null

0

Your cart is empty

Best Brother LC404 Ink Cartridges

BUYING GUIDE CLEVER SUPPLIES · BROTHER LC404 · INKVESTMENT STANDARD-YIELD INK FOR THREE SMALL PRINTERS
Best Brother LC404 Ink Cartridges

Three printers, one cartridge, one tier — LC404 is the plainest shelf in Brother’s LC40x generation, and the one most often mistaken for its neighbors. Brother rates every cartridge in the family at up to 750 pages, black and colors on the same figure, for the MFC-J1205W, the MFC-J1205W XL and the MFC-J1215W. No XL version waits above it and no second family hides inside it. The traps sit outside the family instead: a Tank look-alike that runs on a different cartridge entirely, and an “XL” name Brother never made. Below, all six offers are priced per page and both traps are dealt with in the open.

Up to 750 pages
Brother’s rating for each cartridge in the family — the black and every color on the one figure, to ISO/IEC 24711
3 printers
The MFC-J1205W, its XL bundle twin and the MFC-J1215W — the whole roster, and every offer fits all three
$58.74
The Set of 4 — one cartridge per slot, $7.22 under the four singles bought apart, and past the free-shipping line by itself
One tier only
Brother’s INKvestment Standard-yield — no LC404XL exists above it, whatever marketplace listings claim
THE SHORT VERSION

Own an MFC-J1205W, an MFC-J1205W XL or an MFC-J1215W? Then this page is the whole of your ink shelf: six listings, all compatible, each cartridge carrying a new compatible chip, and not one genuine LC404 offered in this store. The Set of 4 at $58.74 leads because it refills every slot in one order and crosses the free-shipping line alone; the Set of 9 at $119.34 stands behind it for owners who stock deep; the four singles hold at a flat $16.49. Both sets also share a distinction worth knowing up front: each one clears the $49 free-shipping threshold entirely on its own, which no single here can do. What needs explaining is everything around the shelf — the single-tier structure, the generation of look-alike families beside it, the Tank printers it does not fit, and the in-box ink Brother measures in years. All of it follows.

Six offers, one cartridge: the full refill, the deep box, the singles

Fit needs no sorting here — all six offers serve all three printers — so the ladder is ordered by buying habit. The Set of 4 opens it, one fresh cartridge for each slot. The Set of 9 follows, for owners who would rather think about ink twice a year. The singles close it, each one answering the single slot that ran dry.

★ THE FLAGSHIP · ALL FOUR SLOTS, ONE ORDER
Compatible Brother LC404 Set of 4 BCMY Ink Cartridge
Compatible Brother LC404 Set of 4 BCMY Ink Cartridge
Black plus one of each color — the complete refill for the MFC-J1205W, MFC-J1205W XL and MFC-J1215W
$58.74 SAVE $7.22 VS SINGLES
✓  One box renews all four slots at once — black, cyan, magenta and yellow, each rated up to 750 pages
✓  Works out to $14.69 a cartridge, against $16.49 for the same four cartridges bought one at a time
✓  Blended, that is 1.96¢ a page — the $58.74 divided across the 3,000 rated pages the four cartridges carry

Brother’s genuine counter has no box to answer this one. Its line is four singles — black $32.49, colors $19.79 each — and a colors-only 3-pack at $52.49; filling all four slots the genuine way totals $91.86. This set covers the same slots at the same published rating for $58.74, and it crosses the $49 free-shipping line standing alone — a trick the deep box below repeats, but no single on this page can.

Shop the LC404 Set of 4 →

THE REST OF THE LADDER — DEEP BOX FIRST, THEN THE SINGLES

Compatible Brother LC404 Set of 9 BCMY Ink Cartridge
LC404 Set of 9
▦ Bulk box · three blacks, two of each color · every cartridge rated up to 750 pages · 1.77¢ blended a page
$119.34 SAVE $29.07

The family’s floor price: $13.26 a cartridge and 1.77¢ a page, the lowest figures on this page. The mix leans black — three blacks to two of each color — because these printers earn their keep on documents. At $119.34 it ships free on its own.

