Seven printers from HP’s 2015 Color LaserJet Pro generation — the M452 print-only line, the M477 multifunctions and the MFP M377dw — all feed from one cartridge family built in two complete sizes. The standard 410A row (CF410A through CF413A) is rated at about 2,300 pages at every station; the high-yield 410X row (CF410X through CF413X) lifts the black to about 6,500 pages and each color to about 5,000. This store stocks both rows in full and then some: twenty-four offers — ten sets, eight singles and six black packs — every one a compatible, every one sale-priced as this page is written, and not a single station left without a cartridge in either tier.
Two complete tiers mean the first choice is depth, not brand of box. The 410A four-color set at $66.09 restocks every station for about 9,200 rated pages at 0.72¢ blended. Step up to the 410X set at $75.03 — $8.94 more — and the same four stations carry about 21,500 rated pages at 0.35¢: the extra money buys roughly two and a third times the printing. That ratio repeats down the shelf, because an X single costs only $1.83 to $2.37 more than its A counterpart while holding two to nearly three times the toner. Below, all twenty-four offers are priced against each other, the two starter-cartridge stories are separated by printer line, and the one box whose contents are not fully stated is labeled as such instead of being priced as if they were.
Two full tiers, twenty-four boxes — the complete 410 shelf
The shelf is organized the way the family is built: sets first, because a restock usually spans several stations at once, then the eight singles for one-station top-ups, then the black packs for document-heavy desks. Each tier mirrors the other configuration for configuration, so any box that exists in standard yield exists in high yield too. For every set whose contents are spelled out, the card prints what the box saves against the same cartridges bought one by one. One box leaves part of its contents unstated; its card prints neither figure and explains the omission.
HP sells its own genuine version of this same four-cartridge restock, the CF410AQ pack, at $561.99 in its US store — $495.90 beyond this box, at the same published ratings.
Shop the 410A 4-Color Set →TWENTY-THREE MORE OFFERS COMPLETE THE SHELF
The same full restock in the deep tier: $8.94 above the flagship, carrying 21,500 rated pages against its 9,200 — the box heavy printers should start from.
Shop the 410X 4-Color Set →
The three standard colors bundled for a machine whose black is still going. Purchased one by one, the same three cartridges cost $85.20.
Shop the 410A Tri-Color Set →
Colors only, at high yield: 15,000 rated pages of CMY for $60.15, where the three X singles bought apart total $92.31.
Shop the 410X Tri-Color Set →
A full restock plus a spare black — the listing names the fifth cartridge outright: two CF410A blacks ride with one of each color.
Shop the 410A 5-Color Set →
Five high-yield cartridges across all four codes — but the listing never says which code appears twice, and even presents that omission as flexibility. The box is shown here at its shelf price, with no saving and no rate attached, because part of what is inside it is not stated.
Shop the 410X 5-Color Set →
Double colors for a color-heavy desk: two each of cyan, magenta and yellow, no black, at 0.65¢ a rated page.
Shop the 410A 6-Color Set →
The deepest colors-only box: two of each X color, some 30,000 rated pages, at 0.35¢ — level with the X four-color set’s blended rate.
Shop the 410X 6-Color Set →
Two full standard restocks in a single box — the A tier bought by the pair, $112.55 below the eight singles.
Shop the 410A 8-Color Set →
The largest box on the shelf: eight high-yield cartridges, about 43,000 rated pages, at 0.31¢ blended.
Shop the 410X 8-Color Set →
The standard black by itself — the baseline cartridge of the A tier, and the one most of these machines ask for first.
Shop the 410A Black Single →
One standard cyan at the A colors’ shared price — cyan, yellow and magenta all sit at $28.40 in this tier.
Shop the 410A Cyan Single →
Standard yellow, priced in lockstep with the other two A colors and rated the same 2,300 pages.
Shop the 410A Yellow Single →
The magenta station in standard yield, at the same $28.40 as its color companions.
Shop the 410A Magenta Single →
The high-yield black alone: about 6,500 rated pages for $1.83 more than the standard black — the cheapest single-cartridge step up on the shelf.
