Small printers, small cartridges, refreshingly little fine print. The Color LaserJet Pro M154 printers and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M180 and M181 multifunctions all feed from the same four cartridges — CF510A black, CF511A cyan, CF512A yellow, CF513A magenta — and HP built the family in a single standard-yield tier. There is no 204X waiting in a second row of the catalog, at HP or in this store, so the choice here is never about which tier to buy. It is about which box size suits the machine. Twelve offers make up the shelf: a complete four-color set, a colors-only set, three larger color boxes that carry honest cautions instead of savings badges, three packs of black, and four singles whose three colors are priced identically to the cent. The ratings ask for no tie-breaking either — the listings declare about 1,100 pages for the black and 900 for each color, and HP’s published figures declare exactly the same. What this guide does is price the page each box delivers and lay HP’s $307.96 genuine alternative alongside.
Start from the four-color set at $64.12: it comes in $48.23 under the same four cartridges bought one at a time and prices its 3,800 rated pages at 1.69¢ apiece. When only the color stations are due, the colors-only set at $52.60 saves $32.15 against the three color singles. Black deepens in packs — two, three or five cartridges — and the five-pack holds the cheapest page in the family at 1.34¢. Three bigger color boxes are priced and described exactly as their listings leave them, with part of their contents unstated, so they carry cautions rather than savings figures. HP’s own shelf, by contrast, asks $70.99 for the black and $78.99 for each color, $307.96 for a complete genuine change — nearly five times the flagship set’s price for the same rated pages.
Twelve offers, one tier, three boxes with fine print
The order below follows how these compact machines actually get restocked: the full four-cartridge change first, the colors as a set of their own, then the three bulk color boxes whose listings leave part of the contents to the carton label, the four singles in code order, and black by the pack to close. Where a listing spells out its contents cartridge by cartridge, the saving against singles is printed right on the card. Where the contents are not spelled out, the card flags that instead, and claims nothing. Ratings throughout are the pair both sources publish — roughly 1,100 pages from the CF510A black, roughly 900 from each color.
Held against the genuine route, the set is the family’s headline: HP’s four singles total $307.96, so this carton covers the identical four stations for $243.84 less — a saving of roughly four-fifths — at the same published ratings.
Shop the 4-Color Set →THE OTHER ELEVEN OFFERS
A colors-only renewal for machines whose black cartridge is still going. Its listing states plainly that no black rides in the box, and bundling the trio trims $32.15 off buying the three singles separately, holding the color page at 1.95¢.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
Five cartridges in the box, drawn from the family’s four codes, with one code doubled — and which one is left unsaid, as the listing itself concedes. The price is printed exactly as listed; no saving is computed against a contents list that stays partly unspoken.
Shop the 5-Color Set →
Colors only, six deep, with a combined 5,400 color pages stated in its text. The listing never breaks that down color by color, so this guide quotes neither a saving nor a per-page rate for the box — check the carton labels for the split.
Shop the 6-Color Set →
The shelf’s deepest box: eight cartridges spread over the four stations, their exact division recorded on the carton labels rather than in the listing. It is offered here at its listed price, with no saving asserted for contents that are not itemized.
Shop the 8-Color Set →
The black cartridge on its own — and, unusually, the cheapest single in the family, sitting a little below the colors it normally out-prices. It is also the unit every black pack below is built from.
Shop the Black Single →
Cyan at the price all three colors share — $28.25, the same tag yellow and magenta carry. Against HP’s $78.99 genuine cyan, the compatible single is where the per-cartridge gap is widest in dollars.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Yellow asks the same $28.25 as cyan and magenta and returns the same roughly 900 rated pages. Whichever color station the printer flags first, the replacement invoice reads the same.
Shop the Yellow Single →
Magenta completes the row of color singles — three cartridges, three different jobs, one price and one rating. There is no station on this shelf where the single-cartridge arithmetic changes.
Shop the Magenta Single →
A working black and a spare in one order: the pair lands $16.09 under two singles and pulls the black page down from 2.51¢ to 1.78¢. For a document-heavy machine, it is the natural restock rhythm.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →
Three blacks in one order, $32.17 below the three singles, holding about 3,300 rated pages of black between orders. The middle rung of the black ladder, and a sensible depth for a shared home-office machine.
Shop the 3 Black Pack →
The bottom rung of the family’s ladder and its cheapest page: five blacks land $64.33 under five singles and hold the black rate at 1.34¢. Roughly 5,500 pages of black between orders.
