Four cartridges run this entire platform, and HP gave all four of them the same badge. The CB540A black, CB541A cyan, CB542A yellow and CB543A magenta feed the Color LaserJet CP1215, CP1217, CP1515n and CP1518ni printers and the two CM1312 multifunctions, and there is no second tier standing behind any of them — no high-yield row, no station wearing a different number, no bigger cartridge waiting one step up. The store lists these four cartridges twenty-one ways, but the shelf underneath the repetition holds just eight distinct configurations: a four-color set, a tri-color set, a five-cartridge box, the four singles and a two-black pack, with the flagship set carried under two listings at the identical price. The numbers need no arbitration either, because the listings, their yield fields and HP’s own product pages all settle on the same pair — about 2,200 pages from the black, about 1,400 from each color. Every offer carded below is a compatible; HP’s genuine cartridges still exist for this platform, and their prices are printed further down for scale.
The four-color set at $66.03 is where most owners should start: it restocks every station at once, undercuts the four singles bought separately by $48.22, and works out to 1.03¢ a page blended across its 6,400 rated pages. The same set is carried under a second listing at the same $66.03 and the same stock level, and it is carded below as an alternate — either listing delivers the identical box. When the black is still going, the tri-color set at $51.80 renews cyan, yellow and magenta together and saves $32.14 against the color singles. The singles themselves are plainly priced: $30.31 for the black, $27.98 for each color, and the two-black pack at $44.54 posts the family’s lowest rate at 1.01¢. One box is priced with a warning attached — the five-cartridge set at $80.26, whose listing never identifies its fifth cartridge, so no saving and no per-page figure is claimed for it anywhere on this page.
Eight configurations behind twenty-one listings
Strip away the model-named repeats and the shelf resolves into eight ways to buy: two listings of the same four-color set, the tri-color set, the five-cartridge box, the four singles in code order — CB540A through CB543A — and the two-black pack. Seven of the eight configurations state exactly what is inside them, codes counted and named, and their savings below are measured against the singles at sale prices. The exception flags itself on its own card: the five-cartridge set’s listing, asked directly which cartridges it covers, names only the four standard codes and never says what the fifth one is, so that box is priced exactly as sold and nothing is derived from it. The ratings underneath every figure are the agreed pair — roughly 2,200 pages for a black cartridge, roughly 1,400 for a color.
Set this beside HP’s own shelf and the gap widens further: one of each genuine cartridge at HP’s US store totals $453.96. The flagship renews the whole machine for $387.93 less than that, at the same published ratings.
Shop the 4-Color Set →THE REMAINING EIGHT LISTINGS
A twin of the flagship in every measurable respect — same four codes, same $66.03 tag, same stock count on the shelf. Nothing separates the two listings but the page you order from, so the choice between them costs nothing either way.
Shop the Alternate 4-Color Set →
The color stations renewed together while the black keeps printing. Buying the three colors as a set trims $32.14 off their combined single price and pulls the color page down from 2.00¢ to 1.23¢. HP sells a genuine pack of the same three colors under the code CF373AM, though no US price for it could be retrieved.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
Asked which cartridges this box covers, its own listing names the four standard codes and calls the name simply the label for a larger restock box — the extra cartridge stays anonymous. With the contents only partly stated, the box’s page total cannot be fixed, so it is carded at its price with no saving and no rate attached.
Shop the 5-Color Set →
The cartridge this platform burns through first, priced $2.33 above the colors — a modest premium that its extra 800 rated pages more than repay, since its 1.38¢ page still undercuts every color single.
Shop the Black Single →
Cyan on its own for the station that ran dry first. If the other two colors are close behind it, the tri-color set above replaces all three for $32.14 less than the singles would.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Yellow at the shared color price, with the shared color rating. The three color singles are interchangeable as purchases — whichever station the printer is asking for is the one to order.
Shop the Yellow Single →
Magenta completes the color row at the same $27.98. A budget drawn up for one color single in this family is, to the cent, a budget for any of them.