Shop the LC404 Set of 9 →
Compatible Brother LC404 LC404BK Black Ink Cartridge
LC404BK Black
▦ Black single · rated up to 750 pages · 2.20¢ a page
$16.49

The document cartridge, at the family’s flat $16.49 — Brother’s genuine LC404BKS costs $32.49, a cent short of double. It is rated the same 750 pages as every color here; it just empties first.

Shop LC404BK Black →
Compatible Brother LC404 LC404C Cyan Ink Cartridge
LC404 Cyan
▦ Color single · rated up to 750 pages · 2.20¢ a page
$16.49

Cyan feeds the blues in charts, logos and letterhead, and in a small office it is commonly the first color to fade. $16.49 here; Brother’s genuine cyan is $19.79.

Shop LC404 Cyan →
Compatible Brother LC404 LC404M Magenta Ink Cartridge
LC404 Magenta
▦ Color single · rated up to 750 pages · 2.20¢ a page
$16.49

Magenta at the flat $16.49, rated up to 750 pages — report reds, flyer color and slide decks all draw on this slot. The genuine cartridge at Brother is $19.79.

Shop LC404 Magenta →
Compatible Brother LC404 LC404Y Yellow Ink Cartridge
LC404 Yellow
▦ Color single · rated up to 750 pages · 2.20¢ a page
$16.49

Yellow rarely announces itself — output washes pale gradually rather than failing — so its 750-page rating works best as a schedule. $16.49, against $19.79 for Brother’s genuine yellow.

Shop LC404 Yellow →

A word for the singles, because on a shelf led by sets they can look like leftovers. The four slots in these printers do not run dry together; they run out one slot at a time, following the rhythm of what a household or office actually prints — black first under document work, one color ahead of the others under charts or photos. A single is the answer to that moment: the spent slot is renewed, the three cartridges still holding ink stay where they are, and nobody pays to replace ink they still own. The sets win on rate; the singles win on timing — and a shelf that serves real printers needs both shapes on it.

The six offers on one table, priced per page

First, Brother’s own measuring stick, in Brother’s words: “Approximate page yield in accordance with ISO/IEC 24711 (letter/A4).” The stick measures cartridges — up to 750 pages for the black and the same for each color — and it never measures a box. So the two set rows carry a figure worked out by division instead: the box price divided by the rated pages packed inside it, 3,000 pages in the Set of 4 and 6,750 in the Set of 9. Where the per-page column says “blended”, that division is all it means.

Offer Fits Price Rating per cartridge Cost per page Against the singles
LC404 Set of 4 BCMY — the flagship All three printers $58.74 Up to 750 each, black and colors alike 1.96¢ blended SAVE $7.22
LC404 Set of 9 All three printers $119.34 3 blacks and 2 of each color, up to 750 each 1.77¢ blended SAVE $29.07 · ships free alone
LC404BK black single All three printers $16.49 Up to 750 pages 2.20¢ The slot that empties first
LC404C cyan single All three printers $16.49 Up to 750 pages 2.20¢ One slot, one cartridge
LC404M magenta single All three printers $16.49 Up to 750 pages 2.20¢ One slot at a time
LC404Y yellow single All three printers $16.49 Up to 750 pages 2.20¢ One slot, one cartridge

Nothing about the cartridge changes from row to row — one design, one 750-page ceiling in every slot — so read the per-page column as a ladder of box sizes and nothing else: $16.49 for a cartridge on its own, $14.69 apiece inside the Set of 4, $13.26 inside the Set of 9, with the rate stepping 2.20¢, 1.96¢, 1.77¢ behind it. A bigger box buys no extra yield. It buys a lower rate, and a longer wait before the next order.

