Eight compact LaserJet Pro machines — six multifunctions from the M125, M127 and M225 lines and two single-function printers, the M201n and M201dw — share one small black cartridge that HP builds in two sizes: the 83A (CF283A, about 1,500 pages) and the high-yield 83X (CF283X, about 2,200). This store stocks the standard cartridge as a ladder of seven pack sizes and the high-yield as just two offers — a single and a 4-pack — nine listings in all, every one a compatible and every one carrying its markdown as this page is written. No model on the roster is fenced off from either tier, and the family’s strangest figure sits at the bottom of the shelf: the two singles cost exactly the same, so stepping up to the high-yield cartridge costs nothing at all.
Own any of the eight machines and both cartridges fit it — this family has no fit restriction to fence. What it has instead is a lopsided shelf. The standard tier runs seven deep, from a $23.02 single to a ten-cartridge box; the high-yield tier stops at two offers, and its opening price is the same $23.02, for a cartridge HP rates at close to half again the pages. The four-cartridge high-yield box that fronts this page prints at the same rate per page as the deepest standard box while costing $35.47 less. No genuine HP cartridge stands on this shelf; HP’s own prices appear further down for scale. What follows sets the nine offers side by side, walks the roster model by model, and reports the chip position in exactly the terms the listings leave it.
Nine offers, two tiers — one of them stops at two sizes
The nine listings divide unevenly. The standard tier is a full ladder — a single, then boxes of two, three, four, five, eight and ten — while the high-yield tier is a doorway and a box: one cartridge on its own, and a 4-pack, with nothing between them and nothing beyond. Within the standard ladder the per-cartridge price falls as the boxes deepen, from $23.02 down to $8.55. Across the tiers the pattern breaks: the high-yield single matches the standard single’s price to the cent while carrying the larger rating, and its 4-pack reaches the standard 10-pack’s page rate at a little over half of that box’s price.
Against HP’s own shelf the box’s arithmetic sharpens: a genuine 83X costs $120.99, so four of them total $483.96 — $433.91 beyond this box’s price. The rating behind the box deserves a plain word, and gets one in the yield section below: HP rates the CF283X at about 2,200 pages, and that is the figure every number on this page is built on.
Shop the 83X 4-Pack →ALSO ON THE SHELF — THE STANDARD LADDER, SEVEN SIZES
Ten at $8.55 each — the standard tier’s floor per cartridge, and a page rate only the flagship box matches.
Shop the 83A 10-Pack →
Eight at $8.95 apiece — nearly the big box’s rate, in the shelf’s only eight-cartridge size.
Shop the 83A 8-Pack →
Five at $10.16 each — and a ticket within seventy-five cents of the flagship’s, buying standard cartridges instead.
Shop the 83A 5-Pack →
Four at $10.96 each — its listing states the warranty cartridge by cartridge, in its own questions section.
Shop the 83A 4-Pack →
Three at $12.30 apiece — a working cartridge plus two spares, the size a single-machine office turns over steadily.
Shop the 83A 3-Pack →
Two at $14.99 each — the pair is also the honest comparison for HP’s genuine offer, which HP sells as a two-pack at $173.99.
Shop the 83A 2-Pack →
A single standard cartridge. Read it against the high-yield single below before buying: the price is identical, and the other cartridge is rated for about 700 more pages.
Shop the 83A Single →ALSO ON THE SHELF — THE HIGH-YIELD SINGLE
The high-yield cartridge on its own, at the standard single’s price to the cent — and two of these, at $46.04 the pair, outrun every standard box except the two deepest.
Shop the 83X Single →Read down the standard ladder and the reward for depth is steady: 1.53¢ a page at the single easing to 0.57¢ at the 10-pack, the per-cartridge price falling from $23.02 to $8.55 along the way. The high-yield side has no slope to read — two offers, at 1.05¢ and 0.57¢ — but its floor lands exactly where the standard ladder’s floor lands, and it gets there in a four-cartridge box. Put in cash: buying the ten standard cartridges one at a time, across ten separate orders, comes to $230.20; the single box is $85.52.
Nothing on this page is figured from a list price. Every rate and total starts from the sale price, the number checkout charges; the nine listings are running about thirteen percent under list as this page is written. The product pages do their own sums from list prices instead, which is why the rates printed there sit higher than the ones printed here.
