null

0

Your cart is empty

Best Brother LC3017 Ink Cartridges

BUYING GUIDE CLEVER SUPPLIES · BROTHER LC3017 · THE HIGH-YIELD TIER FOR THREE BUSINESS SMART PRINTERS
Best Brother LC3017 Ink Cartridges

Most cartridge families ask you to pick a printer first and a box size second. This one asks a harder question up front, and this page refuses to dodge it: Brother calls LC3017 its High-yield tier, yet the Super High-yield tier above it — LC3019 — fits the same three printers, sits in this same store, and prices its color cartridges at exactly the $11.99 these colors cost. So why does this tier exist, and who should still buy it? The honest answer is outlay: LC3017 is the cheapest cartridge per unit that serves these machines, and for a printer in light or steady service that is a real reason, not a consolation. What follows prices all six LC3017 offers per page, prints the tier-above comparison at full size with the store's actual figures, and states the one screen message a compatible cartridge here may leave behind.

Up to 550 pages
Every cartridge here — black plus all three colors — carries Brother's identical rating, measured to ISO/IEC 24711
3 printers
A single Business Smart roster covers the whole family — each cartridge on this page fits each printer named on it
$43.44
The Set of 4 that opens this page — one cartridge for every slot, $4.52 under the same four purchased one by one
1.63¢
What a page costs inside the Set of 9, blended — this family's floor, and the one box here that ships free by itself
THE SHORT VERSION

If your printer is one of the three Business Smart models below, every cartridge on this page fits it, and the whole shelf runs six listings deep: four $11.99 singles, a Set of 4 at $43.44 and a Set of 9 at $80.87 — all compatible, each carrying a new compatible chip, with no genuine LC3017 listed in this store. The one decision worth slowing down for is the tier line, and the guide makes it with its eyes open: the LC3019 colors in this store cost the same $11.99 and rate nearly three times the pages, so heavy color printing belongs up there. LC3017 earns its place on a different line — the lowest price per cartridge, full stop — and the sections below show exactly where each tier wins.

Three Business Smart printers, one roster, no routing anywhere

Brother prints the compatibility line for this platform identically on every cartridge page it publishes for the family: “For use with: Brother MFC-J5330DW, MFC-J6530DW, MFC-J6930DW.” Three members of the Business Smart series, one shared roster, and nothing fenced off inside it — the black fits where the colors fit, the sets fit where the singles fit, and the tier above shares the same three names. The store files all six offers under each of the three model categories and in the Brother LC3017 category, so whether you arrive by printer or by cartridge code you land on the same six listings.

There is one boundary worth drawing in ink rather than pencil, because the model names make it easy to blur. A neighboring group of Brother machines — the MFC-J5830DW, MFC-J5930DW, MFC-J6535DW and MFC-J6935DW, including their XL variants — belongs to the INKvestment Tank line, and those printers take a different cartridge altogether, the LC3029. They are not bigger versions of the three models above and their ink never crosses over; if the number on your printer's front panel carries a 35 in it, this page is not your shelf. The three roster machines here are the standard-cassette Business Smart models, and everything priced below is theirs alone.

The cartridges already inside a new printer deserve their own warning, because they set an expectation the replacements will seem to break. All three models ship with LC3017 cartridges in the slots, but Brother's footnote on its printer pages rates those inbox cartridges at approximately 65% of a replacement LC3017 series cartridge, with the difference spent on the ink system initialization process. In plain terms, the first set was a roughly two-thirds set. An owner whose starter black faded sooner than expected has not been mis-sold anything — and a replacement cartridge from this page, rated at the full 550 pages, should visibly outlast the one that came out.

Six offers on one shelf: a full refill in front, a stock-up box, then singles

Fit costs nobody a second thought in this family, so the ladder is organized by how much ink changes hands in one order. The Set of 4 leads — a complete refill whose per-cartridge price undercuts buying singly. Behind it sits the Set of 9, the bulk option with extra blacks; behind that, four singles wait as the one-slot repair kit, one flat price for all.