One tier, four families: where LC404 stands in its generation

Start with what LC404 is not. Brother labels this family “INKvestment Standard-yield”, and it is the only tier these three printers have: no high-yield LC404 waits above it and no economy version sits below it. The name “LC404XL” turns up on marketplace listings, but Brother publishes no such cartridge — no XL single, no XL pack, nothing under that name in its catalog. A cartridge sold under the LC404XL name is a seller’s invention, not a Brother product.

LC404 belongs to Brother’s LC40x generation: four cartridge families built in the same years for different machines, each with its own cartridge body. LC401 serves its own group of printers and keeps its own shelf in this store — the LC401 guide in this series prices that family in full. LC402 is a genuine Brother family too — standard yield, up to 550 pages, for the MFC-J5340DW, MFC-J6540DW and MFC-J6940DW — but this store stocks none of it. LC406 closes the generation as the INKvestment Tank line for Brother’s larger tank machines. Four families, four bodies: not one of them fits another family’s printer, however close the codes sit together on a shelf.

The boundary that matters most is the LC406 one, because the printers look like relatives. The MFC-J4335DW and MFC-J4535DW are INKvestment Tank machines, and Brother’s pages for both name their replacement cartridges outright: LC406 at 3,000 pages for the black and 1,500 per color, LC406XL at 6,000 and 5,000. LC404 appears nowhere on either page. An LC404 cartridge will not run in those printers, and an LC406 cartridge will not run in the three printers on this page — the model name on the front panel, not the family resemblance, decides which shelf is yours.

The branding deserves one clarification, because Brother works two similar names in this generation. These three printers belong to the plain INKvestment line — standard-yield cartridges in a conventional four-slot layout, ink bought by the cartridge and by the box. The larger machines carry the INKvestment Tank name, a different design with the LC406 family behind the same brand word. An owner searching by the INKvestment name alone can land on Tank cartridges that will never fit these printers; the LC404 code, and the three model names above it, are the identifiers that keep the shelf straight.

Ink in the box, measured in years

Every one of the three printers leaves its carton holding four starter cartridges — black, cyan, magenta and yellow — and Brother describes what that ink is worth in time rather than pages. For the MFC-J1205W the claim is “Up to 1-year of ink in-box”, footnoted in Brother’s words: “Based on average monthly print volumes of approximately 100 pages at 60% black pages/40% color pages in accordance with ISO/IEC 24711 using 4 cartridges provided in-box.” The MFC-J1215W carries the same one-year claim on a lighter basis, approximately 80 pages a month.

The MFC-J1205W XL doubles the promise without adding a cartridge: “Up to 2-years of Ink in-box” and “2X the Amount of Ink” against the plain MFC-J1205W, from the same four in-box cartridges on the same roughly 100-pages-a-month basis. The XL buys a deeper first fill, not a different cartridge design — when any of the three runs dry, the replacement comes off this page.

One absence is worth stating plainly, because other Brother families print the opposite: Brother publishes no starter percentage and no starter page count for LC404 — no “starts at so-many percent of a replacement” footnote exists for these printers. So this page prints none. When the in-box ink is gone, a replacement LC404 cartridge carries the full published rating of up to 750 pages, and that is the first page figure an owner can plan around.

The chip that reports the level — and the warning Brother attaches to it

Begin with the specification field, because all six listings agree there: “New compatible chip (ink-level chip)”. The descriptions match it in prose — each cartridge carries a new compatible chip that reports ink levels to the printer — and the sets carry one in every cartridge inside them. No LC404 listing in this store is sold without it.

Now the limit, kept at the size the listings themselves print it. Brother’s support material for this generation addresses non-genuine ink directly: the machine may or may not detect the ink volume, and Brother cannot guarantee optimum performance and reliability with ink of other specifications. The listings repeat that warning rather than promising recognition they cannot guarantee — and this page repeats it the same way. What it means in practice: the cartridge seats and prints; the on-screen level reading is the part that may not follow.

