Five cartridges serve this family, and they split along a single seam. Four carry the standard 312A badge — the CF380A black, the CF381A cyan, the CF382A yellow and the CF383A magenta — and the fifth is a longer-lasting black, the CF380X, sold under the 312X name. No high-yield color exists for this platform — HP never issued one, and none is stocked here — so the X sits on the black station alone. Below, those five cartridges are arranged into fourteen offers: five sets, five singles and four black multi-packs, each of them on sale at the time of writing. Two of the sets are described by their listings without a full contents count, and this guide says so on their cards rather than guessing.
Start with the mixed four-color set at $73.01. It pairs the high-yield CF380X black with the three standard colors, undercuts the same four cartridges bought singly by $48.23, and holds roughly 12,500 rated pages — a blended 0.58¢ a page. Thirty-five cents cheaper, the all-standard set at $72.66 swaps in the 2,400-page black and lands at 0.69¢ blended. Color is the simple side of the shelf: $30.53 for any single color, less per page from the tri-color set. Black is where the ladder lives — from the standard single at 1.22¢ a page down through two pack ladders to the four-pack of high-yield blacks at 0.40¢, the cheapest black page in the family. The two sets whose contents are not fully enumerated are flagged where they sit, with the reason printed on the card.
Sets lead, singles follow, black packs close the shelf
The shelf is laid out the way these boxes are usually bought. Sets come first — the flagship’s high-yield black leading and its all-standard counterpart thirty-five cents behind it. After the sets come the five singles; the four black packs, two per black tier, close the section. The ratings on the cards are the ones the listings carry: about 4,400 pages from the CF380X black, 2,400 from the CF380A black, and about 2,700 from each color. Two set cards carry a caveat in place of a saving badge, because their listings stop short of a full contents count; each card explains itself.
HP sells no genuine 312 four-pack. Bought as genuine singles, the same restock costs $169.99 for the CF380X black and $186.99 for each color — $730.96 in all. This set covers the same four stations at the same published ratings for $657.95 less.
Shop the Flagship Mixed Set →THE OTHER THIRTEEN OFFERS
The same four stations restocked on standard cartridges throughout — the 2,400-page black with the three colors, thirty-five cents under the flagship and $48.23 under the singles it replaces.
Shop the 312A 4-Color Set →
The three colors on their own, for a machine whose black still has pages in it. HP’s genuine equivalent, the CF440AM tri-color pack, costs $503.99 — against $59.44 here for the same three stations. Colors only — despite a name that lists all four codes, the box holds no black, exactly as its own FAQ states.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
The listing counts eight cartridges across the four codes — two full rounds of toner, on the natural reading — but never divides the eight by color. Until it does, the price stands here with no saving and no per-page rate claimed.
Shop the 8 Color Set →
Four are accounted for; the fifth doubles one of them, and which one is left to the carton label read on arrival. With the contents unsettled, this guide prints the price and claims neither a saving nor a rate.
Shop the 5 Color Set →
The standard black sold singly — the cartridge the two standard-black packs below are built from, and the reference point for the yield note further down this page.
Shop the Black Single →
Thirty-five cents above the standard black buys 2,000 extra rated pages — the sharpest single-cartridge value on the shelf, and the only 312X cartridge HP makes.
Shop the 312X Black Single →
A single cyan at the family’s flat color price — one cartridge for the station the printer says is low.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Yellow on its own, at the same price as the cyan and magenta beside it — no station in this row costs more than the others.
Shop the Yellow Single →
Magenta on its own completes the color row — three singles, one shared price, one shared rating of about 2,700 pages.
Shop the Magenta Single →
One for the machine, one in reserve — together $16.09 cheaper than buying the two blacks singly.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →
Three standard blacks in one box, $32.17 under the three singles — the upper rung of the standard-black ladder.
Shop the 3 Black Pack →
The high-yield ladder opens here: two CF380X cartridges at $16.07 under the pair of singles, each rated at about 4,400 pages.
Shop the 312X 2 Black Pack →
The deepest black stock-up in the family — four high-yield cartridges, $48.22 under the four singles, and the cheapest black page this shelf offers.
Shop the 312X 4 Black Pack →One feature of the family’s shape deserves a sentence of its own. The X tier reaches no further than the black station — CF380X is the sole X cartridge in existence here — so a set built around the long-life black necessarily fills its color slots with standard cartridges, as the flagship does. Beyond that, the numbers behave as buyers expect: every set whose contents are fully stated undercuts its own singles bought separately, the three colors share a single price, and the high-yield black adds 2,000 rated pages for thirty-five cents over the standard.
