Three printer generations from the mid-2000s share one black cartridge and then go their separate ways. The black is the Q6470A, badged 501A, and it drops into all eleven machines covered here. The colors refuse to travel: the Color LaserJet 3600 series takes the 502A row (Q6471A cyan, Q6472A yellow, Q6473A magenta), while the 3800 series and the CP3505 series take the 503A row (Q7581A, Q7582A, Q7583A). A 502A cyan will not run in a CP3505, and a 503A cyan will not run in a 3600 — only the black crosses the line. Fifteen compatible offers are carded below, arranged as two platform shelves over that shared black, and the split is flagged at every point where a buying decision turns on it. One more ground rule before the prices: HP never sold a high-yield version of any cartridge in this cluster, so every offer here is a standard-capacity cartridge, however it is bundled.
Start by naming your printer, because the two four-color sets cost exactly the same $145.54 and hold different colors. The 3600 set pairs the shared black with the 502A trio and saves $48.22 against its singles; the 3800/CP3505 set pairs the same black with the 503A trio and saves $54.01, its colors carrying half-again the page rating of the 502A row at the same money. Within each row the color singles sit level — $48.26 apiece on the 3600 row, $50.19 apiece on the other — and the black ladder underneath both rows runs from a $48.98 single down to 0.60¢ a page in the five-pack. One big box, the five-color set at $178.44, is priced without any saving attached, because its listing never says which cartridge is doubled.
Two platform shelves over one shared black
The two flagship sets lead, one per platform, followed by each row’s singles and colors-only boxes, and the page closes with the black packs that serve every machine on the roster. Ratings are the figures the listings and HP publish together: roughly 6,000 pages for the black, 4,000 for each 502A color and 6,000 for each 503A color. Buy by part code, not by the family name on a listing — the codes are what the printer recognizes.
This is the default full change for a 3600-series machine: every slot renewed in one carton, at the row’s level single prices of $48.26 per color. Owners of the later platforms should not order it — the set beside it holds their colors at the identical price.
Shop the 3600 4-Color Set →
One caution, printed because it matters: the listing’s own headline names the wrong printer series. Judge this set by the part codes in its stated contents — Q6470A plus the Q758xA trio — which are the 3800 and CP3505 colors, and it is carded here on that basis.
Shop the 3800 & CP3505 4-Color Set →THE 3600 ROW — 502A COLORS (Q6471A · Q6472A · Q6473A)
The 3600’s three colors without the black, contents stated outright — the listing even answers the no-black question directly. It takes $32.14 off the three color singles and suits any 3600 whose black still has life in it.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
The 3600 row’s cyan, carded from the listing whose name matches the printer it fits. Like its two siblings it is priced at $48.26; bought singly, a 502A color page is the dearest on this page, which is what the tri-color set exists to soften.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Yellow at the row’s common price and rating. The 502A row keeps perfect parity — no station costs more than another — so the only decision on this row is how many colors to take at once.
Shop the Yellow Single →
The third 502A color at the same $48.26. In the store this single is filed under the 502A shelf rather than beside the sets above; it is carded here so the 3600 row can be read — and bought — complete.
Shop the Magenta Single →THE 3800 & CP3505 ROW — 503A COLORS (Q7581A · Q7582A · Q7583A)
The later platforms’ cyan carries a 6,000-page rating — half again the 502A figure — for $1.93 more than the 3600 row’s cyan. The store files this single under the 503A shelf; it is carded here to complete its row.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Yellow on the 503A row, level with cyan and magenta at $50.19. Parity holds on this row just as it does on the 3600’s — the rows differ in rating and price level, never station by station.
Shop the Yellow Single →
Magenta completes the 503A singles. At 0.84¢ a page it undercuts every 502A single by more than a third — a consequence of the rating gap between the rows, not of any station being discounted.
Shop the Magenta Single →
All four stations are covered and a fifth cartridge rides along, but the listing declines to identify the repeat — its own wording tells buyers to read the mix off the box labels when the carton arrives. With the contents unsettled, this card prints a price and nothing derived from it.
Shop the 5 Color Set →THE SHARED BLACK — 501A (Q6470A), FITS ALL ELEVEN PRINTERS
The one cartridge every owner of these machines shares, whatever their color row. Bought one at a time it is the priciest black page here; the packs below exist to bring that rate down.
Shop the Black Single →
One black in the machine and one on the shelf, $16.08 under two singles. This is the family-named listing of the pair of identical two-packs the store carries; its twin is carded next to it.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →
Same configuration, same price, same shelf count: the store carries the two-black pack on two listings that match figure for figure. Either delivers the identical pair of cartridges; both are carded so the duplication is visible rather than hidden.
Shop the Alternate 2 Black Pack →
Three blacks in one carton, $32.16 below three singles and a step down the rate ladder to 0.64¢. The listing wears a single model’s name, but the black fits all eleven printers, so the pack serves any of them.
Shop the 3 Black Pack →
The deepest black stock on the page and its cheapest page: five cartridges, $64.32 under five singles, at 0.60¢. For a mono-heavy office running any of these machines, this is where the running cost bottoms out.