Should a “Cannot Detect” message appear, the listings’ routine is mechanical: lift the cartridge out, reseat it firmly until it clicks, keep fingers off the chip contacts, and restart the printer. On the firmware question the record is plain — no official Brother statement that an update blocks compatible cartridges in this generation was found by the listings, and Brother’s stated position since March 2025 is that firmware updates do not block third-party ink. A cartridge that still refuses to register after reseating is covered by the lifetime warranty in every listing’s specification block. Everything here is drawn from these six listings; the store’s other families carry their own chip wordings elsewhere.

Fitting one is a thirty-second job, and the listings describe it the same way across the family: open the ink cover, release the spent cartridge with its lever, and slide the replacement into its lettered slot until it clicks. Match the cartridge to the slot letter rather than to the cap color alone, keep fingers off the chip contacts while handling it, and the swap is done — the three cartridges that still hold ink are never disturbed. A cartridge seated short of its click is the commonest cause of a detection message, which is why the reseat routine above starts with seating.

Three printers take this cartridge — all three, and no others

Brother’s wording on its genuine LC404 pages runs: “Brother Genuine LC404BK is for use with Brother INKvestment multi-function color inkjet printer models MFC-J1205W, MFC-J1205W XL and MFC-J1215W.” The list is short enough to memorize, and it is the whole list: every single and both sets on this page fit all three models, and no fourth printer takes this cartridge.

The store’s filing follows Brother’s list exactly. Each of the six listings sits in all three model categories and in the family’s code category, the Brother LC404 category — arrive by printer or arrive by cartridge code, and the shelf you reach is the same six listings.

All three are INKvestment multi-function color inkjet models, in Brother’s own description — compact machines that print, scan and copy in black and color from the same four slots. Nothing in the family is reserved to one of them: whichever of the three names stands on the front panel, the answer to the fit question is this page.

Behind every listing on this shelf

✓ Lifetime Warranty
The warranty line in every listing’s specification block reads the same way: lifetime cover on the cartridge itself
✓ 1-Year Free Returns
A wrong-model order can go back free any time inside the first year — all six offers carry the same one-year free-returns term
✓ Free Shipping at $49
Both sets on this page pass the $49 free-shipping threshold on their own — the Set of 4 at $58.74 and the Set of 9 at $119.34; singles reach it only as part of a larger order
✓ Four US Warehouses
Inventory sits in Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and California, and the support desk answers 9 AM to 5 PM Central, Monday to Friday

Five checks before an LC404 order

✓The front panel names one of the three. MFC-J1205W, MFC-J1205W XL or MFC-J1215W — a match on any one of them settles fit for all six offers, sets included.
✓It is not one of the Tank look-alikes. The MFC-J4335DW and MFC-J4535DW resemble these machines but run on LC406 — if the front panel carries either of those names, this page is the wrong shelf.
✓No XL cartridge is being hunted. LC404 is a single tier; there is no LC404XL to find, and anything sold under that name is not a Brother cartridge.
✓The $49 line is already cleared by either set. The Set of 4 at $58.74 and the Set of 9 at $119.34 each ship free alone; a single at $16.49 ships free only inside a $49-plus order.
✓The detection warning is no surprise. A compatible chip reports the ink level, but with non-genuine ink the machine may or may not detect the volume — seat the cartridge until it clicks, keep fingers off the chip contacts, and know the reseat routine before the first slot runs dry.

Questions owners of these printers ask

Is there an LC404XL I should be buying instead?

No — the cartridge does not exist. Brother’s LC404 line is a single tier, labeled INKvestment Standard-yield: four singles and one genuine colors pack, with no XL single and no XL pack anywhere in its catalog. Listings built on the LC404XL name are seller inventions. What varies on this page is box size, not tier: the same 750-page cartridge bought singly, in the Set of 4, or in the Set of 9.

My printer is an MFC-J4335DW. Will LC404 fit it?