★ THE FLAGSHIP · ONE BOX REFILLS EVERY SLOT
Compatible Brother LC3017 Set of 4 BCMY Ink Cartridge
Compatible Brother LC3017 Set of 4 BCMY Ink Cartridge
A single box holding one LC3017 cartridge in each color — black, cyan, magenta and yellow — so a full change happens in one sitting
$43.44 SAVE $4.52 VS SINGLES
✓  Serves the MFC-J5330DW, MFC-J6530DW and MFC-J6930DW — the family's complete roster, with no model split to verify
✓  Comes to $10.86 a cartridge beside $11.99 apiece on their own — those same four singles add up to $47.96
✓  Blends to 1.97¢ a page, every cartridge in the box rated up to 550 pages, the black and each color alike

Held against Brother's own counter the gap is wide: Brother sells no genuine four-pack for this platform at all, and assembling the same four slots from its genuine shelf — a $31.49 black plus its color 3-pack at $49.29 — totals $80.78. This box covers those slots at the same published 550-page ratings for $43.44. It stops short of the $49 free-shipping line on its own; the bulk box below is the one that crosses it.

Shop the LC3017 Set of 4 →

THE REST OF THE LADDER — BULK FIRST, THEN THE SINGLES

Compatible Brother LC3017 Set of 9 BCMY Ink Cartridge
LC3017 Set of 9
▦ Three blacks, two of each color · up to 550 pages apiece · blended 1.63¢ per page
$80.87 SAVE $27.04

$8.99 a cartridge is the family's floor price per unit, and the three-black mix follows how these printers actually consume ink. Alone on the shelf, this box also ships free by itself.

Shop the LC3017 Set of 9 →
Compatible Brother LC3017 LC3017BK Black Ink Cartridge
LC3017BK Black
▦ Black single · up to 550 pages · 2.18¢ per page
$11.99

The slot that does the heavy lifting in a Business Smart machine — contracts, invoices and school paperwork all draw here first. Brother charges $31.49 for its own version of this cartridge.

Shop LC3017BK Black →
Compatible Brother LC3017 LC3017C Cyan Ink Cartridge
LC3017 Cyan
▦ Color single · up to 550 pages · 2.18¢ per page
$11.99

Cyan does the quiet work in logos, charts and page headers, and tends to be the first color slot to ask for attention. One cartridge, the family's one price — the tier section below is essential reading before you stock up on colors, though.

Shop LC3017 Cyan →
Compatible Brother LC3017 LC3017M Magenta Ink Cartridge
LC3017 Magenta
▦ Color single · up to 550 pages · 2.18¢ per page
$11.99

Magenta at the same flat $11.99 as everything else on this shelf — where Brother's own shelf asks $18.99 for the genuine article, the compatible single asks the family's standard figure and nothing more.

Shop LC3017 Magenta →
Compatible Brother LC3017 LC3017Y Yellow Ink Cartridge
LC3017 Yellow
▦ Color single · up to 550 pages · 2.18¢ per page
$11.99

Yellow announces its absence softly — washed-out photos and pale highlights — usually halfway through a job that matters. Keeping one single on the shelf ends that discovery for the family's flat price.

Shop LC3017 Yellow →

All six offers with their per-page figures

Evenness defines this family's rating line: black and all three colors carry an identical figure — up to 550 pages apiece — on Brother's basis for the platform, “Approximate page yield in accordance with ISO/IEC 24711.” Price alone separates the rows, since no cartridge outrates its neighbor. And because a rating attaches to one cartridge, the set rows spread a box's price across the rated pages of the cartridges inside it — never a stacked headline total.