Shop the 5 Black Pack →Look at the singles row once more, because it captures the family: the black is the cheapest cartridge of the four, and the three colors are interchangeable in price. That removes the usual station-by-station second-guessing — a refill budget drawn up for one color holds for all three, and black, the cartridge these machines burn fastest, is the one that costs least to replace.
Every price on this page is a sale price — the figure the checkout actually charges. The basis is worth stating here because some listings’ own FAQ text quotes rounded list prices in passing (the black packs’ FAQs speak of $44, $58 and $84 where the sale prices are $39.11, $50.63 and $73.67); the closing note sets out the ground rules behind each figure.
All twelve offers, one table
The family fits on a single screen: twelve rows, no second tier beneath them. Read the page counts as planning figures from the standard test method, not as guarantees — dense color coverage spends a cartridge faster than plain text does. For the sets whose contents are stated in full, the page total sums the cartridges inside and the rate is the sale price divided by that total. Three rows show no rate, because their listings never itemize what is inside closely enough to support one. There is no fit column, since all twelve rows serve the same five printers named further down.
| Offer | Sale price | What is in the box | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 204A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $64.12 | One cartridge per station — black, cyan, yellow, magenta · ~3,800 pages | 1.69¢ blended | SAVE $48.23 |
| 204A Tri-Color Set | $52.60 | Cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~2,700 pages | 1.95¢ | SAVE $32.15 |
| 204A 5-Color Set | $75.64 | 5 cartridges over the four codes — doubled code unnamed | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 204A 6-Color Set — colors only | $89.12 | 6 color cartridges, no black — split by color unstated | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 204A 8-Color Set | $112.16 | 8 cartridges over the four codes — counts per code unstated | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 204A Black Single (CF510A) | $27.60 | 1 black · ~1,100 pages | 2.51¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 204A Cyan Single (CF511A) | $28.25 | 1 cyan · ~900 pages | 3.14¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 204A Yellow Single (CF512A) | $28.25 | 1 yellow · ~900 pages | 3.14¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 204A Magenta Single (CF513A) | $28.25 | 1 magenta · ~900 pages | 3.14¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 204A 2 Black Pack | $39.11 | 2 black · ~2,200 pages | 1.78¢ | SAVE $16.09 |
| 204A 3 Black Pack | $50.63 | 3 black · ~3,300 pages | 1.53¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
| 204A 5 Black Pack | $73.67 | 5 black · ~5,500 pages | 1.34¢ | SAVE $64.33 |
Two things stand out on a slow read. First, the three blank rate cells are deliberate: those boxes are priced and described, but their listings do not itemize the contents closely enough to divide a price by a page count honestly. Second, black is the family’s bargain at every depth — the only sub-2¢ rates outside the flagship set all belong to the black packs.
The cost of a page here — and on HP’s shelf
Within the compatible shelf, the ladder is short and legible. A lone black page runs 2.51¢; the black packs step it down through 1.78¢ and 1.53¢ to 1.34¢ at five deep. A lone color page runs 3.14¢, and the tri-color set brings it to 1.95¢. The flagship set blends all four stations to 1.69¢. In round monthly terms, 10,000 black pages cost about $251 in singles and about $134 from the five-pack; 10,000 color pages cost about $314 as singles and about $195 through the tri-color set.
HP’s genuine shelf prices the same pages several times higher. The genuine black is $70.99 for the same rated 1,100 pages — about 6.45¢ a page — and each genuine color is $78.99 for 900 pages, about 8.78¢. A genuine page therefore costs roughly two and a half to three times its compatible counterpart, and a complete genuine change totals $307.96 against the flagship set’s $64.12. Our search of HP’s US store surfaced no genuine multipack for this family, so there is no genuine bundle price to set against the set discounts above.
These are desktop machines, so the volumes are household and small-office volumes — which is precisely why the per-page gap matters in a different way here. Nobody amortizes a workgroup fleet on this platform; the saving shows up as a smaller number on a single invoice, repeated every few months for the life of the printer. At the flagship’s $243.84 advantage per full change, three or four restocks recover the price of the machine itself.
The ratings agree — the first set in the box does not
On replacement cartridges, the two sources tell one story. The CF510A black is rated at roughly 1,100 pages and each color at roughly 900 under ISO/IEC 19798 — identically in the listings’ prose, in their structured yield fields, and in HP’s published data and ISO test report for the platform. The color figure is a composite: HP measures the three color cartridges working together, and publishes the family that way. No listing dissents from its siblings and no field dissents from its text, so every rate on this page rests on numbers both sources publish.
