null

0

Your cart is empty

Best HP 655A (CF450–CF453) Toner Cartridges

BUYING GUIDE CLEVER SUPPLIES · HP 655 · THE STANDARD ROW FOR TWO MACHINE FAMILIES
Best HP 655A (CF450–CF453) Toner Cartridges

One cartridge row serves two different machine families in this generation of HP color lasers, and this guide covers it. The 655A cartridges — CF450A in black, CF451A in cyan, CF452A in yellow and CF453A in magenta — are the standard-capacity supplies for nine Color LaserJet Enterprise models: the M652dn, M652n, M653dh, M653dn and M653x printers, plus the M681dh, M681f, M681z and M682z multifunction machines, which leave HP’s factory with 655A cartridges already inside them. Above this row, HP sells two high-yield rows that stay on their own sides of the line — 656X for the printers, 657X for the MFPs, neither usable in the other family’s hardware — which leaves 655A as the generation’s one shared row. Its ratings are the smaller ones: about 12,500 pages from black and 10,500 from each color on the ISO/IEC 19798 basis, and unusually for this catalog, HP, the spec fields and the listing text all print those same figures. Buying has one wrinkle worth knowing up front: the family’s two biggest boxes, a four-color set and a five-cartridge set, are switched off in this store, so restocking every bay means the three-color set at $177.90 plus a black cartridge — $234.96 all in with the black single.

0.392¢ a page
The rate the black 2-pack delivers across its 25,000 rated pages — lower than any set on the page
$177.90 vs $1,440.96
What the flagship color set costs here, set against HP’s own store total for the four genuine singles
12,500 / 10,500
Rated pages for black and for each color — the same two numbers in HP’s data, the spec fields and the listings
9 models
Printers and MFPs alike accept all four codes; no model’s bays are partly fenced
THE SHORT VERSION

Restocking every bay takes two boxes, because the one box that would hold all four cartridges is switched off: the three-color set at $177.90, plus black — the single at $57.06 brings the total to $234.96, or take the 2-pack at $98.03 and keep a spare. Colors alone are the three-color set’s job, at $32.16 less than the three color singles bought one by one. Black alone belongs to the 2-pack: $98.03 for about 25,000 pages, 0.392¢ a page, the cheapest rate in the family. A single empty bay takes its single — $57.06 black, $70.02 per color. All of that is arithmetic at sale prices, the prices the product pages actually charge; the listings’ own text reckons from list prices nobody pays, and its sums are left out of this page. For scale, HP’s genuine singles for this row add up to $1,440.96 — the compatible four singles total $267.12.

The two boxes that lead the shelf

Six products in this family can be ordered, and the six cards here cover exactly those six — photograph, sale price and order link all belonging to the product on the card. Two further boxes exist only as switched-off listings; they are described in words further down and get no card, no link and no savings figure. A SAVE badge is earned, not decorative: it appears solely when a box undercuts the total of its own contents bought singly, and two boxes qualify, each badge naming the exact saving. The color set leads because it is the largest buyable box in the family; the black pair beside it leads on arithmetic.

★ THE FLAGSHIP · THE COLOR SIDE RENEWED — ~31,500 RATED PAGES
Compatible HP 655A (CF451A, CF453A, CF452A) Toner Cartridge 3 Color Set
Compatible HP 655A Toner Cartridges — 3 Color Set
CF451A cyan · CF452A yellow · CF453A magenta — the three colors in one box, black bought alongside
$177.90 SAVE $32.16
✓  About 31,500 rated pages across the three color bays — 10,500 per color — working out to 0.565¢ a page
✓  Costs $32.16 less than the $210.06 the three color singles add up to
✓  HP charges $1,136.97 for the three genuine color singles; this set saves $959.07 against that

Ordinarily a flagship color set would hold all four cartridges. Here the four-color box is switched off in the store, which promotes this three-color set to the largest box anyone can actually order — and it is a natural flagship anyway, because the three colors wear down together on color work while black, rated higher and used by every document, runs on its own schedule. Buy it alone to renew the colors, or add black: with the black single the pair restocks all four bays for $234.96, and with the black 2-pack the total is $275.93 with a spare black in reserve. The cartridges arrive chipped — latest-generation chips, fitted by the supplier before sealing — so fitting one is the straightforward swap the machine is built for: old cartridge out, new cartridge in, nothing transplanted from the spent unit.

