One cartridge row serves two HP color families from the late 2000s: the Color LaserJet CP3525 printers and the CM3530 multifunctions. The row answers to two badges. Everything standard wears 504A — the CE250A black plus the CE251A cyan, CE252A yellow and CE253A magenta — while a single high-yield black, the CE250X at roughly 10,500 pages, wears 504X and more than doubles its standard counterpart. That taller step exists at the black slot only; no color in this range was ever given a high-yield version. Fourteen compatible offers are laid out below, and two facts shape how to read them. First, the platforms do not start even: the printers leave the factory on shortened introductory cartridges, the multifunctions on full-size ones. Second, the color row is not priced evenly — magenta sits a clear step below cyan and yellow, and this guide reports that gap rather than tidying it away.
The sensible default is the $149.53 four-color set: it undercuts the four singles by $48.24 and works out at 0.58¢ a page blended, against $1,431.96 for the same four cartridges bought genuine from HP. The store lists that identical stated set a second time at $177.40, on a listing that currently shows no stock; it is carded second so the pair can be compared honestly. In the singles row the color prices split — cyan and yellow are $61.42 apiece, magenta $41.34 — while the high-yield black single, at $44.88 and 0.43¢ a page, undercuts every standard-black pack except the five-pack. Two of the biggest boxes carry no saving figure at all, because their listings never fully say what is inside them.
Full sets first, then the singles, then black in bulk
The order below runs from complete changes of all four cartridges, through the colors-only boxes and the two partly described big sets, into the five singles in code order, and finishes with three packs made of black alone. Every rating quoted is one both sides agree on: the listings state roughly 5,000 pages for the CE250A, 10,500 for the CE250X and 7,000 for each color, and HP’s published figures match them code for code.
Set against genuine pricing, the gap widens sharply: HP’s US store sells the black at $207.99 and each color at $407.99, so the genuine row totals $1,431.96 — close to ten times this set’s price for the same four rated capacities.
Shop the 4-Color Set →THE REMAINING THIRTEEN OFFERS
Two listings, one configuration: the store carries this same four-cartridge set — its contents spelled out in its own questions and answers, one of each code — at $177.40 as well as at the flagship’s $149.53. The dearer listing is the older of the two and currently shows no stock, so it is carded for the record and for comparison; while both stand, the stocked flagship is the one to buy.
Shop the Alternate 4-Color Set →
The three colors without the black, its contents stated in so many words. It suits a machine whose black — standard or high-yield — still has ground to cover, and it takes $32.16 off the three color singles bought apart.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
Two complete rounds of color and no black at all — the listing says exactly that, down to describing the box as two turns of each color. It carries the largest claimed saving on the page, $80.39 against the singles, and the lowest color rate the shelf supports.
Shop the 6 Color Set →
Every slot is covered and a fifth cartridge comes along in the same carton, yet the listing stops short of naming the repeat — its own text leaves the doubled cartridge to be discovered from the box labels. Until the contents are pinned down, this page shows the price and nothing derived from it: no saving, no rate per page.
Shop the 5 Color Set →
The family’s biggest carton speaks of eight cartridges spread across the four codes and hints at two of each without ever counting them. A hint is not a contents list, so — as with the five-color set — the price stands here on its own, with no saving or rate claimed beside it.
Shop the 8 Color Set →
The baseline black of the family, and the cartridge the three black packs at the foot of this shelf are built from. Bought singly it is the dearest way to print a black page here — the packs and the high-yield single all beat its rate.
Shop the Black Single →
The family’s one taller step: $11.29 more than the standard black buys 5,500 extra rated pages, and the rate falls from 0.67¢ to 0.43¢. It fits the same black slot in all six printers — the X is a capacity, not a different fitting.
Shop the 504X Black Single →
Cyan on its own, priced level with yellow and a full step above magenta. As a single it is the most expensive color page on the shelf; the colors-only sets exist precisely to pull that rate down.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Yellow at the same $61.42 and the same ~7,000-page rating as cyan. Between those two stations there is nothing to choose; the choice on this row is between either of them and the cheaper magenta next door.
Shop the Yellow Single →
The shelf’s uneven note, stated plainly: magenta carries the same ~7,000-page rating as its two siblings yet costs $20.08 less than either. Nothing in the listings explains the gap — it is simply where this store prices the cartridge, and a magenta page bought singly costs 0.59¢ against 0.88¢ for cyan or yellow.
Shop the Magenta Single →
The first rung of the black ladder: one cartridge working, one waiting, $16.08 below two singles and a black page at 0.51¢ instead of 0.67¢.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →
Three standard blacks in one carton, $32.17 under the three singles. Worth a glance at the high-yield single before choosing, though: it lands within a cent of this pack’s rate with a single cartridge to store.
