null

0

Your cart is empty

Best HP 67XL (3YM57AN, 3YM58AN) Ink Cartridges

BUYING GUIDE CLEVER SUPPLIES · HP 67XL · 3YM57AN · 3YM58AN · PIGMENT BLACK AND DYE TRI-COLOR FOR DESKJET, DESKJET PLUS AND ENVY PRINTERS
Best HP 67XL (3YM57AN, 3YM58AN) Ink Cartridges

This is the ink family behind the printers HP sells most of today. The DeskJet 2700e and 4100e lines and the ENVY 6000e and 6400e lines — the machines stacked in big-box aisles and bundled with laptops — all print from the same two cartridges: one black, one tri-color, each carrying its own printhead, so a cartridge change is also a printhead change. HP builds the family in three sizes. The standard 67 is rated near 120 pages in black and 100 in color; the 67XL doubles both figures; and an extra-high 67XXL sits above them in HP’s own printer datasheets at roughly 400 and 330. This store stocks the middle size alone — the pair of XL singles and two sets assembled from them — because at the prices below, the middle is where the family’s arithmetic works. Every cartridge here is built new to the HP part’s own specification — no refilled shells — and carries a fresh compatible chip. One condition travels with the platform and belongs at the top of the page: most of these printers carry an “e” at the end of the model name, and on an “e” model where HP+ was switched on during setup, only genuine HP cartridges will ever work — the chip section states that condition in HP’s own terms.

55 printers
Thirty-three DeskJet and DeskJet Plus models and twenty-two ENVY models filed in this store — both cartridges fit every one
11.38¢ a page
Blended across 1,120 rated pages, the Set of 5 runs at the cheapest mixed rate this shelf offers
Exactly double
The XL tier doubles the standard tier at both stations: 240 pages against 120 in black, 200 against 100 in color
39 carry an “e”
Of the 55 models, 39 are the HP+-eligible “e” versions — the setup choice on those machines decides the cartridge rules
THE SHORT VERSION

The default buy is the Set of 2 at $53.97: both stations renewed at the XL ratings in a single box — 440 rated pages, a blended 12.27¢ a page, and $4.51 kept against the $58.48 the pair costs one cartridge at a time. Against HP’s own shelf the gap widens: the two genuine XL singles total $72.98, so the box runs $19.01 under the genuine pair at identical ratings. Households that print in volume should price the Set of 5 instead — $127.43 for 1,120 rated pages, an $18.02 saving that is the shelf’s largest, and an 11.38¢ blended rate that is its cheapest. Two qualifications belong in the short version. HP’s smaller standard cartridges undercut these boxes on sticker — $22.99 and $23.99 against $28.49 and $29.99 — and the cost-per-page section below sets that comparison out in full rather than stepping around it; on a per-page basis the XL compatibles still win at every station. And an “e” model set up with HP+ activated is bound to genuine cartridges for its whole working life — the chip section gives that condition in full — so if that is your printer, the rest of this page is background only.

Four listings, and every one is the middle size

Shelf order follows the restock most owners actually face. The Set of 2 leads because it closes the question in one box — both stations, both XL, nothing outstanding. Behind it, the Set of 5 serves homes where black empties at twice the pace of color, and the two singles finish the shelf for topping up a single station. What is delivered is new manufacture throughout: cartridges produced to each HP part’s own specification — the black’s is 3YM57AN, the tri-color’s 3YM58AN — never a refilled original shell, each fitted with a new chip that reports ink levels to the printer. Card prices are the listings’ own prices, one per product; a set’s saving badge always measures the box against the identical cartridges purchased separately on this page.

★ THE FLAGSHIP · ONE BOX REFILLS BOTH SLOTS
Compatible HP 67XL Set of 2 Black and Tri-color Ink Cartridges
HP 67XL Set of 2 — Black and Tri-color
An XL black (3YM57AN) beside an XL tri-color (3YM58AN) — the complete two-station refill for all 55 printers below
$53.97 SAVE $4.51
✓  440 rated pages in the box — roughly 240 from the black cartridge, 200 from the tri-color
✓  12.27¢ a page blended across both stations
✓  $19.01 under the $72.98 total of HP’s two genuine XL singles

Two-cartridge printers age as a pair: the two low-ink warnings typically land within weeks of one another, and this box is built for that moment. It answers at the XL rating — double the standard tier’s pages at each station — pushing the next change twice as far out. Against this shelf’s singles the box keeps $4.51; the bigger figure is the $19.01 gap to HP’s genuine XL pair, set out in full in the cost-per-page section below.