Shop the 655A 3-Color Set →

THE CHEAPEST PAGES ON THE PAGE · BLACK ONLY
Compatible HP 655A (CF450A) Toner Cartridge 2 Black
Compatible HP 655A (CF450A) Toner Cartridges — Black 2 Pack
Two CF450A black cartridges — the row’s cheapest pages, by a clear margin
$98.03 SAVE $16.09
✓  About 25,000 rated pages — 12,500 from each cartridge — at 0.392¢ a page
✓  Beats two black singles bought separately ($114.12) by $16.09
✓  One genuine CF450A costs $303.99 at HP’s store — more than three of these pairs ($294.09)

On this platform black is the workhorse bay: forms, drafts and text documents all draw on it while the colors idle, and its cartridge carries the row’s highest rating. Put the highest rating together with a pair discount and the result is the family’s lowest cost per page — lower than the flagship set, lower than the black single. For a machine that empties black first and often, this is the box that keeps it fed, with the second cartridge sealed and waiting.

Shop the 655A Black 2 Pack →

Four singles, and the boxes that are not here

The rest of the shelf is four singles. The colors are interchangeable in everything but hue: $70.02 buys any one of them, and each is rated at 10,500 pages, so the only decision is which bay the machine says is empty. Black breaks the symmetry — $57.06, cheaper than any color, yet rated 2,000 pages higher, which is why its per-page figure beats theirs. One caution before ordering from the digits: HP’s code order in this row is black, cyan, yellow, magenta, so CF452A is yellow and CF453A is magenta — settled on HP’s own product pages, whatever order the rainbow suggests. Note, too, that a single color can only be bought as a single: the family’s only color bundle is the three-color box, so there is no smaller color set to step down to.

THE FOUR SINGLES — BLACK $57.06, EACH COLOR $70.02

Compatible HP 655A (CF450A) Toner Cartridge Black
655A Black · CF450A
▦ A single cartridge · ~12,500 rated pages · 0.457¢ a page · all nine roster models
$57.06

The fastest-moving bay on document-heavy machines, and the best single buy here: 12,500 rated pages put it at 0.457¢ a page, clear of every color single. Against HP’s genuine CF450A at $303.99, it is also the family’s biggest single-cartridge price gap — the genuine article costs over five times as much for the same rated output.

Shop the 655A Black →
Compatible HP 655A (CF451A) Toner Cartridge Cyan
655A Cyan · CF451A
▦ A single cartridge · ~10,500 rated pages · 0.667¢ a page · all nine roster models
$70.02

The 1-code opens the color sequence. Price and rating match its two color siblings exactly, so there is nothing to weigh: when the machine calls for cyan, this cartridge is the answer.

Shop the 655A Cyan →
Compatible HP 655A (CF452A) Toner Cartridge Yellow
655A Yellow · CF452A
▦ A single cartridge · ~10,500 rated pages · 0.667¢ a page · all nine roster models
$70.02

Yellow holds the 2-code in this row — HP puts it before magenta, rainbow order notwithstanding. Order from the code-and-color pairings on these cards and on the cartridge you take out, not from where a color sits in the spectrum.

Shop the 655A Yellow →

Compatible HP 655A (CF453A) Toner Cartridge Magenta
655A Magenta · CF453A
▦ A single cartridge · ~10,500 rated pages · 0.667¢ a page · all nine roster models
$70.02

Magenta closes the sequence at CF453A, though it sits third in the machine’s color order. Fitted alone, it brings back reds and skin tones while leaving three bays that still have pages in them undisturbed.

Shop the 655A Magenta →

Two boxes are missing from this shelf, deliberately. A four-color set and a five-cartridge set for this family exist as store listings, but both are switched off — set invisible and disabled, so neither can be ordered — and for that reason neither appears as a card or a link on this page. The practical consequence is the one priced throughout this guide: no single buyable box holds all four colors, so a full restock pairs the three-color set with a black cartridge. The catalog gives no reason for the switch-off, so this page invents none. The five-cartridge set has a further gap: it names four codes across five cartridges without ever saying which code repeats, describing the extra unit only as a spare, so its exact contents cannot be stated.

The whole buyable shelf on one price basis

One method prices every row: the sale price from the product’s own page, divided by the pages the box is rated for — 12,500 per black cartridge, 10,500 per color. Rows for sets say pooled, because their page totals span several bays; that is the fair way to compare boxes with each other, while the cost of one printed page is worked out separately in the notes after the table. The two switched-off sets are absent from the rows entirely. Cheapest first:

Configuration Sale price Rated pages Cost per page Printer fit
655A Black 2-Pack $98.03 2 cartridges · ~25,000 pages 0.392¢ All 9 models
655A Black Single $57.06 1 cartridge · ~12,500 pages 0.457¢ All 9 models
655A 3-Color Set — the flagship $177.90 3 cartridges · ~31,500 pages 0.565¢ pooled All 9 models
655A Cyan Single $70.02 1 cartridge · ~10,500 pages 0.667¢ All 9 models
655A Yellow Single $70.02 1 cartridge · ~10,500 pages 0.667¢ All 9 models
655A Magenta Single $70.02 1 cartridge · ~10,500 pages 0.667¢ All 9 models