Shop the 410X Black Single →
High-yield cyan at the X colors’ shared $30.77 — about 5,000 rated pages in a single cartridge.
Shop the 410X Cyan Single →
Yellow in the deep tier, rated near 5,000 pages and priced with the other X colors.
Shop the 410X Yellow Single →
The magenta station in high yield, priced identically to the other two X colors.
Shop the 410X Magenta Single →
A working black and its spare in standard yield: $16.09 under the same pair bought one at a time.
Shop the 410A 2 Black Pack →
Three standard blacks — roughly 6,900 rated pages of document printing at 0.80¢ a page.
Shop the 410A 3 Black Pack →
Five standard blacks in one order — the A tier’s deepest black box, at 0.71¢ a page.
Shop the 410A 5 Black Pack →
Two high-yield blacks: about 13,000 rated pages at 0.35¢ — more black cover than the entire A-tier 5-pack holds.
Shop the 410X 2 Black Pack →
Three X blacks — near 19,500 rated pages of black printing at 0.31¢ a page.
Shop the 410X 3 Black Pack →
The floor rate of the family: five high-yield blacks bring black printing down to 0.28¢ a rated page.
Shop the 410X 5 Black Pack →Two habits of this shelf are worth noticing before the table. The first is parity: within a tier the three colors share one price exactly — $28.40 across the A colors, $30.77 across the X colors — with the black a few dimes above its tier’s colors rather than below them. The second is how little the tier step costs at the single-cartridge level: $1.83 more moves the black from 2,300 rated pages to 6,500, and $2.37 more moves each color from 2,300 to 5,000. Depth, not station, is what this family charges for.
Every rate on this page is worked from sale prices — what the checkout actually charges today. Several product pages below do their own arithmetic in their text from the higher list prices, so figures quoted inside a listing can sit above the ones printed here; the note at the end of the page explains the two bases.
All twenty-four offers in one table
Ratings in the table are the yields HP publishes for each code under ISO/IEC 19798; they are planning figures, and real output moves with the coverage on the page. A box’s total is the sum of the ratings of the cartridges inside it, and its rate is the sale price divided by that total. One row quotes no rate at all — the 410X 5-color set, whose listing never identifies its fifth cartridge. Fit takes no column: every row fits all seven printers named further down.
| Offer | Price (sale) | Box contents | Cost per page | Saving against singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 410A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $66.09 | One of each station · ~9,200 pages | 0.72¢ blended | SAVE $48.23 |
| 410X 4-Color Set | $75.03 | One of each station, high yield · ~21,500 pages | 0.35¢ blended | SAVE $48.23 |
| 410A Tri-Color Set | $53.05 | Cyan, magenta, yellow — no black · ~6,900 pages | 0.77¢ | SAVE $32.15 |
| 410X Tri-Color Set | $60.15 | Cyan, magenta, yellow, high yield — no black · ~15,000 pages | 0.40¢ | SAVE $32.16 |
| 410A 5-Color Set | $79.12 | 2 black + 1 of each color · ~11,500 pages | 0.69¢ blended | SAVE $64.32 |
| 410X 5-Color Set | $89.90 | Five across the four codes — doubled code not identified | Not quoted | Not claimed |
| 410A 6-Color Set — colors only | $90.02 | 2 of each color, no black · ~13,800 pages | 0.65¢ | SAVE $80.38 |
| 410X 6-Color Set — colors only | $104.23 | 2 of each color, high yield, no black · ~30,000 pages | 0.35¢ | SAVE $80.39 |
| 410A 8-Color Set | $116.09 | 2 of each station · ~18,400 pages | 0.63¢ blended | SAVE $112.55 |
| 410X 8-Color Set | $133.97 | 2 of each station, high yield · ~43,000 pages | 0.31¢ blended | SAVE $112.55 |
