16 |
| 202A 5 Black Pack | $71.73 | 5 black · ~7,000 pages | 1.02¢ | SAVE $64.32 |
Two rows deserve a second look. The flagship’s 0.58¢ is no rounding gift — it is simply what happens when a $61.94 box carries 10,700 rated pages. And the two five-black packs frame the whole argument in miniature: the standard pack’s 1.02¢ would count as a respectable floor in most families, until the high-yield pack posts 0.49¢ directly beneath it.
Where the page gets cheap — and where HP’s does not
Inside the compatible shelf, cost per page is a story about depth, not about color. Parity across the colors is exact within each tier — $27.07 buys any standard color and $27.16 any high-yield one — while black sits a few cents above its tier’s colors yet outrates every one of them, which quietly leaves black the better buy in both tiers: 1.94¢ a page against 2.08¢ in standard yield, 0.90¢ against 1.09¢ in high yield. The sets compress the numbers further, blending four stations into a single rate — 1.14¢ in the standard set, 0.58¢ in the high-yield one.
HP’s genuine shelf runs several times higher, and it splits the stations the opposite way. A genuine standard black is $88.99, about 6.36¢ a page, and each genuine standard color is $105.99, about 8.15¢. In high yield the genuine black is $131.99, about 4.12¢, and the colors are $141.99 apiece, about 5.68¢. HP does sell genuine multipacks — a three-color pack at $284.99 in the standard tier and $382.99 in high yield, plus a two-black pack at $239.99 in high yield — but no genuine four-pack exists in either tier, so a full genuine restock always means four singles: $406.96 in standard yield, $557.96 in high yield.
Scale it to a year of small-office printing. Ten thousand black pages fed from the 202X five-black packs cost about $49 in toner; the same ten thousand pages fed from genuine high-yield black singles cost about $413. The cartridges in between — the standard packs, the tri-color sets — land where the table says they land, but the shape of the shelf never changes: depth is cheap here, and the genuine alternative is priced in a different league altogether.
Two ratings ladders, and a starter split worth knowing
The ratings need no referee in this family, because every listing publishes the same figures HP publishes. Standard yield runs about 1,400 pages for the CF500A black and 1,300 for each standard color; high yield runs about 3,200 for the CF500X black and 2,500 for each high-yield color, all declared under ISO/IEC 19798. Nothing on the canonical shelf dissents from those numbers, so every rate in the table above rests on figures both the store and the manufacturer stand behind.
The cartridges a new machine starts on depend on which line you bought. The M254 printers ship with introductory cartridges at every station — roughly 800 pages of black and 700 pages of color composite. The M280 and M281 multifunctions split the difference: their colors also start introductory, at about 700 pages composite, but the black in the box is a full standard cartridge rated at the whole 1,400. Either way the colors call for their first replacements first; on an M254, expect the black to follow sooner than its retail rating suggests.
There is no drum budget hiding behind this family. Each cartridge is an all-in-one unit with its drum built in, so a cartridge change renews the works, and HP’s supplies lists for these machines name cartridges and paper only — no separate drum unit and no toner collection unit is stocked or listed for the platform. Genuine prices quoted in this guide were read at HP’s US store with every code showing in stock: standard singles at $88.99 for black and $105.99 per color; high-yield singles at $131.99 for black and $141.99 per color.
Seven printers, one shared cartridge family
HP assigns this family to seven machines across two lines: the Color LaserJet Pro M254dn, M254dw and M254nw printers, and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M280nw, M281fdn, M281fdw and M281cdw multifunctions. Every model in that roster accepts both tiers at every station — no machine here is confined to the standard cartridges, and none is shut out of the high-yield ones.
Of the seven, only the Color LaserJet Pro M254dw has its own category in this store, so it is the one model linked from this page. The other six are named here in full, and they take exactly the same eight cartridges.
One naming caution is worth printing. The listings’ fit lines name just two printers — the M254dw and an “M281dw” — but HP never sold a model under that second name; the real M281 machines are the M281fdn, M281fdw and M281cdw in the roster above. If your machine’s badge reads one of those, this is your family, whatever a fit line says. And as always, the cartridge coming out of the machine settles the question on its own: any code from CF500 through CF503, closed by an A or an X, belongs to this page.
A smart chip in the parts list; dynamic security in HP’s wording
The listings do mention a chip — once each, and always inside the same sentence. Each describes its cartridges as manufactured brand new with all-new parts, naming the OPC drum, the wiper blades and “a smart chip” among the internals. That single parts sentence is the whole of the store’s chip claim: no listing says anything further about recognition, firmware or security in either direction.
HP’s side of the page is firmer. Its datasheets and printer pages for this platform carry dynamic-security language, noting that the machines are only intended to be used with cartridges using an HP original chip. On the manufacturer’s own description, then, this is a dynamic-security platform — and this guide promises nothing about how a future firmware update will treat any cartridge, because that is not a promise the listings make either.
What stands behind a purchase here is written cover rather than chip claims: twelve months of warranty and free returns running across the same twelve months, on every one of the twenty-four offers above.
What backs every box on this shelf
Matching the box to the printer’s appetite
Questions from M254 and M280/M281 owners
Both, in any of the seven printers, and the tiers can be mixed from station to station. On this shelf the economics are unusually one-sided: a high-yield cartridge costs between nine cents and $1.47 more than its standard twin, yet returns roughly double the rated pages, so the X tier posts the lower cost per page in all twelve configurations. The standard tier’s only argument is the invoice in front of you — a complete standard restock is $60.20 against $61.94.
It is simply how this shelf is priced. The two four-color sets sit $1.74 apart, the color singles nine cents apart, and the black singles $1.47 apart — while the names, yield fields and texts on every listing stay coherent within their own tier. Treat the near-parity as the family’s central buying fact rather than a misprint to wait out: at these prices, capacity is close to free.
Partly stated, partly not. The five-cartridge sets hold the four codes plus a spare of one of them, and which code is doubled is printed on the carton labels rather than in the listing. The six-cartridge sets are colors only — the three color codes, no black — with the count of each color likewise left to the carton. The eight-cartridge sets span the four codes without enumerating how many of each. Because those six boxes’ contents are not fully stated, this guide claims no saving and no per-page rate for them.
It depends on the line. The M254 printers start on introductory cartridges at every station — about 800 pages of black and 700 of color composite. The M280 and M281 multifunctions start their colors at the same introductory level, about 700 pages composite, but their in-box black is a full standard cartridge rated at 1,400. On either line, plan for the colors to reach their first replacement first.
No separate drum exists for this platform, and no collection unit is listed for it either. Toner and drum are built into a single all-in-one cartridge, so fitting a fresh cartridge renews both at once, and HP’s supplies lists for these machines name cartridges and paper only. There is no drum counter to watch and no second consumable to budget for.
Each listing says exactly one thing: its cartridges are built with all-new parts, a smart chip named among them. HP’s own material for this platform goes further in the other direction, describing dynamic-security machines intended to be used with cartridges using an HP original chip. This guide reports both positions as they stand and promises nothing about future firmware behavior; what backs a purchase in writing is the twelve-month warranty and the year of free returns.
The store’s compatible terms cover it: a twelve-month warranty, returns free for the whole of that year, and support on weekdays from 9 AM to 5 PM Central to arrange the exchange. Keep the carton until the replacement is printing cleanly.