Rates throughout this guide are worked out from sale prices, the amounts actually charged. A product page may quote its own arithmetic from the higher list prices, so its figures can sit above the ones here; the closing note sets out which basis each number uses.
Fourteen offers, side by side
Declared yields are averages from standardized tests, and real coverage moves them — a month of presentation decks burns color in a way a month of memos never will. For boxes holding several cartridges, page totals add the individual ratings, and the blended rate divides the total into the sale price. There is no fit column, deliberately: all three printers named further down accept every row, leaving tier, box size and rate as the only decisions.
| Offer | Sale price | Box contents | Cost per page | Saving vs buying singly |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 312X & 312A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $73.01 | CF380X black with the three colors · ~12,500 pages | 0.58¢ blended | SAVE $48.23 |
| 312A 4-Color Set | $72.66 | One cartridge per station, all standard · ~10,500 pages | 0.69¢ blended | SAVE $48.23 |
| 312A Tri-Color Set | $59.44 | Cyan, yellow and magenta · ~8,100 pages | 0.73¢ | SAVE $32.15 |
| 312A 8 Color Set | $129.24 | 8 cartridges over the four codes — counts per color not stated | Not claimed | Not claimed |
| 312A 5 Color Set | $85.87 | Four stations plus one unidentified double | Not claimed | Not claimed |
| 312A Black Single (CF380A) | $29.30 | 1 black · ~2,400 pages | 1.22¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 312X Black Single (CF380X) | $29.65 | 1 high-yield black · ~4,400 pages | 0.67¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 312A Cyan Single (CF381A) | $30.53 | 1 cyan · ~2,700 pages | 1.13¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 312A Yellow Single (CF382A) | $30.53 | 1 yellow · ~2,700 pages | 1.13¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 312A Magenta Single (CF383A) | $30.53 | 1 magenta · ~2,700 pages | 1.13¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 312A 2 Black Pack | $42.51 | 2 standard black · ~4,800 pages | 0.89¢ | SAVE $16.09 |
| 312A 3 Black Pack | $55.73 | 3 standard black · ~7,200 pages | 0.77¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
| 312X 2 Black Pack | $43.23 | 2 high-yield black · ~8,800 pages | 0.49¢ | SAVE $16.07 |
| 312X 4 Black Pack | $70.38 | 4 high-yield black · ~17,600 pages | 0.40¢ | SAVE $48.22 |
Two rows read “Not claimed”, deliberately. The 8-color set’s listing never divides its eight by color, and the 5-color set never names its doubled cartridge, so this guide asserts neither a saving nor a rate for either — the prices stand, and the claims wait for the listings to say more. Every remaining row can be verified against the singles carded above, line by line.
The per-page ladder, black and color
Black first, because black is where this family spreads out. The standard single runs 1.22¢ a page, and its packs step downward — 0.89¢ in the pair, 0.77¢ in the three-pack. The high-yield side undercuts all of it: 0.67¢ from the CF380X single, 0.49¢ from its two-pack, and 0.40¢ from the four-pack, the cheapest black page in the family. Color is flatter: any single runs 1.13¢, the tri-color set 0.73¢. Across a complete restock, the mixed set blends to 0.58¢ and the all-standard set to 0.69¢.
Put in monthly terms: 5,000 mostly-text pages run to about $61 of black toner when bought as standard singles, about $34 as high-yield singles, and about $20 from the four-black X pack. The standard-versus-high-yield call on this shelf is worth roughly twenty-seven dollars per five thousand black pages — decided, unusually, by a thirty-five-cent difference between two single cartridges.
Ratings for the five cartridges — and the black carrying two figures
These yields are declared under ISO/IEC 19798, colors as a composite: about 4,400 pages for the CF380X black, about 2,700 for each color, and 2,400 for the standard CF380A black. Treat them as planning averages rather than promises — how long any cartridge lasts is settled by coverage. The store’s record here is unusually tidy: all twenty-six listings in the family state identical figures in their texts, and their structured page-yield fields match the texts.
The family’s one disagreement is between HP and itself. The 2,400 figure is the launch declaration, carried by the platform datasheet and HP’s printer pages; HP’s current US page for the CF380A cartridge reads about 2,280 instead. Neither number belongs to the store. The guide names the split here and bases every CF380A calculation on the listings’ 2,400; worked on 2,280, the standard black’s rates per page would come out roughly five percent higher.