| 410A Black Single (CF410A) | $29.12 | 1 black · ~2,300 pages | 1.27¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410A Cyan Single (CF411A) | $28.40 | 1 cyan · ~2,300 pages | 1.23¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410A Yellow Single (CF412A) | $28.40 | 1 yellow · ~2,300 pages | 1.23¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410A Magenta Single (CF413A) | $28.40 | 1 magenta · ~2,300 pages | 1.23¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410X Black Single (CF410X) | $30.95 | 1 black, high yield · ~6,500 pages | 0.48¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410X Cyan Single (CF411X) | $30.77 | 1 cyan, high yield · ~5,000 pages | 0.62¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410X Yellow Single (CF412X) | $30.77 | 1 yellow, high yield · ~5,000 pages | 0.62¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410X Magenta Single (CF413X) | $30.77 | 1 magenta, high yield · ~5,000 pages | 0.62¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 410A 2 Black Pack | $42.15 | 2 black · ~4,600 pages | 0.92¢ | SAVE $16.09 |
| 410A 3 Black Pack | $55.19 | 3 black · ~6,900 pages | 0.80¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
| 410A 5 Black Pack | $81.27 | 5 black · ~11,500 pages | 0.71¢ | SAVE $64.33 |
| 410X 2 Black Pack | $45.82 | 2 black, high yield · ~13,000 pages | 0.35¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 410X 3 Black Pack | $60.69 | 3 black, high yield · ~19,500 pages | 0.31¢ | SAVE $32.16 |
| 410X 5 Black Pack | $90.43 | 5 black, high yield · ~32,500 pages | 0.28¢ | SAVE $64.32 |
Read the two set rows against each other and the family’s whole argument is in front of you: $8.94 separates the standard set from the high-yield one, and the dearer box carries 12,300 more rated pages. The other row worth a second look is the last one — the 410X 5 Black pack undercuts even the X four-color set’s blended rate, because black is where this family’s depth is cheapest.
The tier step costs little — the page rate falls by half or more
Inside the compatible shelf, moving from A to X is the single most valuable decision on the page. The black’s rate falls from 1.27¢ to 0.48¢, each color’s from 1.23¢ to 0.62¢, and the four-color set’s blended rate halves from 0.72¢ to 0.35¢ — all for single-cartridge steps of $1.83 on black and $2.37 on colors. Within a tier, the colors sit in perfect parity and the black a shade above them on price yet ahead of them on rating in the X row, where its 6,500 pages against the colors’ 5,000 make it the tier’s best page as well as its deepest cartridge.
Genuine HP pricing belongs to a different world, and only part of it can be quoted from HP’s own store: the genuine 410A black is $126.99 (about 5.52¢ a page), the genuine cyan $165.99 (about 7.22¢), and the genuine 410X black $214.99 (about 3.31¢). HP also sells genuine multipacks — the 410A four-pack CF410AQ at $561.99 and the three-color CF251AM pack at $449.99. The remaining genuine singles were not priced from HP’s store for this guide, so no figure is printed for them rather than borrowing a third-party number.
Set the two worlds side by side at the set level and the gap is stark: the genuine four-pack at $561.99 against this shelf’s flagship at $66.09, for the same four stations at the same published ratings. Even the high-yield compatible set, at $75.03, costs less than a single genuine standard black cartridge — and carries all four stations with it.
One rating per code, agreed by both sides — and two different starter stories
This family needs no referee between its numbers. Every listing states the same yields HP publishes: about 2,300 pages for each 410A cartridge, about 6,500 for the 410X black and about 5,000 for each 410X color, declared under ISO/IEC 19798. HP’s own yield test report for the platform carries the same figures, so the rates in the table above rest on numbers both the store and the manufacturer print. Treat them as planning averages all the same — dense color pages will run a station dry sooner, plain text can stretch one further.
What a new machine starts on depends on which line it belongs to. The M452 printers ship with introductory cartridges at all four stations, rated at about 1,200 pages apiece — the black starts small along with the colors, so the first replacement order on a new M452 comes early everywhere. The multifunctions split the arrangement: the M477 line and the MFP M377dw start on a full-size black cartridge of about 2,300 pages, with introductory colors at about 1,200 each, so on those machines the colors call for replacement well before the black does. Either way, everything sold on this page is a full retail cartridge.