Shop the Magenta Single →
One black in the machine and one on the shelf, for $16.08 less than the pair bought singly — and at 1.01¢ it prints the cheapest page in the family. Its SKU is built on CB540AD, the code of HP’s own genuine black dual pack.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →Notice how the color side is priced. The three color singles sit in perfect parity at $27.98, and HP’s genuine shelf inverts the usual pattern in the same direction — its colors, at $110.99 each, actually cost less than its $120.99 black. What separates the stations here is never the color’s price; it is the black’s larger rating, which is why the black rows keep winning the per-page column despite the black single carrying the shelf’s highest single price.
Every rate on this page is divided out of a sale price — what the checkout charges today. Some of the listings below run their own in-text arithmetic from list prices instead, so the figures printed on those pages sit higher; the closing note separates the two bases.
The nine carded listings in one view
Each rate below comes from the same recipe: total the rated pages of the cartridges in the box, then divide the sale price by that total. One row is deliberately left blank in the rate column — the five-cartridge set never fully states its contents, so no defensible total exists for it. Compatibility needs no column of its own, since every row fits all six printers named further down. Read the ratings as planning figures rather than promises: dense color coverage drains a cartridge faster than the test standard assumes, and light coverage stretches it further.
| Offer | Sale price | What is in the box | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 125A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $66.03 | Black, cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~6,400 pages | 1.03¢ blended | SAVE $48.22 |
| 125A 4-Color Set — Alternate Listing | $66.03 | Black, cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~6,400 pages | 1.03¢ blended | SAVE $48.22 |
| 125A Tri-Color Set | $51.80 | Cyan, yellow and magenta · ~4,200 pages | 1.23¢ | SAVE $32.14 |
| 125A 5-Color Set | $80.26 | Five cartridges across the four codes — fifth cartridge not identified | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 125A Black Single (CB540A) | $30.31 | 1 black · ~2,200 pages | 1.38¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 125A Cyan Single (CB541A) | $27.98 | 1 cyan · ~1,400 pages | 2.00¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 125A Yellow Single (CB542A) | $27.98 | 1 yellow · ~1,400 pages | 2.00¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 125A Magenta Single (CB543A) | $27.98 | 1 magenta · ~1,400 pages | 2.00¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 125A 2 Black Pack | $44.54 | 2 black · ~4,400 pages | 1.01¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
Read it from the bottom up and the family’s logic shows itself: the plainest box on the page, two blacks in a pack, prints the cheapest page at 1.01¢, because black does most of the work in these machines and carries the biggest rating. The flagship’s blended 1.03¢ sits a hair behind it while also renewing three color stations the black pack never touches — the two rows are not rivals so much as answers to different toner warnings.
What a page costs — and what HP charges for the same page
On the compatible shelf the ladder is compact. Black pages run 1.38¢ from a single and 1.01¢ from the two-pack; color pages run 2.00¢ as singles and 1.23¢ through the tri-color set; a full four-station renewal from either four-color listing blends both sides to 1.03¢. In working terms, 10,000 black pages cost about $138 in singles or about $101 in two-packs, and 10,000 color pages cost about $200 in singles or about $123 in tri-color sets.
Above that ladder sits the genuine one, and it is steep. HP’s US store lists the genuine CB540A black at $120.99 — 5.50¢ a rated page — and each genuine color at $110.99, which is 7.93¢ a page. One of each totals $453.96, against $66.03 for the compatible set that renews the same four stations at the same published ratings. Note the shape of HP’s own pricing while you are there: its colors undercut its black, the reverse of the pattern most families show, because the black’s rating is the larger one.
HP does sell genuine multipacks for this family — a black dual pack, CB540AD, and a three-color pack currently coded CF373AM — but no US price for either could be retrieved, so none is printed here and no genuine pack rate is estimated. The comparison above rests on the four genuine singles, each verified in stock at HP’s store.
Two ratings every source agrees on — and the smaller set a new printer starts with
This family has no yield dispute to referee. The CB540A black is rated at about 2,200 pages and each of the three colors at about 1,400, declared under ISO/IEC 19798 — and that pair of figures is stated identically in the listings’ text, in their page-yield fields, and on HP’s own product pages. Not one of the twenty-one listings breaks ranks. Every rate in this guide is therefore built on those two numbers, with no split between a store figure and an HP figure to disclose.