A new M476 starts well below all of these numbers, and starts there on every station at once. HP’s box contents for the M476nw list preinstalled introductory black, cyan, yellow and magenta cartridges at about 1,200 pages each, and HP’s ISO test report for those introductory cartridges declares the same 1,200-page averages formally. So the first replacement round arrives early and arrives together — and the first full set fitted is a clear step up, to 10,500 rated pages in the all-standard set or 12,500 in the flagship’s mix.
For scale: genuine singles at HP’s US store run $140.99 (standard black), $169.99 (high-yield black) and $186.99 per color. Four standard genuine singles total $701.96; swapping in the high-yield black makes $730.96. HP’s genuine tri-color pack, the CF440AM, costs $503.99. A genuine 312X dual pack, the CF380XD, exists in HP’s documents, but no US price for it could be retrieved, so none is printed.
There is no drum chapter to this platform’s story. HP’s test documentation classifies the cartridges as all-in-one units with the imaging drum inside, and its supplies list for the M476 names nothing else a user replaces. When a cartridge is spent, its drum leaves with it; the next cartridge brings a new drum of its own.
Three printers share all five cartridges
HP states this family’s compatibility by machine, and the machine list is as short as they come: the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M476 series, launched in 2014 in three models. Fit, though, could not be simpler: each of the three models accepts all five cartridges, both tiers included. Nothing here is restricted — no model is colors-only, none is shut out of the X black.
The three, in full: the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M476nw, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M476dn and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M476dw.
The roster and its names are HP’s own. With the machine in front of you, the label on the spent cartridge settles the question: any code in the CF380–CF383 run belongs to this shelf — the A codes across all four stations, the X on black alone.
On chips and firmware, silence in both directions
Begin with the seller’s record, because there is almost none to report: the word “chip” appears nowhere in any of the family’s twenty-six listings. Nothing is claimed about recognition, nothing promised or warned about firmware — the product pages stick to prices, ratings and written terms.
HP’s side is barely louder. A 2014 platform predates the dynamic-security program entirely, and HP’s M476 pages contain no blocking language and no firmware warnings aimed at cartridges — the security documented there is the printer’s own network security. This guide therefore claims nothing in either direction — no chip asserted for these cartridges, no blocking asserted against them. What a buyer can actually rely on is the cover the listings print: a twelve-month warranty and twelve months of free returns.
What stands behind each cartridge
Matching the box to the workload
Answers to the questions this shelf raises
Thirty-five cents and the black cartridge. The flagship at $73.01 carries the high-yield CF380X black, rated at about 4,400 pages; the set at $72.66 carries the standard CF380A, rated at 2,400. Colors are the same three cartridges in both boxes, and each set undercuts its own four singles by $48.23 at sale prices — the page pools land at about 12,500 against about 10,500.
No — the X tier is a single cartridge, the black CF380X. HP’s catalog holds no CF381X, CF382X or CF383X, and the store stocks none; every color in this family wears the 312A badge and the same ~2,700-page rating.
Because a saving can only be measured against a contents list, and neither listing provides a complete one. The 8-color set’s eight cartridges are never divided by color; the 5-color set’s fifth cartridge is a double whose identity the listing leaves to the carton label. Both sets are therefore shown with prices only — no saving, no per-page rate — until their listings say more.
Both figures are HP’s. The launch declaration, the platform datasheet and the printer pages say 2,400; the current US cartridge page reads about 2,280. The listings use 2,400, and this guide follows them — the split is set out in the yields section above. On the lower figure, the standard black’s rates per page would rise by roughly five percent.
Introductory cartridges at every station. For the M476nw, HP’s box contents list preinstalled introductory black, cyan, yellow and magenta cartridges at about 1,200 pages each, and HP’s ISO test report for those cartridges declares the same averages. The first full set fitted afterwards is a step up — to the standard ratings, or to the high-yield black’s roughly 4,400.
Nothing in either record raises the question. No listing claims a chip, and HP’s documentation for this 2014 platform — which predates its dynamic-security program — contains no cartridge-blocking language at all. The guide asserts nothing either way; what a buyer holds is the printed cover: a twelve-month warranty, with free returns across the same twelve months.
Three models in one series: the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M476nw, M476dn and M476dw. All five cartridges are listed by HP as replacements for each of the three — no model is limited to one tier or one station.
The terms printed on the listing apply: the cartridge is covered for twelve months, and returns are free across the same period. Support is reachable on weekdays (9 AM to 5 PM Central) and can set a return in motion — keep the box until the replacement has printed a clean test page.
