One machine, one cartridge set, no code games: the Aficio MP C501SP is the only printer this family serves, and its four codes run in the order you would expect — 842243 black, 842244 cyan, 842245 magenta, 842246 yellow. The oddities live in the shelf itself. Twelve listings turn out to hold only six distinct boxes, because every configuration is listed twice. The ladder is short, ending at a black 2-pack and a single four-color set. And the color pricing is lopsided: cyan and yellow singles cost $114.42 apiece while magenta, rated identically, costs $66.89. This guide untangles the duplicates, prices the six real boxes at checkout, and shows where the set quietly beats the singles.
The short answer: when all four slots need filling, the 4 Color Set at $300.72 beats buying the singles separately by $48.22, and its listing names exactly what is inside. For black by itself, the 2-pack at $90.34 brings the per-cartridge cost down to $45.17 from $53.21. Nothing on this page needs a companion item to ship free — even the $53.21 black single passes the $49 line, with $4.21 to spare.
The shelf, compressed into a single paragraph. A single model — the Aficio MP C501SP — takes four cartridges: 842243 black rated at 14,000 pages, and 842244 cyan, 842245 magenta and 842246 yellow at 12,000 pages each, Ricoh's published figures, matched exactly by our listings. Six distinct boxes are sold: the four singles (black $53.21, cyan $114.42, magenta $66.89, yellow $114.42), a black 2-pack at $90.34, and the 842243 4 Color Set at $300.72, which is the default order when the whole bay needs changing. Each box ships free on its own.
A platform of exactly one machine
Most cartridge families spread across a row of printers. This one does not. Ricoh launched the MP C501SP in November 2018 as a compact A4 color multifunction for small workgroups, and its documentation ties this cartridge set to that model alone — no larger sibling shares the bay, and no badge version under another brand name is documented for it. Our store files all six boxes under the model's own category, Aficio MP C501SP. If that name is on your machine, everything on this page fits it; if it is not, nothing here does.
That narrowness cuts both ways. There is no compatibility chart to study and no second model to cross-check before ordering — the only question this family asks is which box, not which cartridge. It also means the set travels nowhere else: an office running a mixed fleet cannot share these cartridges with a bigger Ricoh down the hall, however similar the machines look on paper.
Four codes, in the order you would guess
Some Ricoh families shuffle their codes between the family sequence and the set names, and catching that shuffle is half the work of buying them. This family does no shuffling. The codes climb in plain color order — black, cyan, magenta, yellow — and the set titles print them in that same order, so a code's position in any list on this shelf matches the color it belongs to. The table below is still worth a glance before a first order, if only to confirm there is nothing to memorize.
| Code | Color | Place in the family's order | Rated yield |
|---|---|---|---|
| 842243 | Black | First | 14,000 pages |
| 842244 | Cyan | Second | 12,000 pages |
| 842245 | Magenta | Third | 12,000 pages |
| 842246 | Yellow | Fourth | 12,000 pages |
The ratings come from Ricoh USA's own brochure for this machine (form R3951), whose consumables table lists the set at 14,000 pages for black and 12,000 for each color. Our listings quote the identical numbers, and the store's text works from the usual 5% coverage basis, so the per-page costs quoted throughout this guide rest on one consistent footing: roughly 0.38 cents for a black page from a single cartridge, 0.95 cents for cyan or yellow, 0.56 cents for magenta, and about 2.84 cents for a page that uses all four toners.
One correction does belong in the open, because it runs through every listing in this family: the savings and per-page numbers on the product pages are figured from list prices rather than checkout prices. The 2-pack's page, for instance, advertises $51.95 a cartridge and $18.49 saved; pay the actual $90.34 and the real numbers are $45.17 a cartridge and $16.08 saved. The set's own FAQ prices it at $345.83, which is its list price — the checkout figure is $300.72. Nothing about the cartridges changes; only the arithmetic needed restating, and this guide restates it throughout.
The six boxes on the shelf
Begin with the singles, since everything else is priced against them: black $53.21, cyan $114.42, magenta $66.89, yellow $114.42. A complete round bought that way totals $348.94, and the three colors alone make up $295.73 of it. Above the singles sit just two bundles. In the 2-pack the black cartridge falls to $45.17, roughly 0.32 cents per rated page; in the 4 Color Set the four cartridges average $75.18 apiece. Each saving in the table is a checkout-price comparison with the identical cartridges bought one by one.
| Box | Checkout price | Cost per cartridge | Against buying singles | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Color Set (K+C+M+Y) THE FULL REFRESH | $300.72 | $75.18 | Saves $48.22 vs the four singles | One order that replaces the whole bay, with the contents named outright. |
| 842243 black 2-pack | $90.34 | $45.17 | Saves $16.08 vs two singles | For a machine that works through black steadily — a spare waits in the drawer. |
| 842243 black single | $53.21 | $53.21 | — | Trying a compatible for the first time, or feeding a low-volume machine. |
| 842244 cyan single | $114.42 | $114.42 | — | Replacing a lone cyan — priced level with yellow, the family's joint-dearest box. |
| 842245 magenta single | $66.89 | $66.89 | — | The bargain color — $47.53 less than either of its sisters, at an identical rating. |
| 842246 yellow single | $114.42 | $114.42 | — | Replacing a lone yellow — worth pricing against the set if more colors are low. |
Shipping footnote: no order here needs padding. The least expensive box in the family, the black single at $53.21, already passes the $49 free-shipping mark on its own.