Shop the 5 Black Pack →One card above carries a bare price, with no percentage or rate hung on it. The five-color set never finishes describing itself — the doubled cartridge is left to the box labels by the listing’s own admission — and inventing a saving for a box whose contents are partly unknown would dress a guess up as a measurement, so none appears.
Three of the singles carded here are filed in the store under their color badges — the 502A magenta and the 503A cyan and yellow — rather than beside this family’s sets. They are carded anyway, at the same price points the rest of their rows use, because a row with a missing station cannot be priced honestly; the note at the foot of the page records the arrangement.
All arithmetic on this page runs on sale prices, the amounts actually charged. Several of these listings quote their higher list prices inside their own text, so a number seen on a product page may not match its counterpart here; the closing note sets out the basis in full.
Fifteen offers, grouped the way the printers divide
The table keeps the store’s two color rows apart, because that is how the cartridges themselves divide: a row only helps a buyer whose machine appears under it. Page ratings are standard-test averages, useful for planning rather than promising, and a box’s rate is its sale price spread over the ratings of everything inside it. The black rows at the foot belong to both groups at once.
| Offer | Sale price | What the box holds | Cost per page | Saving against singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| For the Color LaserJet 3600, 3600n and 3600dn — 502A colors | ||||
| 501A-502A 4-Color Set — the 3600 flagship | $145.54 | Black plus cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~18,000 pages | 0.81¢ blended | SAVE $48.22 |
| 502A Tri-Color Set | $112.64 | Cyan, yellow and magenta, no black · ~12,000 pages | 0.94¢ | SAVE $32.14 |
| 502A Cyan Single (Q6471A) | $48.26 | 1 cyan · ~4,000 pages | 1.21¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 502A Yellow Single (Q6472A) | $48.26 | 1 yellow · ~4,000 pages | 1.21¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 502A Magenta Single (Q6473A) | $48.26 | 1 magenta · ~4,000 pages | 1.21¢ | Bought one at a time |
| For the Color LaserJet 3800 series and CP3505 series — 503A colors | ||||
| 501A-503A 4-Color Set — the 3800 & CP3505 flagship | $145.54 | Black plus cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~24,000 pages | 0.61¢ blended | SAVE $54.01 |
| 503A Cyan Single (Q7581A) | $50.19 | 1 cyan · ~6,000 pages | 0.84¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 503A Yellow Single (Q7582A) | $50.19 | 1 yellow · ~6,000 pages | 0.84¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 503A Magenta Single (Q7583A) | $50.19 | 1 magenta · ~6,000 pages | 0.84¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 503A 5 Color Set | $178.44 | Five cartridges over the four codes, the repeat unnamed | Not claimed | Not claimed |
| The shared black — fits all eleven printers | ||||
| 501A Black Single (Q6470A) | $48.98 | 1 black · ~6,000 pages | 0.82¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 501A 2 Black Pack | $81.88 | 2 black · ~12,000 pages | 0.68¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 501A 2 Black Pack — alternate listing | $81.88 | The same two blacks on a second listing · ~12,000 pages | 0.68¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| 501A 3 Black Pack | $114.78 | 3 black · ~18,000 pages | 0.64¢ | SAVE $32.16 |
| 501A 5 Black Pack | $180.58 | 5 black · ~30,000 pages | 0.60¢ | SAVE $64.32 |
Two comparisons do the real work in this table. The flagship sets cost the same to the cent, yet the 503A set carries 6,000 more rated pages, because its colors are rated half again as high — owners of the later platforms simply get more printing for the same money. And the single “Not claimed” row is a deliberate gap: that listing never finishes its contents list, and this guide does not finish it on the listing’s behalf.
What a page costs on each row
Black is one ladder for everybody: 0.82¢ from a lone cartridge, then 0.68¢, 0.64¢ and 0.60¢ as the packs deepen — the same figures whichever platform sits on the desk, since the cartridge is the same. Color is where the generations part. A 502A page bought as a single costs 1.21¢, the highest rate in this guide, and the tri-color set trims it to 0.94¢. A 503A page starts lower, at 0.84¢ for a single, because the rating is 6,000 pages rather than 4,000 at a near-identical price.
In monthly terms, 10,000 black pages run about $82 in singles, about $68 from the two-pack and about $60 from the five-pack. Ten thousand color pages on a 3600 cost about $121 in singles or about $94 from the tri-color set; on a 3800 or CP3505 the same volume costs about $84 in singles. A complete four-slot renewal blends to 0.81¢ on the 3600 row and 0.61¢ on the 503A row.
There is no genuine-HP column in this arithmetic, and the absence is HP’s doing: its US store no longer lists any of the seven part codes in this cluster, so no current genuine price exists to set against the compatible figures. Rather than borrow a reseller’s number and present it as HP’s, this guide compares the compatible offers with each other and leaves the genuine side of the ledger blank.