Shop the 67XL Set of 2 →

THE OTHER THREE LISTINGS

Compatible HP 67XL Set of 5 3 Black 2 Tri-color Ink Cartridges
HP 67XL Set of 5 — 3 Black and 2 Tri-color
▦ Bulk buying · 1,120 rated pages over five cartridges · 11.38¢ a page blended, the lowest mixed rate here
$127.43 SAVE $18.02

Three blacks against two tri-colors follows the platform’s real appetite: text and schoolwork drain black long before the colors thin. The same five bought singly come to $145.45, so the box holds onto $18.02 — the shelf’s biggest saving — and leaves a spare black and a spare pair in the drawer after the first complete change.

Shop the 67XL Set of 5 →
Compatible HP 67XL 3YM57AN Black Ink Cartridge
HP 67XL Black Single — 3YM57AN
▦ One pigment black cartridge · rated ~240 pages · 11.87¢ per page — the cheapest single page here
$28.49

Black does the heavy lifting on this platform, and this cartridge is its value form: double the standard black’s rating, priced $7.50 under HP’s genuine XL black ($35.99). Black almost always empties first on these machines — when it does, this is the single to order.

Shop the 67XL Black Single →
Compatible HP 67XL 3YM58AN Tri-color Ink Cartridge
HP 67XL Tri-color Single — 3YM58AN
▦ One dye tri-color cartridge · rated ~200 pages · 15.00¢ per page
$29.99

One body carries cyan, magenta and yellow together, and the three are replaced as a unit when the first color gives out. At 200 pages the XL rating doubles the standard tri-color’s output, and at $29.99 the cartridge sits $7.00 under HP’s genuine XL tri-color ($36.99).

Shop the 67XL Tri-color Single →

Two notes about the shelf itself. Nothing on it appears twice — the four listings are four distinct configurations — and neither of HP’s other two sizes is stocked here in compatible form. The standard tier appears only as genuine HP cartridges, priced in the cost-per-page section below; the extra-high XXL pair is named in the yield section, where HP publishes its ratings.

Four boxes built from two cartridges

There is no fit column, deliberately: every row serves the identical 55 printers listed further down, and HP’s standard and XXL sizes serve the same 55. Set page counts total the cartridges inside the box; a blended rate is that total divided into the box price.

Offer Price In the box Cost per page Saving vs singles
67XL Set of 2 — the flagship $53.97 1 XL black, 1 XL tri-color · ~440 pages 12.27¢ blended SAVE $4.51
67XL Set of 5 $127.43 3 XL black, 2 XL tri-color · ~1,120 pages 11.38¢ blended SAVE $18.02
67XL Black Single (3YM57AN) $28.49 1 pigment black · ~240 pages 11.87¢ Sold singly
67XL Tri-color Single (3YM58AN) $29.99 1 dye tri-color · ~200 pages 15.00¢ Sold singly

Set the two singles side by side and the platform’s shape shows. The tri-color costs $1.50 more than the black yet returns 40 fewer pages for it, because a body that must divide its capacity among three inks costs more to fill than one holding black alone — which is why the tri-color’s page, at 15.00¢, is the most expensive on the shelf, and why both sets earn their place: their blended rates pull the color station’s cost back toward the black station’s.

What each page costs — XL against genuine, tier against tier

Run the shelf’s own numbers first. Black pages bought as XL singles work out near $119 per thousand; tri-color pages near $150 per thousand. Across both stations the blends are 11.38¢ for the Set of 5 and 12.27¢ for the Set of 2 — the family’s cheapest mixed running — and the black single, at 11.87¢, posts the lowest rate of any single cartridge here.