The cartridges a new machine starts on are a different matter: they are introductory. HP’s box-contents listing for the platform’s MFP line describes introductory cartridges rated at about 800 black pages and a 700-page color composite — below the 1,100 and 900 of the full-size replacements carded above. So the first replacement arrives sooner than the ratings in the table might suggest, and from that first change onward the machine lives on full-size cartridges for the rest of its life.
Genuine prices can be quoted completely here: HP’s US store still lists all four 204A cartridges, every one in stock — black at $70.99 and each color at $78.99, $307.96 in total for the four. No multipack price appears, because our search of HP’s US store found no genuine multipack to price.
There is no separate drum to budget for on this platform. Each 204A cartridge is an all-in-one unit — HP’s ISO report lists the cartridge type as “All-in-one,” and the listings say the same: the imaging drum is built into the cartridge, so a toner swap renews the drum with it. HP’s supplies list for these printers is the four cartridges and nothing else — no drum unit, no collection unit, no second consumable to plan around.
Five compact printers, one shared shelf
HP’s roster for this family runs to five models across two compact lines: the Color LaserJet Pro M154 printers and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M180/M181 multifunctions, all from the 2017 JetIntelligence generation. Every model takes all four cartridges — no machine in the roster is restricted to a subset of the family, and there is no high-yield tier for any model to be locked out of.
The printers: the Color LaserJet Pro M154a and the Color LaserJet Pro M154nw. The multifunctions: the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M180n, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M180nw, and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M181fw. Four of the five have their own category pages in this store and are linked at their names above; the M180nw is named here in full and takes exactly the same four cartridges.
Any of those five names on the front panel means the twelve offers above fit that machine — all twelve of them. And if the panel is out of sight, the cartridge that slides out settles the question on its own: CF510A, CF511A, CF512A or CF513A belongs to this family alone.
Chips: one boilerplate line, and HP’s security wording
Each listing in this family mentions a chip exactly once, inside the same parts sentence: the cartridges are built with all-new parts, the OPC drum, wiper blades and a smart chip named among them. No listing goes further — there are no firmware claims, no recognition promises and no chip-transfer instructions anywhere on this shelf — so that single sentence is the whole of what the store side says, and this guide reports it as such.
HP’s side carries more weight. Its printer pages for this platform describe a dynamic-security enabled printer, one meant to run cartridges carrying an HP original chip, and note that cartridges using a non-HP chip may not work. On the manufacturer’s own wording, then, this is a dynamic-security platform, and buyers should weigh that statement alongside the listings’ parts description rather than instead of it. The written cover behind a purchase in either case sits in the next band: twelve months of warranty on every cartridge here, with returns free across the same twelve months.
What backs every cartridge on this shelf
Matching the box to the machine’s appetite
Questions from M154 and M180/M181 owners
No. HP produced this family in a single tier only — the four 204A cartridges are the complete lineup, and no CF510X-through-CF513X range exists at HP or in this store. What you see is the whole lineup, rated at roughly 1,100 pages for black and 900 for each color.
Five, per HP: the Color LaserJet Pro M154a and M154nw, and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M180n, M180nw and M181fw. All four cartridges fit all five models — there are no model-specific carve-outs in this family.
Only in part. The five-cartridge box adds a spare to the four codes, and its own text concedes that the doubled code goes unspecified. The six-cartridge box is colors alone — no black — and gives a combined 5,400 color pages without apportioning them among cyan, yellow and magenta. The eight-cartridge box spreads across the four codes with the division left to the carton. Since none of the three itemizes its contents in full, no saving and no per-page rate is claimed for any of them on this page.
No — the first set is introductory. HP’s box-contents listing for the platform’s MFP line rates the in-box cartridges at some 800 pages of black and a 700-page color composite, against 1,100 and 900 for the full-size replacements. Expect the first replacement sooner than the headline ratings suggest; every change after that is full-size.
Neither part exists here as a separate purchase. Drum and toner are combined in one all-in-one cartridge — HP’s ISO report for these cartridges gives the type as “All-in-one” — so fitting a fresh cartridge renews both together, and HP’s supplies list for these machines names the four cartridges and nothing else.
One sentence is all any listing offers: the cartridges are built from all-new parts, with a smart chip named among the internals. HP’s own material for this platform goes further, describing dynamic-security enabled printers built for cartridges with an HP original chip, and noting that cartridges using a non-HP chip may not work. This guide reports both positions as they stand; the written cover behind a purchase is the twelve-month warranty and free returns for the same year.
The store’s compatible-cartridge terms apply: twelve months of warranty cover, free returns at any point in that year, and weekday support between 9 AM and 5 PM Central to arrange a replacement. Keep the packaging until the new cartridge is in and printing properly.