Ratings both sides publish — and full-size cartridges from day one
Yield disputes are common in this trade; this family has none. The listings put the Q6470A black at roughly 6,000 pages, each 502A color at roughly 4,000 and each 503A color at roughly 6,000, and HP’s datasheets for the three platforms print the same figures code for code. The store’s own yield fields agree with its texts as well, so every rate in this guide stands on numbers nobody involved contests.
The first cartridges follow the same no-surprises pattern on all three platforms. HP’s 3600 datasheet describes preinstalled, full-capacity cartridges — the 6,000-page black and the 4,000-page colors. The 3800 datasheet’s box contents say the same for its machines, at the full 6,000-page ratings across all four slots, and the CP3505 documentation repeats it. A new machine from any of these generations therefore starts on the very cartridges this shelf sells, and its first replacement is a full cycle away rather than an early introductory swap.
Upkeep adds no second consumable to budget for. These cartridges are all-in-one units: in HP’s own words from the platform’s user guide, the cartridge, toner and imaging drum are integrated into one supply, so changing a cartridge renews the imaging system with it. No separate drum unit exists for these printers, none is stocked, and no toner collection unit belongs to the platform either.
Eleven printers, one black, two color rows
HP’s datasheets place eleven models under this cartridge cluster. Every one of them takes the Q6470A black; what separates them is which color row their three color slots accept, and the roster below is arranged to keep that line unmissable.
The 502A row belongs to the Color LaserJet 3600, the Color LaserJet 3600n and the Color LaserJet 3600dn — the 2005 printers whose colors are Q6471A, Q6472A and Q6473A.
The 503A row covers the Color LaserJet 3800, the Color LaserJet 3800n, the Color LaserJet 3800dn and the Color LaserJet 3800dtn, together with the Color LaserJet CP3505, the Color LaserJet CP3505n, the Color LaserJet CP3505dn and the Color LaserJet CP3505x — eight machines whose colors are Q7581A, Q7582A and Q7583A.
When the model plate is out of reach, read the spent cartridge instead. A black marked Q6470A belongs here whichever row the machine uses; a color marked Q647xA settles the machine as a 3600, and one marked Q758xA settles it as a 3800 or CP3505. Order the row the old cartridge names, and the replacement will fit.
On chips, the listings are silent
Search all twenty-nine listings in this cluster — the fifteen carded here and every duplicate alongside them — and the word chip does not appear once. No listing claims a smart chip, none discusses cartridge recognition, and none promises anything about firmware. Buyers arriving from newer HP families, where chip wording fills half the page, will find this shelf saying nothing on the subject at all.
The silence fits the era. These are 2005-to-2007 platforms, designed long before HP’s dynamic-security program existed; HP’s own documentation for them speaks of Smart Printing technology rather than security chips. This guide follows the listings and claims nothing in either direction — the ground a buyer can actually stand on is the warranty and returns cover in the next section.
What stands behind every offer above
Choosing by machine and workload
Questions the 3600, 3800 and CP3505 generations raise
No — and this is the family’s one hard rule. The colors are platform-locked: Q6471A, Q6472A and Q6473A (502A) fit only the Color LaserJet 3600, 3600n and 3600dn, while the 3800 and CP3505 models take Q7581A, Q7582A and Q7583A (503A). Some listings’ shared text blurs this line; HP’s datasheets do not. Only the black, Q6470A, fits all eleven printers.
No. HP’s toner chart and the platform datasheets list standard-capacity cartridges only for this cluster — there is no Q6470X and no high-yield version of any color. Buyers who arrive searching for a 501X are looking for a cartridge HP never made; the shelf above, in 501A, 502A and 503A, is the whole genuine range.
Because they are not the same set. Both cost $145.54, but one holds the 502A colors for the 3600 series and the other holds the 503A colors for the 3800 and CP3505 series. Ordering the wrong one delivers three cartridges your printer cannot use, so match the part codes in the set to your model before anything else.
Full-capacity ones, on all three platforms. HP’s datasheets describe preinstalled full-capacity cartridges for the 3600 (6,000-page black, 4,000-page colors), the 3800 (6,000 pages across all four slots) and the CP3505 (likewise full ratings) — the same cartridges sold on this page, so the first replacement is a full cycle away.
Because a saving can only be reckoned once a box’s contents are known, and this listing never completes its own list: five cartridges span the four 503A-row codes, but which code is doubled is stated nowhere — the listing itself tells buyers to read the mix off the box labels on arrival. The set is carded and priced; the derived figures wait until the contents are pinned down.
No. HP’s user guide for the platform puts it directly: the cartridge, the toner and the imaging drum are integrated into one supply, so the drum is renewed with every cartridge change. No separate drum — and no toner collection unit — exists for these printers.
The listings never raise the subject — the word appears in none of the cluster’s twenty-nine listings, in any wording. These platforms predate HP’s dynamic-security program, and HP’s documentation for them speaks of Smart Printing technology instead. This guide claims nothing either way; the enforceable ground is the year of warranty and the year of free returns.
Every offer on this page sits inside the same safety net: a twelve-month warranty, returns free throughout that year, and a support desk staffed on weekdays (9 AM to 5 PM Central) to get a replacement moving. Hold on to the carton until the new cartridge has run off some clean output.