Nine offers at sale prices — the table
The yield column prints HP’s ratings for both tiers — ISO/IEC 19752 approximate averages, with real output shifting as the coverage on each page changes. Totals are the cartridges inside the box added together, rates are the sale price divided by those totals, and blended flags the rows where a rate is averaged over a whole pack rather than read off a single cartridge. Every row fits every machine on the roster — this family carries no fit column because it needs none.
| Offer | Sale price | Rated yield per cartridge | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 83X 4-Pack — the flagship | $50.05 | Up to ~2,200 pages each | 0.57¢ blended | SAVE $42.03 |
| 83X Single | $23.02 | Up to ~2,200 pages | 1.05¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 83A 10-Pack | $85.52 | Up to ~1,500 pages each | 0.57¢ blended | SAVE $144.68 |
| 83A 8-Pack | $71.63 | Up to ~1,500 pages each | 0.60¢ blended | SAVE $112.53 |
| 83A 5-Pack | $50.80 | Up to ~1,500 pages each | 0.68¢ blended | SAVE $64.30 |
| 83A 4-Pack | $43.85 | Up to ~1,500 pages each | 0.73¢ blended | SAVE $48.23 |
| 83A 3-Pack | $36.91 | Up to ~1,500 pages each | 0.82¢ blended | SAVE $32.15 |
| 83A 2-Pack | $29.97 | Up to ~1,500 pages each | 1.00¢ blended | SAVE $16.07 |
| 83A Single | $23.02 | Up to ~1,500 pages | 1.53¢ | Bought one at a time |
Two comparisons do this page’s work. The two singles: identical tickets at $23.02 each, but the high-yield cartridge carries about 2,200 rated pages against the standard’s 1,500 — the same money buying close to half again the printing. And the flagship against the deepest standard box: the 83X 4-pack and the 83A 10-pack print at the same 0.57¢ a page, while the two boxes differ by $35.47 and six cartridges.
The tier step that costs nothing
Most two-tier families charge for the step up: the bigger cartridge costs more, and the buyer weighs outlay against rate before taking it. Here there is nothing to weigh at the single size. Both singles sit at $23.02, so the move from 1.53¢ a page to 1.05¢ is taken for free — the only decision the single buyer actually faces is which cartridge, not how much.
Depth then does the rest of the work, on the standard side at least: the ladder’s slope runs from 1.53¢ down to 0.57¢, each deeper box cheaper per page than the last. The high-yield side offers just one step of depth, single to 4-pack, and it is a long one — 1.05¢ to 0.57¢, level with the standard ladder’s floor. A buyer whose machine works through cartridges quickly reaches that floor fastest through the flagship box; a buyer replacing one cartridge a year loses little by simply taking the high-yield single each time.
Two ratings — and one number this page declines to use
HP rates the CF283A at about 1,500 pages and the CF283X at about 2,200, both framed the same way in its page-yield footnote: approximate average yields based on ISO/IEC 19752, with actual yield varying considerably according to the content of the pages printed. The standard listings on this shelf state HP’s 1,500 exactly, and their pack totals are plain sums of it — 3,000 for the pair, 15,000 for the ten-box.
The high-yield listings tell a different story, and this page does not follow them into it. Both 83X texts describe their cartridge at 2,500 pages — a figure HP does not publish for the CF283X anywhere. Every number on this page is therefore worked from HP’s ~2,200: the 4-pack’s total reads 8,800 pages here rather than the 10,000 the listing claims, and its rate reads 0.57¢ rather than the lower figure the listing’s own arithmetic produces. If the product pages are ever corrected, this page’s figures will not need to move.
The cartridge a new machine arrives with splits this platform in two. The M125 and M127 multifunctions ship with a shortened introductory cartridge of about 700 pages, per HP’s datasheets for those machines — the first reorder on those models comes sooner than the standard rating suggests. The M225 pair ship with the full standard cartridge, about 1,500 pages, stated in HP’s M225dw datasheet as the standard cartridge included in the box. For the M201n and M201dw this page prints no in-box figure: the number was not verified from an HP datasheet in the research behind this guide, and a starter claim will not be guessed at.
For scale, HP’s own US store prices the genuine 83X at $120.99, shown in stock on the day this page was written — a little over five times the compatible single’s sale price at the same published rating. The genuine 83A is sold there as a two-pack, the CF283AD, at $173.99; set against this shelf’s compatible pair at $29.97, the two-pack gap is $144.02.