Shop the 3 Black Pack →
The bottom rung and the cheapest page this guide can claim: five standard blacks, $64.33 below five singles, at 0.41¢ a page — the one black offer that edges out even the high-yield single’s rate.
Shop the 5 Black Pack →Two cards above show a price with nothing calculated from it. The five-color and eight-color sets never finish describing their own contents — one leaves its doubled cartridge unnamed, the other never divides its eight by code — and a saving built on an unfinished contents list would be a guess dressed as a measurement, so none is printed for either.
One related offer is deliberately left uncarded. The store also lists a twin pack of the CE250X presented as a genuine HP product; this guide covers the compatible range, so that listing is noted here rather than carded, and no link leads to it. Buyers set on the genuine-described twin will find it in the store alongside the high-yield single carded above.
Every figure on this page is worked from sale prices — the sums actually charged at checkout. A number of these listings run their own percentages from the higher list prices in their text, which is why a figure quoted on a product page can differ from its counterpart here; the note at the foot of the page sets out the basis in full.
Fourteen offers in a single table
Ratings are standard-test averages — planning figures, not guarantees — and coverage decides how a given cartridge actually lasts. A box’s page total is its cartridges’ ratings added together, and its rate is the sale price divided by that total. There is no fit column: each row serves all six printers named further down.
| Offer | Sale price | What is in the box | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 504A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $149.53 | Black, cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~26,000 pages | 0.58¢ blended | SAVE $48.24 |
| 504A 4-Color Set — alternate listing | $177.40 | The same four cartridges on a second listing · ~26,000 pages | 0.68¢ blended | SAVE $20.37 |
| 504A Tri-Color Set | $132.02 | Cyan, yellow and magenta · ~21,000 pages | 0.63¢ | SAVE $32.16 |
| 504A 6 Color Set — colors only | $247.97 | Two each of the three colors, no black · ~42,000 pages | 0.59¢ | SAVE $80.39 |
| 504A 5 Color Set | $167.04 | Five cartridges spanning the four codes; the fifth is not identified | Not claimed | Not claimed |
| 504A 8 Color Set | $282.98 | Eight cartridges spanning the four codes; counts per code not given | Not claimed | Not claimed |
| 504A Black Single (CE250A) | $33.59 | 1 black · ~5,000 pages | 0.67¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 504X Black Single (CE250X) | $44.88 | 1 high-yield black · ~10,500 pages | 0.43¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 504A Cyan Single (CE251A) | $61.42 | 1 cyan · ~7,000 pages | 0.88¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 504A Yellow Single (CE252A) | $61.42 | 1 yellow · ~7,000 pages | 0.88¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 504A Magenta Single (CE253A) | $41.34 | 1 magenta · ~7,000 pages | 0.59¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 504A 2 Black Pack | $51.10 | 2 black · ~10,000 pages | 0.51¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 504A 3 Black Pack | $68.60 | 3 black · ~15,000 pages | 0.46¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
| 504A 5 Black Pack | $103.62 | 5 black · ~25,000 pages | 0.41¢ | SAVE $64.33 |
The two “Not claimed” rows are deliberate: neither of those listings finishes its own contents list, and this guide does not finish it for them. The row worth a second glance is the magenta single — the same rating as cyan and yellow at $20.08 less, a difference that flows into every set containing it.
The running cost, slot by slot
Black offers two ladders that cross. Down the standard one the rate steps from 0.67¢ for a lone cartridge to 0.51¢, 0.46¢ and finally 0.41¢ as the packs grow. The high-yield single cuts across all of it at 0.43¢ — cheaper per page than every standard pack bar the five-pack, from one cartridge instead of a stack. Color splits by station instead: a cyan or yellow page bought singly costs 0.88¢, a magenta page 0.59¢, and the colors-only boxes narrow the spread, the tri-color set landing at 0.63¢ and the six-color set at 0.59¢ blended.
Put in monthly terms, 10,000 black pages cost about $67 in standard singles, about $51 from the two-pack, about $41 from the five-pack and about $43 from high-yield singles. Ten thousand color pages cost about $88 apiece in cyan or yellow singles, about $59 in magenta singles, and about $59 to $63 from the colors-only sets. The full four-slot change, from the flagship set, blends everything to 0.58¢.
Agreed ratings — and a starter that depends on the machine
On yields, unusually, there is nothing to referee. The listings put the CE250A at roughly 5,000 pages, the CE250X at roughly 10,500 and each color at roughly 7,000 — and HP’s own published figures, measured under ISO/IEC 19798 with the color rating quoted as a composite of the three, are the same numbers code for code. Wholesaler and manufacturer tell one story here, so every rate on this page rests on figures both sides stand behind.