At the stocked tier the genuine comparison is not close. HP’s US store asks $35.99 for the genuine XL black and $36.99 for the genuine XL tri-color — $72.98 the pair, working out to 15.00¢ and 18.50¢ a page — against $28.49 and $29.99 on this shelf. Per cartridge and per page alike, the compatibles win at both XL stations; the Set of 2’s $53.97 undercuts the two genuine singles by $19.01. One gap in HP’s own range deserves a mention: no all-XL genuine two-pack is sold in the US. HP’s only multi-cartridge box built around an XL cartridge pairs that XL black with a standard tri-color, so a genuine buyer wanting XL at both stations buys the singles. This guide did not retrieve that pack’s price, and quotes none.

Then the finding that runs against this shelf, stated as plainly as the savings above. On sticker price alone, HP’s standard tier is cheaper: genuine standard black $22.99 against $28.49 here, genuine standard tri-color $23.99 against $29.99, HP’s standard two-pack $43.99 against the $53.97 Set of 2. This page makes no claim that the compatibles are the cheapest boxes a 67 owner can buy — on stickers, they are not. What the extra money buys is pages: about 240 and 200 per cartridge against 120 and 100. That is why the per-page table still favors the compatibles at every station, standard tier included — genuine standard black runs 19.16¢ a page, genuine standard tri-color 23.99¢, and the genuine standard two-pack blends to 20.00¢ against 12.27¢ here. The exception is the genuinely light user: a printer run a few times a month may never spend a standard cartridge’s pages, and for that household the lower sticker is the whole argument.

Two sizes HP rates — and a third it only documents

For the stocked pair, shelf and manufacturer tell one story. The figure in each listing’s text, the figure in its specification field and HP’s rating for the code coincide: about 240 pages for the XL black (3YM57AN), about 200 for the XL tri-color (3YM58AN), both under the ISO/IEC 24711 method, with the ENVY 6000 series named in HP’s footnote as the test platform. Treat ratings as standardized-test averages — dense photo work lands below them, light text above — and note that every rate on this page is computed from these shared figures.

What the XL step buys is clearest against the tiers this shelf does not stock. The standard black (3YM56AN) is rated near 120 pages and the standard tri-color (3YM55AN) near 100, so stepping up to XL exactly doubles output at both stations. Above XL, HP documents a third size it calls extra high yield — the 67XXL black (3YM59AN) at roughly 400 pages and the 67XXL tri-color (6ZA16AN) at roughly 330, figures HP publishes in its printer datasheets for this platform. This store does not stock the XXL tier, and HP’s US store does not price either XXL cartridge, so the tier is named here — a reader holding an XXL box owns a real HP product — and priced nowhere on this page.

Every printer on the platform leaves the factory with an HP 67 Setup black and an HP 67 Setup tri-color in the box. HP names that pair in its datasheets but publishes no page rating for it, and this guide follows the same rule it applies wherever HP is silent: no setup figure is printed. Every figure in the table above applies from the first retail set onward. These printers are also Instant Ink-eligible in HP’s program when genuine cartridges are used; nothing on this shelf claims that program’s compatibility, here or in the listings.

One paragraph of mechanics. Inside the printer there is no printhead assembly waiting to wear out — the printhead is built into each cartridge, so each cartridge change hands the printer a fresh printing surface together with the new ink. Nothing else wears out alongside: these models carry no drum, no maintenance cartridge and no waste container of any kind. Normal printing uses both cartridges together, and HP’s user guides for these printers also document a single-cartridge mode for printing with one cartridge installed.

The 55 printers that run on HP 67

Every model below sits in its own visible category in this store, and the total matches the listings’ own count of 55 verified printers. Fit never narrows inside the roster: HP’s compatibility copy is uniform across the family, so the standard, XL and XXL sizes alike fit all 55 models at either station. Thirty-nine of the 55 are “e” models — the HP+-eligible versions, whose setup-time choice is covered in the chip section — and sixteen carry no “e” and were never HP+ printers.