Offer Fits Price Rated pages per cartridge Per-page cost Versus buying singly
LC3017 Set of 4 — the flagship All three printers $43.44 Up to 550 pages each 1.97¢ blended SAVE $4.52
LC3017 Set of 9 All three printers $80.87 Three black cartridges plus two of each color, each rated up to 550 1.63¢ blended SAVE $27.04 · ships free alone
LC3017BK black single All three printers $11.99 Up to 550 pages 2.18¢ The one-slot top-up
LC3017C cyan single All three printers $11.99 Up to 550 pages 2.18¢ The one-slot top-up
LC3017M magenta single All three printers $11.99 Up to 550 pages 2.18¢ The one-slot top-up
LC3017Y yellow single All three printers $11.99 Up to 550 pages 2.18¢ The one-slot top-up

Read it as a single slope. Bigger boxes charge less per cartridge — $11.99, then $10.86, then $8.99 — and the per-page column descends with them, 2.18¢ to 1.97¢ to 1.63¢. Nothing here is priced in defiance of its rating, no offer hides under a second listing name, and no row sends you back to a model chart. The comparison that actually deserves a section of its own stands outside this table entirely — the shelf one tier up — and it is next.

The tier above, priced honestly: LC3019 wins on pages, LC3017 on outlay

Brother builds exactly two tiers for these three printers and names them without embroidery: LC3017 is the High-yield tier, rated up to 550 pages a cartridge, and LC3019 is the Super High-yield tier, rated up to 3,000 pages for black and up to 1,500 for each color, under the same ISO/IEC 24711 basis. There is nothing below LC3017 — no LC3016 or LC3018 exists on Brother's pages or on this store's shelf, so this family is the platform's entry point, not its middle. This store stocks the LC3019 tier as its own family of singles and sets, and since the two tiers share printers and slots, the comparison can be made with real prices instead of brochures.

Here is the comparison at full size, because a guide that shrank it would not be worth reading. An LC3019 color cartridge in this store costs $11.99 — the identical figure on the LC3017 colors above — and rates 1,500 pages against 550, which works out to 0.80¢ a page against 2.18¢. The LC3019 black costs $14.99, a $3.00 step over this family's black, and rates 3,000 pages against 550: 0.50¢ a page against the same 2.18¢. On cost per page the tier above wins everywhere, and on change frequency it wins by more — a heavy printer swaps LC3019 cartridges a fraction as often. Anyone running these machines hard in color should buy up there, and the LC3019 family's own guide in this series takes that shelf apart in the same detail.

What remains for LC3017 is genuine, and it is the reason this page exists. It is the lowest price per cartridge that fits these printers — $11.99 is the smallest single outlay on either shelf — and outlay is the figure that matters to a printer in modest service. A home office that prints a few hundred pages a year may take years to spend a 3,000-page black, and money sitting in an oversized cartridge is money parked, not saved; at light volumes the two tiers' total spend converges while LC3017 keeps each purchase small. The tiers also mix freely — Brother's platform treats them as two sizes of one supply, so a printer can hold an LC3017 black beside LC3019 colors, and each slot can move up at its own next refill. Choose per page if you print heavily; choose per cartridge if you do not. Neither answer is a compromise, and both are priced on this page and its LC3019 companion.

Set of 4, Set of 9, or a single when a slot calls

The Set of 4 is the natural refill for a printer whose slots drift down together, as slots in regular service usually do: one box renews everything at $10.86 a cartridge and ends the sequence of staggered orders. It suits the weekly printer — the household or small office that wants ink handled in a single transaction and the supply drawer empty. It does stop below the $49 free-shipping line at $43.44, so it rides cheapest with a spare single added for the shelf.

The Set of 9 answers volume inside this tier. Its mix leans black — three black cartridges to two of each color — because that mirrors how the ink is actually spent, and it brings the family's unit floor with it: $8.99 per cartridge, 1.63¢ blended per page, and at $80.87 the only free-shipping ticket on the shelf that needs no help. Its one condition is honest throughput. Nine cartridges rated at up to 550 pages apiece form a long supply line; a busy machine works through it steadily, while a quiet one could be holding the last cartridges for a very long time. Buy it for the unit price when the volume is real, not as a hedge against a day that may never come.