Where the family genuinely divides is the first set of cartridges. A CP3525 printer leaves the factory on introductory units: HP’s datasheet lists four preinstalled introductory cartridges rated at approximately 3,000 pages for the black and 3,000 pages composite across the colors. A CP3525 owner therefore meets the replacement shelf early — the first full set, standard or high-yield black included, is a genuine step up from what the machine started on, not a like-for-like swap.
A CM3530 multifunction starts from the opposite position. Its datasheet lists preinstalled full-capacity cartridges — the 5,000-page black and the 7,000-page colors, the very ratings sold on this shelf — so an MFP’s first replacement arrives far later and simply continues the running costs the machine has had since its first day. Same cartridges, same shelf; the calendar to the first order depends entirely on which badge the machine wears.
For scale, genuine cartridges remain on sale at HP’s US store: the CE250A at $207.99 and each of the three colors at $407.99, all shown in stock. HP sells no genuine four-color multipack for this family — its only multipack is a twin of the high-yield black — and no US price for the genuine CE250X could be retrieved, so none is quoted here and no total is built on it.
Upkeep asks for no second cartridge type. These are all-in-one units, the imaging drum built into each cartridge and renewed with it, so no drum is stocked or sold for the platform. The one further consumable is the CE254A toner collection unit, a waste-toner receptacle rated around 36,000 pages that ships inside the box with the printer; this store does not stock it under this family, and it carries no card here.
Six machines, one shared shelf
HP’s compatibility documents place this cartridge row under six models, and the row fits them without exception — no model on the list is limited to the standard black or shut out of the high-yield one.
The printers come first: the Color LaserJet CP3525, the Color LaserJet CP3525n, the Color LaserJet CP3525dn and the Color LaserJet CP3525x — the four single-function machines, which begin life on the introductory cartridges described above.
The multifunctions follow: the Color LaserJet CM3530 and the Color LaserJet CM3530fs, which start instead on full-capacity cartridges.
If the model plate is hard to reach, the spent cartridge settles the question: a unit marked CE250A, CE250X, CE251A, CE252A or CE253A belongs to this family and to no other, and its replacement is somewhere on the shelf above.
Chips: a subject nobody raises
Across all forty-six listings in this family — the fourteen carded here and every duplicate beside them — the word chip appears not once: no parts inventory mentions one, and no listing makes any claim about recognition or firmware behavior. Buyers used to chip language on newer families will find this shelf entirely silent on the subject.
HP’s own pages are quiet in the same way. This platform dates from 2008, ahead of HP’s dynamic-security program, and nothing published for these cartridges speaks in those terms. With neither side raising the matter, this guide asserts nothing in either direction — the practical ground for a buyer is the warranty and returns cover set out in the next section.
The cover behind each cartridge
Matching the box to the workload
Questions the CP3525 and CM3530 platform raises
No. The taller step exists at the black slot only, where the CE250X (504X) roughly doubles the standard black’s rating to about 10,500 pages. Cyan, yellow and magenta were made in the standard 504A capacity alone, at roughly 7,000 pages each — color volume is handled with the multi-cartridge sets instead.
It depends on the badge. CP3525 printers ship with introductory cartridges rated near 3,000 pages for the black and 3,000 composite for the colors, per HP’s datasheet. CM3530 multifunctions ship with full-capacity cartridges — the standard 5,000-page black and 7,000-page colors sold on this page — so their first replacement comes much later.
Because that is where the store prices it. All three colors carry the same ~7,000-page rating, yet magenta is $41.34 against $61.42 for each of the others — a $20.08 gap with no explanation offered in the listings. This guide prints the shelf as it stands rather than smoothing the row into a parity the prices do not show.
The store carries the same stated configuration — one cartridge of each code, contents spelled out on both listings — at two prices: $149.53 and $177.40. The dearer listing is an older one and currently shows no stock. Both are carded above so the pair can be compared; the stocked, cheaper listing leads the page.
A saving is measured against a known contents list, and two listings never finish theirs: the five-color set does not say which cartridge is doubled, and the eight-color set does not count its eight by code. Both sets are carded and priced; the claims wait until the contents are stated.
No. The drum is part of each all-in-one cartridge and is renewed when the cartridge is changed. The platform’s other consumable is the CE254A toner collection unit, a waste-toner receptacle that arrives inside the printer’s box; it is not stocked under this family here.
The listings never say — the subject appears in none of the family’s forty-six listings, in any wording. HP, for its part, publishes no dynamic-security language for this 2008 platform. This guide therefore claims nothing either way; what a buyer can rely on is the year of warranty and the year of free returns.
The compatible-range cover applies: twelve months of warranty and free returns across the same period, with staff on hand Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central, to sort out a return. Keep the packaging until the replacement has printed a few clean pages.