Two sums hide in this table, and they answer different questions. Pooled figures price boxes. On that measure the black pair comes first, because black pairs the row’s biggest rating with its lowest running cost — two blacks undercut even the flagship set per page. A printed page is another matter: a full-color page draws on all four bays, so its toner cost stacks the four single rates — 0.457¢ of black and 0.667¢ from each color, about 2.46¢ altogether at the coverage the ratings assume. Real office pages lay down far less color than that, so treat 2.46¢ as the ratings’ ceiling rather than a meter reading. The four singles as a group — $267.12 for about 44,000 pooled pages, 0.607¢ a page — land between the pair and the color singles, exactly where an average of one cheap black and three pricier colors should land.

HP’s US store sells this row one way only — as singles — so the genuine side needs no pooling: $303.99 for the CF450A black, $378.99 for each of CF451A, CF452A and CF453A, $1,440.96 for all four. Side by side, a genuine black costs about five and a third times its compatible counterpart, and a genuine color about five and four-tenths times. Or take the restock this guide recommends — three-color set plus black single, $234.96 — and it undercuts the genuine four by $1,206.00. Even the flagship set alone, at $177.90, falls $201.09 short of buying a single genuine color cartridge from HP.

Nine machines, two families, one row

HP publishes this row’s fit at series level — Color LaserJet Enterprise M652, M653, M681 and M682 — and nine models stand under those four names. The printers are the M652dn, M652n, M653dh, M653dn and M653x; the multifunction machines are the M681dh, M681f and the Flow models M681z and M682z. Every one of the nine accepts every one of the four codes: no model takes black but not a color, and the Flow variants hold no code in reserve. That is what makes this row unusual — one cartridge stock can serve a printer in one room and an MFP in another, and a set can be divided between machine types without stranding a cartridge.

The listings phrase this loosely, calling out “M681” and “M682” as though they were further printers; they are series names, and the roster above is the nine real models. But loose phrasing is all it is — the underlying claims check out against HP. HP’s cartridge pages name the M681 and M682 lines as compatible, HP’s page for the M681dh lists CF450A among its replacement cartridges, and the MFPs are delivered with 655A cartridges installed. Anyone who has seen cross-platform claims collapse elsewhere in this catalog may doubt these on sight; here, unusually, they hold. Where series-level references occur, the M681 and M682 names link to their series categories.

The store’s filing matches that roster exactly. Every product in the family sits under all nine model categories and both MFP series categories, so a buyer who starts from any one machine’s category page finds the whole row — black, colors and both buyable boxes — rather than a subset of it. In a catalog where filing gaps are common enough to form a defect class of their own, this family’s filing is complete, and the roster links above lead to those same categories.

The boundaries that do exist sit between rows, not inside this one. The 656X high-yield row (CF460X–CF463X) fits the five printers and nothing else; the 657X high-yield row (CF470X–CF473X) fits the four MFPs and nothing else; neither crosses over, in either direction. 655A is the only row of the three that crosses. And inside any box, nothing binds the cartridges together: fit one today and the rest next quarter, run a new black beside aging colors, split a set between two machines — a set is a way of pricing cartridges, not a unit the machine inspects. If a code printed on a cartridge ever conflicts with a code in a listing, believe the cartridge.

One rating per code, agreed everywhere

On yields, this family is the quiet one. HP rates the CF450A black at about 12,500 pages and each color at about 10,500, the color figure being HP’s composite average over cyan, yellow and magenta under the ISO/IEC 19798 test method. The listings carry those numbers in their spec fields — this family, unlike the generation’s X rows, has real custom fields — and their prose repeats them rather than quietly substituting smaller ones. With HP, field and prose in agreement, the divisions on this page run on 12,500 and 10,500 exactly as printed. The pack totals are simple multiples: 25,000 pages in the black pair, 31,500 in the three-color set, roughly 44,000 across the four singles.

Ratings describe test pages, not your documents, and the bays empty at the speed your work dictates. Black’s 2,000-page edge is real but small next to usage: an office copying forms all day will burn through black long before the colors move, while a team proofing color work can empty a color first. Use the ratings as the shared ruler the prices were divided by — that is what they are for.