The DeskJet group, under this store’s DeskJet series: the DeskJet 1255, DeskJet 2710e, DeskJet 2720e, DeskJet 2721e, DeskJet 2722, DeskJet 2722e, DeskJet 2723e, DeskJet 2724, DeskJet 2725, DeskJet 2732, DeskJet 2752e, DeskJet 2755, DeskJet 2755e, DeskJet 2842, DeskJet 2842e, DeskJet 2852e, DeskJet 2855e, DeskJet 4110e, DeskJet 4120e, DeskJet 4121e, DeskJet 4122e, DeskJet 4123e, DeskJet 4130e, DeskJet 4132e, DeskJet 4152e, DeskJet 4155e, DeskJet 4158e, DeskJet 4252e, DeskJet 4255e and DeskJet 4258e.

The DeskJet Plus group — the platform’s all-in-one DeskJet bodies: the DeskJet Plus 4122, DeskJet Plus 4132 and DeskJet Plus 4155.

The ENVY group: the ENVY 6010e, ENVY 6020e, ENVY 6022e, ENVY 6030e, ENVY 6032e, ENVY 6034e, ENVY 6055, ENVY 6055e, ENVY 6075, ENVY 6075e, ENVY 6420e, ENVY 6422e, ENVY 6430e, ENVY 6432e, ENVY 6450, ENVY 6452e, ENVY 6455e, ENVY 6458e, ENVY 6475e, ENVY Pro 6455, ENVY Pro 6458 and ENVY Pro 6475.

Two edges of the roster deserve plain statement. HP’s own cartridge pages name three further models — the DeskJet 2742e and the ENVY 6050e and 6052e — which have no category in this store; on HP’s data the cartridges fit them as well, so they are named here without links. (HP’s list also prints the ENVY 6450 with an “e” suffix; the store files that model without one, and it is linked as filed.) In the other direction, seven models filed here — the DeskJet 2842, 2842e, 2852e and 2855e and the DeskJet 4252e, 4255e and 4258e — do not appear on HP’s cartridge-page list; their fit rests on their own HP printer documentation, which names the HP 67 family for each of them. One more note, for machines bought outside the United States and Canada: HP badges this same platform 305 in Europe, 667 in Latin America and 682 in Asia Pacific, and each badge’s printers expect that badge’s cartridges — the European 305 is the one a US reader is most likely to meet in a marketplace listing. If the badge is ever unclear, read the code on the cartridge you are removing — it names the family the machine takes.

The chip in each cartridge — and the two HP conditions that come with this platform

Start with the supply itself, which is the straightforward kind. These cartridges were produced new — the black built to the 3YM57AN specification, the tri-color to 3YM58AN’s; the listings say in terms that none is “a refilled original shell with a reset chip,” and each specification field records the chip as “Yes — new compatible chip.” The chip is fitted before the cartridge ships, so levels report from the first page, and nothing is carried over from the cartridge coming out.

The first condition is HP’s dynamic security, which this platform carries and the listings themselves name. HP’s printer pages state it in these terms: “This printer is intended to work only with cartridges that have new or reused HP electronic circuitry, and it uses dynamic security measures to block cartridges using modified or non-HP circuitry. Periodic firmware updates will maintain the effectiveness of these measures and block cartridges that previously worked.” That is the manufacturer’s position, carried here at its own strength. The listings meet it with the family’s warranty: if a future HP firmware update ever blocks a cartridge from this shelf, the lifetime warranty covers the cartridge — that remedy is printed on every listing in the family.

The second condition is HP+, and on this platform it is decided by a letter. Thirty-nine of the 55 roster models end in “e” — DeskJet 2710e, ENVY 6455e and their kin — and those are the HP+-eligible machines; the sixteen models without the suffix were not sold as HP+ printers at all. HP’s datasheets describe the program this way: “HP+ requires an HP account, ongoing connection to the internet, and exclusive use of Original HP Ink cartridges for the life of the printer.” Activation is a choice offered during setup on an eligible model and can be skipped; once chosen, it is embedded for the printer’s life. The listings repeat the warning in their own words: a printer set up with HP+ takes original HP cartridges only, a lock that is part of the program and reaches every non-original cartridge, this shelf’s included. Where HP+ was skipped at setup — or the model carries no “e” at all — no lock exists, and the cartridges on this shelf install and print normally. Where it was activated, that machine will take no compatible cartridge from any maker, and HP’s own cartridges are the honest purchase.