Eight small-office machines, no exceptions
The roster is HP’s, taken from the compatibility list of its CF283A datasheet and the model tables of its machine datasheets: eight LaserJet Pro models from 2013–14, six of them multifunctions. Unusually for this store’s range, the roster carries no split — HP lists both cartridges for every machine, so the standard and high-yield offers on this page fit the whole row, and no model needs a fence of the kind other families require.
The multifunctions: the LaserJet Pro MFP M125a and LaserJet Pro MFP M125nw at the small end, the LaserJet Pro MFP M127fn and LaserJet Pro MFP M127fw above them, and the heavier-duty LaserJet Pro MFP M225dn and LaserJet Pro MFP M225dw at the top — the pair that also ships with the full-size starter cartridge.
The printers: the LaserJet Pro M201n and LaserJet Pro M201dw, the platform’s two print-only machines, taking the same pair of cartridges as everything above them.
One caution, because it sits on the product pages themselves. The two 83X listings each carry a stray legacy line in their feature lists suggesting the M125 and M127 machines are excluded — against HP’s datasheet, against the same listings’ own compatibility lines, and against their question sections. It is a garbled fragment left behind in the text, and this guide follows HP: the 83X fits all eight models. The check that settles fit, as ever, is the code printed on the cartridge coming out of the machine: CF283A and CF283X both belong in every model named above.
Chips: a single sentence on part of the shelf
Four of the nine listings here mention a chip, and each does so in the same single place: a parts sentence listing what the cartridge is built from — OPC drum, wiper blades, a smart chip and the rest of the internals. The remaining five listings never use the word. Nothing on the shelf goes further: no listing talks about firmware, and an inventory of parts is not an undertaking that a printer will accept a cartridge.
HP’s own pages add nothing to that. These are 2013–14 machines, and HP does not describe them in dynamic-security terms on any page checked for this guide — no warning to pass on, and no basis for a blocking claim in either direction. What stands behind every offer instead is remedy: a year of warranty and a year of free returns. The store’s HP monochrome toner chip compatibility page covers both of this family’s codes, CF283A and CF283X, alongside the rest of the monochrome range.
What stands behind the nine listings
Which of the nine to buy
Questions buyers ask about this family
Yes. HP’s compatibility list for this family names the same machines for both cartridges — the M125a, M125nw, M127fn, M127fw, M201n, M201dw, M225dn and M225dw — and this family carries no model restriction of the kind some others do. One wrinkle lives on the product pages: each 83X listing carries a stray legacy line suggesting the M125 and M127 machines are excluded. HP’s documents, and the listings’ own compatibility lines, say otherwise; this page follows HP.
On the figures, they simply do: both list at $26.47 and both sell at $23.02 as this page is written. This page prints the fact without dressing it in a reason it cannot source. What the fact does to the arithmetic is plain — at HP’s ratings the high-yield single prints at 1.05¢ a page against the standard single’s 1.53¢, so the tier step at single quantity is free.
No. The high-yield tier on this shelf is two offers deep: the single and the 4-pack. A buyer wanting two high-yield cartridges buys two singles for $46.04; a buyer wanting depth buys the 4-pack, whose 0.57¢ rate no pair of singles can reach.
It depends on the machine. HP’s datasheets put a shortened introductory cartridge of about 700 pages inside the M125 and M127 multifunctions, and the full standard cartridge — about 1,500 pages — inside the M225 pair. For the M201n and M201dw, no in-box figure was verified from an HP datasheet for this guide, so none is printed; owners of those two machines can read the rating off the cartridge the machine arrived with.
Because the two pages start from different prices. The rates here divide the sale price — $23.02 for either single — by HP’s rated pages. The product pages divide their list prices instead, $26.47 for the same cartridges, and so land higher. Both are honest arithmetic at different inputs; while the markdown lasts, the sale figures are the ones that describe the transaction, and if it lapses the product pages’ figures take over again.
Send it back. Each of the nine offers carries a one-year warranty and one year of free returns, and inside a multi-pack the protection follows the cartridge — a unit installed months after the box arrived is covered from its own installation, not from the delivery date. The support line runs Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central while a return is set up. Keep the box until the cartridge has earned its place; returns travel better in it.