The composite color figure deserves one clarification. 10,500 is HP’s average across the three colors, not a promise about any single bay: a workload heavy in one color — presentation charts full of cyan, say — drains that bay sooner, while a color the documents barely touch can outlast the rating. Black’s figure is a single-cartridge rating, which makes the black numbers in this guide the firmer ones; the colors are priced and compared on the composite, because that is the only basis HP publishes for them.

Chips on a row that crosses two machine families

Because one cartridge serves nine machines, the chip question here is whether a single chip design can satisfy printers and MFPs alike. The supplier’s practice across this store’s compatible range answers it: units leave sealed with the newest chip generation available, and in Clever Supplies’ selling record no chip complaint has surfaced. Fitting stays a plain mechanical exchange — spent cartridge out, fresh cartridge in — with no step where a chip is pried off the old unit and reused. These are fleet machines, commonly administered, firmware-managed and reporting their toner levels, so the chip does real work; the same one serves the copy-room printer and the corridor MFP.

The assurance has a boundary, and it is printed rather than implied. It speaks for cartridges as supplied today and for the record so far; firmware HP has not yet written cannot be warranted against by anyone selling today, and this page does not pretend otherwise. The family’s own listings say nothing about chips or firmware at all, so the store’s position is stated here, where a buyer will actually read it.

Warranty, returns and support

The same terms cover every box in the family, flagship set and lone single alike, so they are set out once here instead of trailing every card.

✓ 1-Year Warranty
Should a cartridge fail inside twelve months of delivery, its product page’s warranty terms apply
✓ 1-Year Free Returns
Returns cost nothing for a full year after delivery — twelve months of cover, not the thirty-day norm
✓ Weekday Support
A person, not a script, answers questions Monday to Friday between 9 AM and 5 PM Central
✓ Four US Warehouses
Stock ships from Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia or California, whichever warehouse best serves the address

Choosing the box

✓Every bay is running low — or a machine is being stocked from empty: three-color set plus black. With the black single the bill is $234.96; with the 2-pack it is $275.93 and a spare black remains. No buyable four-color box exists, so this pairing is the full restock.
✓Black runs out first, repeatedly: the black 2-pack. $98.03 for roughly 25,000 pages — 0.392¢ a page, the family’s lowest rate, sets included.
✓Colors faded together, black still going: the three-color set. $177.90 renews cyan, yellow and magenta at 0.565¢ pooled, without buying black before its time.
✓One bay empty, three still working: that bay’s single. $57.06 for CF450A black, $70.02 for a color — and order by the pairing on the card, since this row’s colors run cyan, yellow, magenta by code.
✓Keeping spares for a mixed fleet: sets and pairs, split freely. Any cartridge fits any of the nine models, printers and MFPs alike, so one box can feed two machines bay by bay. Leave the two switched-off sets out of the plan — they cannot be ordered.

Questions from M652, M653, M681 and M682 owners

Will a 655A cartridge fit my M681 MFP?

Yes, on HP’s word rather than the store’s. HP’s own cartridge pages list the M681 and M682 lines among the machines these cartridges work with, the M681dh’s printer page names CF450A as a replacement cartridge, and the MFPs ship with 655A cartridges installed. The row is the standard capacity for all nine models of the generation — five printers, four MFPs — with every code fitting every model.

Which code is yellow — CF452A or CF453A?

CF452A. HP’s product pages assign yellow to the 2-code and magenta to CF453A, and the store’s product names agree. The full sequence is CF450A black, CF451A cyan, CF452A yellow, CF453A magenta — cyan-yellow-magenta order, not the rainbow’s. Order from the pairings on the cards, and check the new cartridge’s code against the one you remove.

Why is there no four-color set to buy?

Two such boxes exist on paper — a four-color set and a five-cartridge set are listed in the store — but both are switched off, invisible and disabled, so neither can be ordered, and neither is carded or linked on this page. The catalog states no reason, so this guide offers none. The priced workaround stands: three-color set plus black, $234.96 with the single, $275.93 with the 2-pack.

What is the difference between 655A, 656X and 657X?

Capacity, and which machines each row serves. 655A is the standard row — about 12,500 pages black, 10,500 per color — and the only row fitting both platforms. 656X is high-yield for the five printers alone (about 27,000 black, 22,000 per color); 657X is high-yield for the four MFPs alone (about 28,000 black, 23,000 per color); neither X row fits the other family’s machines. Maximum pages per cartridge means stepping up to your machine type’s X row; one shared stock for printers and MFPs means staying here.

The listings name “M681” and “M682” as printers. Are they models?

No — M681 and M682 are the series names HP files the machines under. The models themselves are the M652dn, M652n, M653dh, M653dn and M653x printers and the M681dh, M681f, M681z and M682z MFPs, nine in total, and all four codes fit all nine. The listings print the series names beside the models, which inflates their fit lists to eleven names; the claims behind the names are nonetheless accurate.