It will not, and the look of the machine is what misleads people. The MFC-J4335DW is an INKvestment Tank printer; Brother’s page for it names LC406 (3,000 pages black, 1,500 per color) and LC406XL (6,000 and 5,000) as its replacement cartridges, and LC404 appears nowhere there. The same holds for the MFC-J4535DW. This store stocks no LC406, so the honest answer is that your shelf is a different one — the model name on the front panel is the test.

Why do the black and the colors all carry a 750-page rating?

Because Brother rates this family flat. The black is not given a larger figure than the colors here — up to 750 pages for the LC404BK and up to 750 for each color — and the store’s singles follow the same shape at one flat $16.49. In practice the black still empties first in a document-heavy home, which is why the Set of 9 stocks three blacks against two of each color rather than pretending one cartridge outlasts the rest.

Does Brother sell a genuine set that covers all four slots?

No. Brother’s genuine LC404 line is four singles — the black at $32.49, each color at $19.79 — plus one pack, the LC4043PKS colors 3-pack at $52.49, which holds no black at all. There is no genuine black 2-pack and no genuine four-pack. Filling all four slots with genuine singles totals $91.86; the compatible Set of 4 on this page covers the same four slots at $58.74.

How much ink came in the box with my printer?

Four starter cartridges — and Brother measures them in time, not pages. The MFC-J1205W and MFC-J1215W are sold with up to 1-year of ink in-box, on a stated basis of roughly 100 and 80 pages a month respectively; the MFC-J1205W XL carries up to 2-years from its four in-box cartridges. Brother publishes no starter page count for this family, so this page quotes none — the first figure you can plan on is the replacement cartridge’s own rating of up to 750 pages.

The printer says it cannot detect the ink volume. Is the cartridge faulty?

Not necessarily — it is the behavior Brother’s own support material describes for non-genuine ink in this generation: the machine may or may not detect the ink volume. Lift the cartridge out, reseat it firmly until it clicks with fingers off the chip contacts, and restart the printer. The listings print that warning instead of promising recognition they cannot guarantee, and this page does the same; a cartridge that still will not register is covered by the lifetime warranty in its listing.

Price and disclosure note: Every price on this page was read from the listing’s own store page on November 13, 2026; the product page’s figure governs at checkout if the two ever differ. The set savings are this page’s arithmetic against its own singles — four singles total $65.96 and nine total $148.41, which is where the Set of 4’s $7.22 and the Set of 9’s $29.07 come from. Ratings belong to cartridges, on the basis Brother prints for this family — “Approximate page yield in accordance with ISO/IEC 24711 (letter/A4).” — up to 750 pages for the black and the same for each color; no box on this page is given a rating of its own, and a set’s blended figure is its price divided by the rated pages inside it. Brother publishes no milliliter volume for LC404, so none appears. Genuine figures are Brother USA storefront context, read the same day: the LC404BKS black at $32.49, the genuine colors at $19.79 each, and the LC4043PKS colors 3-pack at $52.49 — $91.86 for a genuine fill of all four slots — in a genuine line that is still current and holds no black 2-pack and no four-pack. The three-printer roster is Brother’s, taken from its cartridge pages. In-box ink follows Brother’s printer pages: four starter cartridges in each carton, described by Brother as up to 1-year of ink in-box for the MFC-J1205W (about 100 pages a month at 60% black / 40% color) and the MFC-J1215W (about 80 a month), and up to 2-years for the MFC-J1205W XL; Brother publishes no starter page count or percentage for this family, and none is printed. The chip statement is the listings’ own — a new compatible chip (ink-level chip) in every cartridge — with the limit the listings attach to it kept attached: with non-genuine ink the machine may or may not detect the ink volume, and recognition is not promised. The neighboring families are named from Brother’s pages: LC401, covered by its own guide in this series; LC402, a genuine family this store does not stock; and LC406, the INKvestment Tank family whose printers — the MFC-J4335DW and MFC-J4535DW among them — take no LC404 cartridge.