Singles are the maintenance instrument, and the flat pricing makes them a clean one: black and colors all cost $11.99, so whichever slot stops a job can be restored for the same figure. The drain order on these machines is predictable — black empties first, colors trail behind it, yellow last of all — and a single answers the one dry slot without restocking three that still hold pages. No box decision is permanent, either: set cartridges and singles are the same physical cartridges, same ratings, same chip, so a shelf can open with the Set of 9 and be maintained with singles for years.

The chip claim, and the display message that can come with it

Start with what the products themselves claim, since the claim is theirs to make. Each of the six listings carries a specification field that reads “New compatible chip”, and the prose agrees with the field — singles say a new compatible chip is fitted, sets say every cartridge in the box has one. The listings also name the physical part: the little green chip mounted on the cartridge's top face, the very contact Brother's support pages single out when a cartridge goes undetected. No box and no single on this page is without one.

What travels with the claim matters just as much, and this family's texts do not hide it. Fit a compatible cartridge and the display may read “Cannot Detect Ink Volume”. The reason, in the listings' characterization of Brother's support text, is that a genuine cartridge's microchip reports ink volume and confirms installation in a way a non-genuine one may not match. The machine prints on regardless; it is the level gauge that may go unread. So low-ink warning duty falls to your eyes — output quality first, a spare single in the drawer second. Firmware updates can occasionally be followed by recognition hiccups, the texts concede, and no recognition guarantee is offered for any firmware version; this page passes that limit along unedited. On the other side of the ledger stands Brother's stated general position since March 2025: its firmware updates do not block third-party ink.

Care is simple and mostly about fingers: hold the housing, keep skin off the green chip, push the cartridge home until it seats, and install it soon after the packaging opens. That routine prevents most detection trouble outright; should a cartridge still refuse to register, every listing's fields carry a lifetime warranty as the backstop. Scope, finally: this account covers these six ink listings at the size they state it — it says nothing about toner or drum cartridges elsewhere in the store.

What backs every listing on this shelf

✓ Lifetime Warranty
The warranty line in all six listings' specification fields reads the same way: lifetime cover on the ink, with no time limit attached
✓ 1-Year Free Returns
Returns run a full year, free, on every listing — ink ordered against the wrong model name can travel back long after delivery day
✓ Free Shipping at $49
Free shipping starts at $49. Inside this family only the Set of 9 crosses that line unaided; everything else needs a fuller cart
✓ Four US Warehouses
Stock ships out of four warehouses — Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and California — and support keeps weekday hours, 9 AM to 5 PM Central

Five last checks before you order

✓Your model is one of the three. MFC-J5330DW, MFC-J6530DW or MFC-J6930DW — with one of those on the front panel, every offer on this page fits, and no further checking is owed.
✓It is not a Tank model in disguise. If the model number carries a 35 — J5830DW, J5930DW, J6535DW, J6935DW — the machine belongs to the INKvestment Tank line and takes LC3029 ink; nothing on this page fits it.
✓The tier was chosen on purpose. LC3017 at up to 550 pages a cartridge is the low-outlay tier priced here; the LC3019 above it sells its colors at the same $11.99 with far more pages, so a heavy color workload belongs up there instead.
✓The $49 line is worth a thought. The Set of 9 crosses it alone; a Set of 4 order draws a freight charge unless a spare single rides along in the same cart.
✓The screen message holds no surprise. “Cannot Detect Ink Volume” on a compatible cartridge reports a silent gauge, not a stopped printer — and fingertips stay off the green chip.

Questions owners of these printers ask

If the LC3019 colors cost the same $11.99, why does LC3017 exist at all?

Because price per cartridge and price per page are different budgets, and only one of them is charged today. The LC3019 color cartridge is the better value by the page — 1,500 rated pages at 0.80¢ against 550 at 2.18¢ — and this guide says so in its tier section rather than leaving the discovery to you. LC3017's ground is outlay: at light volumes a printer may take years to spend the larger cartridge, and every purchase here is the smallest this store offers for these machines. Owners who print heavily in color should step up; owners who print modestly are not overpaying for capacity they will never reach.

Can LC3017 and LC3019 cartridges share one printer at the same time?