Can I split a set between my M653 printer and my M681 MFP?

Yes — that is this row’s special property. Every 655A cartridge fits both platforms, so a three-color set can put cyan in the printer and yellow and magenta in the MFP, and a black 2-pack divides the same way. The trick is impossible one row up: 656X cartridges fit only the printers and 657X only the MFPs, so an X-row box belongs to one machine family or the other, never both.

What warranty and return period do these cartridges carry?

A year of each. Warranty cover lasts twelve months from delivery, and returns are free across the same twelve months, on the terms stated on the family’s product pages. Support is staffed by people on weekdays, 9 AM to 5 PM Central, and orders leave from warehouses in Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and California.

Price and disclosure note: Every price above is a sale price, taken from the carded product’s own page in the live catalog and checked again there on November 18, 2026; should a price change afterwards, the product page is the authority. Sale prices drive all the arithmetic here, deliberately: the listings’ prose instead reckons from list prices, which exceed what any buyer is charged. A SAVE badge certifies one narrow thing — the difference between a set’s price and the sale-price total of its contents bought singly. Two badges appear: $32.16 on the three-color set, $16.09 on the black 2-pack. The switched-off sets get none, being unorderable, and exact savings require an exact, buyable box. Yields are HP’s declared figures — about 12,500 pages for CF450A, 10,500 per color, the color number being HP’s ISO/IEC 19798 composite average — echoed by the listings in field and prose; set totals are marked pooled wherever they appear, because no real page empties its bays in step. Genuine prices come from HP’s US store, which sells this row as singles only: $303.99 for CF450A, $378.99 for each color, $1,440.96 for the four, all read from HP’s product pages on November 18, 2026, each cartridge in stock there. Fit rests on HP’s published compatibility — the M652dn, M652n, M653dh, M653dn, M653x, M681dh, M681f, M681z and M682z, four codes across nine models. The untidy remainder belongs to the store’s catalog, not HP’s data, and follows.

First, a production prompt sits on the storefront. Each of the eight descriptions opens with the raw instructions the text was generated from — a keyword string, then the direction to write under 2,000 characters using every keyword and to vary each paragraph’s opening word, signed “ChatGPT” — ahead of any copy meant for a customer. It heads all eight listings and is the family’s most visible defect. Second, money is discussed at list. Where the product pages talk price, they quote $65.62 for black, $80.52 per color, $112.73 for the pair, $204.59 for the color set and $275.52 and $328.08 for the two switched-off sets, although checkout charges the lower sale prices — and the per-page figures beside those numbers are computed from list, inflating the stated cost of printing: the black single’s “roughly 0.5 cents per page” at list is 0.457¢ at its $57.06 sale price. Third, the two biggest sets are off. Both the four-color set and the five-cartridge set sit invisible and disabled despite healthy stock on each, leaving no buyable box with all four colors inside; restocking every bay therefore means combining the three-color set with a black cartridge, as priced in this guide. Fourth, those sets misstate their yields in the spec field: on both, the field reads “Black: 10500” — the color rating parked under black, whose true rating is 12,500 — and neither set shows a color yield line at all, though their prose gives the correct numbers and this guide’s arithmetic follows the prose. Fifth, the five-cartridge set’s contents cannot be pinned down: four codes are named for five cartridges, the repeat is never identified, and the copy frames the extra unit only as a spare for whichever bay empties first. Sixth, sales history is essentially blank — seven listings record no sale and the black single records one — so this page makes no claim about what sells. Seventh, there is no family shelf to browse: no “HP 655A” category exists, and the products file under brand, color series and model categories only. Eighth, every SKU in the family contains a space (“CS-HP 655A-BK” and its siblings) — cosmetic, uniform, recorded for completeness. And one apparent error that is not one: the listings’ M681 and M682 fit claims, which look like contamination, are correct per HP — this standard row genuinely serves the MFPs, unlike the platform-locked X rows.

Six cards above, six products that can be ordered — the family’s complete buyable shelf, with nothing held back: this census family has no duplicates to collapse and no disputed listing to set aside, and its two unorderable sets are handled in prose because they cannot be bought. No fit claim here reaches beyond HP’s nine models, and no yield is printed above or below what HP declares and the listings repeat. On chips, the assurance and its limit stand together: cartridges arrive with the newest chip generation fitted and the record to date is clean, and there the promise stops — firmware that does not yet exist is not underwritten. Beneath it all sit the terms the listings themselves publish: a year’s warranty, a year’s free returns, people answering Monday to Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM Central, and dispatch from warehouses in Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and California.