A short ladder, an uneven one, and a doubled catalog
Start with what is not here. This shelf has no black 3-pack or 5-pack and no 3, 5, 6 or 8-piece color sets — the ladder stops at the 2-pack and the 4 Color Set, so there is no deeper bundle to graduate to and no big-box arithmetic to audit. An office that burns through black toner buys 2-packs repeatedly; an office that refreshes colors together buys the set. That is the whole menu, and its shortness is honestly a convenience.
The uneven part is the color pricing. Cyan and yellow singles sit at $114.42 apiece — each one costs more than the black 2-pack, and together they come to $228.84, three quarters of the entire 4 Color Set. Magenta, sealed the same way and rated at the same 12,000 pages, is $66.89, a full $47.53 below its two sisters. Nothing in the cartridges explains the spread; it is simply how this shelf is priced. The practical reading: magenta is a genuine bargain bought singly, while cyan and yellow deserve a second look at the set price before they are ordered alone, especially when the black is also running low.
One consequence deserves its own line. When all three colors run low together, the natural order looks like three color singles — but those total $295.73, and the 4 Color Set at $300.72 adds a black cartridge to the same delivery for $4.99 more. A colors-only refresh is therefore the one purchase where the set wins almost regardless of how much life the installed black has left: five dollars is a small price for the next black change to arrive early.
Finally, the doubled catalog. Search the store for this family and twelve listings appear — but they are the six boxes above, each published twice under near-identical names, at identical prices, with identical photographs. There is no difference to shop between a listing and its twin, and no seventh configuration hiding among them. This guide cards the six distinct products once each; whichever of a pair you land on, the box that arrives is the same.
The six boxes, one by one
For a machine whose colors are fading together, or one being brought back into service from empty, this box refills the entire bay in a single order. Its $48.22 advantage over the four singles is also the most transparent discount in the family: the contents are declared, the prices are checkout prices, and no reading between the lines is involved.
View the 4 Color Set →
Black runs out first on any shared machine, and 14,000 pages sounds endless right up to the week it ends. Keeping the second cartridge in the building turns that week into a two-minute swap followed by a calm reorder — and the pair prices each cartridge at $45.17 instead of $53.21.
View the 2-Pack →
Two situations justify the single. The first is a trial: one cartridge, judged on your own printouts, before the office commits to packs and sets. The second is a genuinely quiet machine, where 14,000 rated pages might cover a year or more and a spare would sit longer than it should. Either way the small box is not penalized — it ships free by itself.
View the Black Single →
Cyan carries half of this family's pricing puzzle: rated the same as magenta, sealed the same way, yet priced $47.53 higher. Bought alone it is the right box when cyan is the only empty slot — just run the set comparison first if anything else is close behind it.
View the Cyan Single →
Magenta is where this shelf's pricing stops making sense and starts making a gift: the same 12,000-page rating as its sisters at barely more than half their price. When the panel asks for magenta, the single is simply the buy — no bundle improves on it unless the rest of the bay is due too.
View the Magenta Single →
Yellow shares cyan's price and cyan's advice: on its own it is the correct purchase for a lone empty slot, but two dear colors due in the same month is exactly the situation the 4 Color Set exists for. The code to order is 842246, and the price is $114.42 however you arrive at it.
View the Yellow Single →Putting an order together
A worked example: one machine, stocked for the season
Take a workgroup whose MP C501SP needs all four cartridges now, and whose administrator wants two spare blacks on the shelf so the machine never waits on a delivery. Assembled from singles, that basket is the four singles at $348.94 plus two more black singles at $53.21 each — $106.42 — for a total of $455.36. Buy the same six cartridges grouped instead — one 4 Color Set at $300.72 to handle the refresh, plus one black 2-pack at $90.34 to serve as the spares — and the bill is $391.06. The $64.30 difference is nothing more mysterious than the two bundle discounts added together: $48.22 from the set and $16.08 from the 2-pack. The cartridges themselves are identical either way; grouping is the only trick this shelf offers, and it is enough.
Cyan and yellow: run the set comparison before the single
A lone cyan or yellow at $114.42 is a fair order when only that slot is empty. The moment a second color is within sight of empty, the comparison flips: the two singles together cost $228.84, and for $71.88 more the 4 Color Set adds a black and a magenta as well and resets every bay at once. Neither answer is automatic — it turns on how much life the other cartridges have left — but at these single prices the set deserves the thirty seconds the comparison takes.