There is no second consumable hiding behind these cartridges. HP’s yield report for the platform lists the cartridge type as all-in-one — toner and drum in a single unit — and its supplies lists for these machines name the eight cartridges and nothing else: no separate drum to budget for, and no collection unit stocked for the platform.
Seven printers across three lines, one cartridge family
HP’s datasheets assign this family to seven machines, and the fit has no exceptions to fence off: the replacement-cartridge tables list all eight codes — both tiers, every station — for the whole platform. A standard cartridge and a high-yield one can sit side by side in the same machine, so the tier can be chosen station by station as each one runs dry.
The print-only line: the Color LaserJet Pro M452dn, the Color LaserJet Pro M452dw and the Color LaserJet Pro M452nw.
The multifunctions: the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M477fdn, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M477fdw, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M477fnw and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP M377dw — the same print engine with scanning and copying built around it.
When in doubt, read the cartridge you just pulled out: any code from CF410 to CF413 ending in A or X is one of this family’s, and its label names the station color as well.
Chips: a single sentence in twenty-five listings
Search this family’s listings for the word chip and it surfaces exactly once — inside the 410X four-color set’s parts description, where the cartridges are described as manufactured with all-new parts, the list naming the OPC drum, the wiper blades, a smart chip and other internals. The remaining listings never use the word at all, and none of them discusses recognition or firmware in either direction. A components list is a statement about construction; this guide does not stretch it into anything more.
HP’s own pages for this family lead with its JetIntelligence platform and stress anti-fraud technology and cartridge authentication. That framing is reported here as it stands; no stronger statement about how these printers treat a cartridge over time is made on this page, because neither side’s published words support one.
The enforceable promise on this shelf is not about chips at all — it is the cover every listing states: warranty protection for a year, and returns free for a year.
The cover behind every offer on this shelf
Twenty-four offers — choosing by how the printer actually works
Questions from M452, M477 and M377 owners
Either tier fits every one of the seven printers, and the two can be mixed from station to station. The economics lean hard toward X wherever printing is regular: an X single costs $1.83 (black) to $2.37 (colors) more than its A counterpart and returns between about 2.2 and 2.8 times the rated pages, so X posts the lower rate in every configuration on the shelf. The A tier’s argument is the smaller invoice in front of you — a full standard restock is $66.09 against $75.03.
Five high-yield cartridges, with all four codes represented — and there the listing’s account stops. It never identifies the fifth cartridge, and its own text frames the unknown split as a feature. The standard tier’s 5-set, by contrast, states its spare outright: a second black. With part of the X box’s contents unstated, no saving or per-page figure is attached to it here; its shelf price of $89.90 is printed as-is.
That turns on which line you own. M452 printers begin with introductory cartridges at all four stations — roughly 1,200 pages apiece, the black included. The M477 multifunctions and the MFP M377dw start on a full black cartridge of about 2,300 pages with introductory colors at about 1,200 each. On an M452, expect the first full set to be ordered early on all four stations; on the multifunctions, plan for the colors to call first.
No to both. The cartridge is a single all-in-one unit — that is the type HP’s yield report records for this platform — so the drum surface is renewed each time a cartridge is changed, and HP’s supplies lists for these machines name cartridges only. There is no drum counter to budget against and no second consumable to stock.
The listings say almost nothing: across the whole family the word chip appears once, inside the 410X set’s description of its all-new parts. HP’s pages for the family emphasize its JetIntelligence platform, anti-fraud technology and cartridge authentication. Both accounts are given here exactly as published, and neither is inflated into a forecast about firmware. The commitment a buyer can actually hold is the written one: twelve months of warranty, with free returns across the same twelve months.
Send it back under the store’s compatible cover: the warranty runs twelve months, returns stay free for that entire period, and weekday support (9 AM to 5 PM Central) handles the exchange. Inside a set, cover attaches cartridge by cartridge, so a spare installed later is protected from the day it goes in. Hold on to the packaging until the replacement has printed cleanly.