WHAT STANDS BEHIND EVERY CARTRIDGE
Lifetime Warranty

All four listings record a lifetime warranty in their fields: a cartridge that fails in service — including one blocked by a future firmware update — is replaced or refunded — the warranty follows the cartridge, not the box it came in.

1-Year Free Returns

Each listing’s returns field runs a full year, free — comfortably longer than most households take to work through a first set of XL cartridges.

Weekday Support

Questions are answered by people who sell these cartridges every day, on weekdays, 9 AM to 5 PM Central.

Four US Warehouses

Stock reaches you from Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and California warehouses; the one nearest the delivery address fills each order.

Which box fits which household

  • When both slots empty together: the Set of 2 at $53.97 — the full XL renewal, 440 rated pages at 12.27¢ a page blended, with $19.01 kept against the $72.98 HP asks for its two genuine XL singles.
  • Print mostly documents, in volume: the Set of 5 at $127.43. Three blacks to two tri-colors matches how these machines consume, the $18.02 saving is the shelf’s largest, and 11.38¢ a page blended is its cheapest mixed rate.
  • Only the black slot is empty: the 67XL black single at $28.49 — at 11.87¢ it prints the shelf’s cheapest single page, and it undercuts HP’s genuine XL black by $7.50.
  • Color has run out: the 67XL tri-color single at $29.99 — the color station’s XL size at 15.00¢ a page, $7.00 below HP’s genuine XL tri-color.
  • An “e” model set up with HP+ activated: not these cartridges — HP’s program binds that machine to genuine cartridges for its whole life, so buy HP’s own while it serves.
  • Drawn to HP’s cheaper standard sticker: HP’s standard black costs $22.99 and prints roughly 120 pages — 19.16¢ a page, against 11.87¢ from the XL black here. Rarely used printers can honestly favor the smaller box; regular use reverses the answer.
  • Holding an XXL cartridge: HP’s extra-high tier is real — roughly 400 pages in black, 330 in color — but this store does not stock it and HP’s US store does not price it. The XL shelf above is the stocked high-yield option.

Questions the XL-only shelf and the “e” models raise

Why is there no standard HP 67 or 67XXL cartridge on this shelf?

Because this catalog carries no compatible listing for either of those tiers. HP makes six singles for these printers — standard, XL and extra-high XXL at each of the two stations — and of those six, compatible listings exist for the XL pair alone, singly and inside both sets. Fit is untouched by the narrowing, since all three tiers serve the same 55 printers; standard cartridges can still be bought as genuine HP products, their prices set out in the cost-per-page section above, and the XXL pair is named in the yield section.

My printer’s name ends in “e”. Does that change which cartridges I can use?

It can. The “e” marks the HP+-eligible version of the model. If HP+ was activated during setup, HP’s terms bind the printer to genuine HP cartridges for its life, and no compatible cartridge — from any maker — will work in it. If HP+ was skipped at setup, there is no lock and the cartridges on this shelf install and print normally. The sixteen roster models without an “e” were never HP+ printers and carry no such condition.

What is dynamic security, in plain terms?

It is HP’s name for the firmware checks this platform runs on cartridge chips. HP’s own statement — that the printer is intended to work only with cartridges carrying new or reused HP circuitry, and that periodic firmware updates will maintain the measures and block cartridges that previously worked — is quoted in the chip section above. The listings state the remedy in the same breath: a cartridge blocked by a future update is covered by the lifetime warranty on every listing in this family.

Are these cartridges new, or refilled?

New manufacture, in the listings’ own description: each cartridge is produced to its HP part’s specification, and the listings state in terms that it is no refilled original shell with a reset chip inside. A new compatible chip handles ink-level reporting; nothing crosses over from the cartridge coming out, and no empty core goes back.

Which printers use HP 67XL ink?