Yes — the platform draws no distinction in kind between the two series, only in size: identical printers, identical slots. Keep an LC3017 black beside LC3019 colors, or run the reverse, and let each slot move up to the higher tier when it next runs dry. Nothing needs converting and no setting changes; the only discipline worth keeping is to change tiers at natural refills rather than discard cartridges that still hold ink.

Why did the cartridges that came with my printer run out well before 550 pages?

Because the inbox set is rated lower than the replacements by design, and Brother prints the figure on its printer pages: the starter LC3017 cartridges deliver approximately 65% of a replacement cartridge's yield, with the balance spent bringing the ink system up during initialization. Nothing failed and nothing was short-filled beyond that documented rating. The cartridge you fit from this page carries the full up-to-550-page rating, so a replacement black should visibly outlast the one it succeeds.

My printer is an MFC-J6535DW. Will these cartridges fit it?

No — and the resemblance in the model names is exactly why the question belongs here. The MFC-J6535DW belongs to Brother's INKvestment Tank line, alongside the MFC-J5830DW, MFC-J5930DW and MFC-J6935DW, and that line runs on LC3029 cartridges. The three models this page serves are the standard-cassette Business Smart machines, MFC-J5330DW, MFC-J6530DW and MFC-J6930DW. If your front panel carries a 35 in the number, shop the Tank family's shelf instead; fitting an LC3017 cartridge to those slots is not an option at any price.

The screen says “Cannot Detect Ink Volume” after I fitted a new cartridge. Has it failed?

No. On this family that message is the documented behavior of a compatible cartridge, not a failure: a genuine cartridge's microchip registers volume and installation in a way a non-genuine one may not duplicate — Brother's support text as the listings relay it — so the machine works on while its ink gauge may stay silent. Judge ink by the printed page from then on, keep a spare single nearby, and leave the green chip on the cartridge's top face alone, because clean contact there is what recognition rests on.

Set of 4 or Set of 9 — what actually decides it?

Volume decides it, with freight as the tiebreaker. One full renewal costs $43.44 in the Set of 4, blending to 1.97¢ per page; the Set of 9 stretches to three black renewals and two per color at $80.87 and 1.63¢ blended, and it alone clears the free-shipping line unaided. Daily printing earns the bigger box; occasional printing is better served by the Set of 4 plus singles as slots run dry — every box holds the same cartridges, so today's pick never binds the next.

Price and disclosure note: Prices here were taken from each listing's own store page on November 13, 2026; they move from time to time, and the figure on the product page rules at checkout. Yield figures belong to Brother and use Brother's own basis line for this platform, quoted exactly: “Approximate page yield in accordance with ISO/IEC 24711.” Each rating attaches to a single cartridge — up to 550 pages for the black and for every color in this family — and this page states no combined set total; where a blended per-page figure appears for a set, it is that set's price spread over the rated pages of the cartridges the box contains. Brother publishes no milliliter volume for this family, so none appears here. Savings for the two sets are reckoned against this family's singles at the prices shown: four singles total $47.96 and nine total $107.91, hence $4.52 saved on the Set of 4 and $27.04 on the Set of 9. Tier-comparison figures come from the LC3019 listings this store stocks — $14.99 the black, $11.99 each color — and from Brother's ratings for that tier, up to 3,000 pages black and up to 1,500 per color. Brother's prices appear for context only, read from Brother USA's storefront the same day: the genuine LC3017 black single at $31.49, genuine colors at $18.99 each, the genuine black 2-pack LC30172PK at $56.29 and the genuine color 3-pack LC30173PK at $49.29; Brother offers no genuine four-pack here, and building a four-slot genuine fill from its shelf comes to $80.78. The roster of three printers follows Brother's present cartridge pages, which give the identical list for singles and sets. The chip statement is the listings' own — a new compatible chip in every cartridge — carried with the behavior those listings attach: a possible “Cannot Detect Ink Volume” message, continued printing, a gauge that may not read, and no recognition guarantee on any firmware version.