A new machine, though, does not begin on full cartridges. HP’s fact sheet for the Color LaserJet CP1215 describes pre-installed introductory cartridges yielding approximately 750 pages in black and 750 in color — roughly a third of a full black’s rating and just over half of a color’s. That figure is verified for the CP1215; per-model starter figures for the rest of the roster were not separately retrieved, so the 750-page introductory set is stated here at family level, the way the evidence supports, and no model-by-model split is claimed. Either way, the first replacement order on this platform arrives sooner than the headline ratings suggest, and every cartridge carded above is a full retail unit.
There is also no second consumable to budget for. Each 125A cartridge is an all-in-one unit — HP’s own description of the CB540A says as much — with the imaging drum sealed inside, and no separate drum unit exists for this platform at HP or in this store. A cartridge change is the whole maintenance event: toner and drum renewed in the same swap.
Six machines, one shared set of four cartridges
HP’s compatibility documents assign this family to six models drawn from two printer series and one multifunction series, and the assignment is unconditional: each of the six runs the same CB540A through CB543A set, with no model restricted to certain stations or certain boxes.
The printers: the Color LaserJet CP1215, the Color LaserJet CP1217, the Color LaserJet CP1515n and the Color LaserJet CP1518ni. The multifunctions: the Color LaserJet CM1312 MFP and the Color LaserJet CM1312nfi MFP, which add scanning and copying around the same four-cartridge engine.
One roster member deserves a word of its own: the CP1217 is easy to overlook, since HP’s short compatibility lists sometimes leave it off, but HP’s full toner compatibility table includes it with these same four cartridges — it belongs here. And if a machine’s badge is unreadable, the cartridge coming out of it settles the question: any code from CB540A to CB543A belongs to this family alone.
Chips: twenty-one listings, not one mention
Go through all twenty-one listings in this family looking for the word chip and it never appears — no chip claims, no chip questions, no promises about how a cartridge identifies itself to the printer. There is simply no statement on the shelf for this guide to relay, and none is manufactured here.
HP’s side matches the era. This platform predates the dynamic-security language HP attaches to its newer printers, and no such statement appears in HP’s material for these cartridges; this store’s chip-compatibility coverage does not extend to this color family either, so nothing is linked. The written commitment a buyer actually holds is the one in the next band — the warranty and returns cover standing behind every cartridge above.
The terms standing behind every box on the shelf
Which box answers which toner warning
Questions from CP1215, CP1515 and CM1312 owners
No. The 125A four are the whole family — HP never issued an X version of the CB540A through CB543A, and the store asserts none. Extra capacity on this platform comes from the packs and sets, never from a larger cartridge.
Its listing does not say. Asked which cartridges the box covers, it names the four standard codes — CB540A, CB541A, CB542A and CB543A — and describes the name as simply the label for a larger restock box. Because the fifth cartridge is never identified, this guide claims no saving and no per-page rate for that set; it is priced exactly as sold.
Six: the Color LaserJet CP1215, CP1217, CP1515n and CP1518ni printers, and the Color LaserJet CM1312 MFP and CM1312nfi MFP. All six run the identical four cartridges, with no model-specific exceptions.
Introductory ones. HP’s fact sheet for the CP1215 lists pre-installed introductory cartridges at approximately 750 pages in black and 750 in color — well short of the full 2,200 and 1,400 ratings. That figure is verified for the CP1215 and stated at family level here; per-model starter figures for the other five printers were not separately retrieved.
No. The drum is built into each cartridge — HP describes the CB540A itself as an all-in-one unit — so a fresh cartridge brings a fresh drum with it. No standalone drum exists for this platform, and no other user-replaceable consumable is stocked for it.
The store’s compatible terms cover it: a twelve-month warranty and returns free throughout that year, with support staffed on weekdays from 9 AM to 5 PM Central to arrange the exchange. Keep the packaging until the replacement is fitted and printing cleanly.