Fifty-five models in this store’s catalog: thirty-three DeskJet and DeskJet Plus models from the 1255 to the 4258e, and twenty-two ENVY models, the three ENVY Pro machines among them, from the 6010e to the Pro 6475. Both XL cartridges fit all fifty-five, and so do HP’s standard and XXL sizes — no roster model is limited to one tier. HP’s cartridge pages name three further models — the DeskJet 2742e and the ENVY 6050e and 6052e — that this store does not file under a category; the roster section above names them in prose.

Does the printer need both cartridges installed to print?

Normal printing on this platform is a two-cartridge affair — black and tri-color working together — and a full set is what these printers are designed around. HP’s user guides for the platform also document a single-cartridge mode that lets the printer run on one cartridge, so an empty slot does not disable the machine; everyday printing resumes as a pair once both stations are filled.

Why is HP’s standard cartridge the cheaper box?

Because the lower sticker buys a smaller cartridge. The genuine standard black is $22.99 for roughly 120 pages — 19.16¢ a page, where the XL black on this shelf runs $28.49 for roughly 240 pages, 11.87¢ a page. The color station and the two-packs follow the same pattern: HP’s standard pair is $43.99 for about 220 pages, 20.00¢ blended, against $53.97 here for 440 pages at 12.27¢. A rarely used printer can honestly favor the cheaper box; a busy one spends the difference many times over in per-page cost.

Do these cartridges work with Instant Ink?

Nothing here claims it, and neither do the listings. The platform qualifies for HP’s Instant Ink program when genuine program cartridges are used; a household enrolled in the program should stay with HP’s supply while the enrollment lasts.

What if a cartridge is not recognized?

Follow the remedy the listings give: remove the cartridge, reseat it until it sits firmly, and restart the printer. This platform’s dynamic security is stated in the chip section above; a unit that still will not register after reseating falls under the lifetime warranty every listing in this family carries, and is replaced or refunded.

Disclosure — November 16, 2026. Every price in this guide was read from the product’s own live page on November 16, 2026 and matched against the title of the listing it belongs to. One listed price per product applies throughout; this family carries no promotional or markdown pricing, and each set’s saving is measured against the identical cartridges bought as singles on this site. For the stocked codes, three sources agree — the figures the listings print, their fields record and HP publishes: XL black roughly 240 pages, XL tri-color roughly 200, under ISO/IEC 24711, HP’s footnote naming the ENVY 6000 series as the test platform. HP alone supplies the standard tier’s figures: roughly 120 (3YM56AN) and 100 (3YM55AN). The XXL tier’s figures — roughly 400 (3YM59AN) and 330 (6ZA16AN) — come from HP’s printer datasheets for this platform; no price for either XXL code could be read on HP’s US store, so none appears here. The genuine figures are HP’s US store prices, read the same day: $35.99 (XL black), $36.99 (XL tri-color), $22.99 (standard black), $23.99 (standard tri-color) and $43.99 for the genuine standard 2-pack (3YP29AN). HP sells no all-XL genuine two-pack in the US; its mixed pack (3YP30AN) pairs an XL black with a standard tri-color, and its price was not retrieved, so none is quoted. The cross-tier figures are reported as found: HP’s standard boxes carry the lower stickers, and the compatibles carry the lower cost per page at every station. HP names a setup black and a setup tri-color for every printer on this platform but publishes no page rating for the pair, so no setup figure is printed. The roster is the store’s fifty-five visible DeskJet, DeskJet Plus and ENVY model categories. Three more HP-named models have no store category and are named in prose; seven models filed here rest on their own HP printer documentation rather than HP’s cartridge-page list, as the roster section states. The platform’s other regional badges are 305 (Europe), 667 (Latin America) and 682 (Asia Pacific); no fit is claimed for printers sold under them. On HP+: activation at setup on an “e” model binds the printer to Original HP Ink cartridges for its lifetime, per HP’s datasheets, and the listings say the same. Dynamic security is stated at the strength of HP’s own printer pages. The supply is new-manufacture compatible — built to the HP part’s specification, not a refilled original shell — as the listings describe it. No Instant Ink compatibility is claimed for any cartridge on this shelf. The four listings are each carded once, and each carries the lifetime warranty and 1-year free returns its listing’s fields state.