Magenta needs no strategy at all
The magenta single is the one box on this shelf whose price argues for itself. At $66.89 it undercuts its sister colors by $47.53 at the same 12,000-page rating, works out near 0.56 cents a rated page, and ships free alone. There is no bundle to wait for and no refresh to batch it with: when the machine calls for magenta, order the single and let the set arithmetic govern the other three colors when their turn comes.
Living with the MP C501SP
A factory-fitted chip
Every cartridge in this family comes from a supplier that fits only the latest updated, trouble-free chips, so the unit is recognized the moment it seats and its level is tracked normally — there is no chip to salvage from the spent cartridge and move across. The honest limit is the one shared by every compatible cartridge on the market: if Ricoh issues a firmware update tomorrow that changes how the machine treats third-party supplies, no seller can promise it will not matter. What we can promise is the chip as it ships today, backed by the warranty and returns below.
Changing cartridges and storing spares
Fitting a fresh cartridge is a minute's work: open the front cover, pull the spent unit, give its replacement a gentle rock from side to side so the toner inside settles evenly, strip the seal, and slide the unit in until it clicks home. Keep spares in their sealed boxes, flat, somewhere cool and out of direct sunlight, and fit the oldest first. Sealed toner does not age in any way that matters — the second half of a 2-pack prints just as well in its second year as the first half did in its first week.
What the ratings assume
Ricoh's figures — 14,000 pages for black, 12,000 for each color — are measured at the standard 5% coverage, a page of ordinary office text. Real workgroups wander around that mark in both directions: text-heavy printing can stretch a cartridge past its rating, while slide decks, brochures and full-bleed color pull the total down, sometimes sharply. Treat the ratings as the yardstick for comparing the boxes on this page against each other — which is how every figure here uses them — rather than as a guarantee for any particular office.
The 842243 pre-order checklist
Answers for MP C501SP owners
No — this is a one-model family. Ricoh's documentation for the 842243 set names the Aficio MP C501SP alone, and no badge twin under the Lanier, Savin or Gestetner names is documented for it. The name to be careful with is the MP 501SPF: it reads like a variant of this machine but is a monochrome model from another line, and it takes a different cartridge entirely.
Because each of the six configurations is published twice, under near-identical product names. The pairs match on price, photographs and specifications — there is no better or worse listing of the two, and no hidden seventh product among them. This guide cards the six distinct boxes once each; ordering either member of a pair brings the same cartridge to your door.
Honestly, nothing in the cartridges justifies it. All three colors carry the same 12,000-page rating and arrive in the same sealed format for the same machine, yet magenta is priced at $66.89 while cyan and yellow sit at $114.42 each — a gap of $47.53 with no specification behind it. Our advice follows the prices as they stand: magenta is best bought alone, whenever it runs out, and the dearer two colors are the ones worth checking against the 4 Color Set, which averages the four cartridges at $75.18 apiece.
Not at the prices you pay. That figure — like the $51.95 per-cartridge claim beside it, and the per-page figures across this family's listings — is calculated from list prices. At checkout the 2-pack costs $90.34 against $106.42 for two singles, so the true saving is $16.08 and the true per-cartridge price is $45.17. The same restatement applies to the set: its FAQ quotes the $345.83 list price, while checkout charges $300.72. Every number in this guide has been recalculated at the sale price.
Ricoh rates the black at 14,000 pages and each color at 12,000, measured at 5% coverage — and your mileage will differ in both directions. Offices printing mostly plain text often squeeze out more than the rating; offices printing dense graphics and heavy color blocks get noticeably less. Use the ratings the way this guide does, as a fair way to compare one box with another, rather than as a count anyone guarantees.
Start with the 4 Color Set when a machine needs everything — its contents are declared outright and it costs $48.22 less than the four singles. For black alone, the 2-pack suits most offices: $45.17 per cartridge, with a sealed spare waiting so an empty black never becomes an emergency. Magenta should simply be bought as a single whenever it runs out; cyan and yellow singles are for a lone empty slot, with the set comparison worth running when a second color is close behind. Since every box ships free by itself, the choice can rest purely on what the machine needs.
Neither exists for this family. The black ladder ends at the 2-pack — there is no 3-pack or 5-pack — and the only set is the full four-cartridge one; no colors-only set is sold. Heavy black users simply order 2-packs in multiples, at the same $45.17 per cartridge. And a colors-only refresh has a quirk worth knowing: the three color singles total $295.73, while the 4 Color Set costs $300.72 — so the set adds a black cartridge to the order for $4.99, which makes it the sensible colors refresh in most cases too.
The cartridges arrive ready: each one carries the current chip for this platform, fitted by a supplier that ships only the latest updated, trouble-free chipped units. The machine recognizes the cartridge on insertion, reports its level normally, and asks nothing of you — no chip has to be moved across from the spent unit. The single caveat is the universal one for compatibles: a future firmware release could change how the machine treats third-party supplies, and no seller can honestly rule that out. What stands behind the cartridge as shipped is a one-year warranty and one-year returns.
