This family is built split down the middle, and it helps to know that before anything else. HP makes exactly four 654 cartridges: a high-yield black, the 654X CF330X, rated at roughly 20,500 pages, and three standard-yield colors — the 654A cyan CF331A, yellow CF332A and magenta CF333A, each rated at roughly 15,000. There is no high-yield color and no standard-yield black anywhere in the line, so every set built from this family’s own cartridges pairs the X black with A colors by construction; the one combination set pairs the colors with the platform’s starter black instead. Three enterprise printers draw on the family, and the shelf arranges the four cartridges into thirteen offers: six sets, the four singles, and black-only packs at three depths. All thirteen are compatible cartridges, and all thirteen are sale-priced as this guide is published.
Begin with the four-color set at $189.76: a single box restocks all four stations for $48.24 less than the same cartridges bought one at a time, against $2,144.96 for the four genuine HP singles. Offices that live on documents should then read the black ladder, which steps from the $64.51 single down to 0.25¢ a page in the five-pack. Color by itself is handled by the tri-color set at $141.34, and color in depth by the six-cartridge box. Two of the six sets carry an honest caveat, flagged on their cards and again at the foot of the page: their listings never spell out everything inside the box, so no saving is claimed for either. The pages that follow price all thirteen offers side by side, lay out HP’s ratings and the cartridges these printers start life with, and name the three machines the family serves.
The shelf: six sets, four singles and a black ladder
Three printers and four cartridges produce a short list of buying situations. Everything low at once calls for a set; one station calling for help calls for that single; a fleet that prints documents all week calls for black in depth. The cards follow that order — sets, singles, then the black ladder — and the ratings quoted on them are HP’s own: roughly 20,500 pages from the black cartridge, 15,000 from each color.
HP does not sell a four-pack here, so restocking with genuine cartridges means buying four singles: $413.99 for the black and $576.99 for each color, $2,144.96 all told. The compatible set does the same four-station job, at the same HP-published ratings, for $1,955.20 less.
Shop the 654 4-Color Set →TWELVE MORE OFFERS COMPLETE THE SHELF
The complete restock built on the black these printers start with: one CF320A — the 652A cartridge an M651 carries out of the box — beside one each of the three 654A colors. The box costs $3.96 less than the flagship, but its black is rated some 9,000 pages lower, so the flagship’s blended page stays cheaper; this set suits a cabinet that standardizes on the starter black.
Shop the 652A + 654A Set →
One round of cyan, yellow and magenta for a machine whose black cartridge still has legs — the color row renewed on its own clock, at a blended 0.31¢ a page.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
Five cartridges built on the four-station row — but the listing does not say which cartridge the fifth one is, and defers to the labels on the box when it arrives. Until that is known, no saving and no per-page figure can honestly be attached to this box, so none is; note it also sits $0.19 above the four singles bought separately.
Shop the 5-Color Set →
Two full rounds of the color row and nothing else — the deep color box, written out in full in its own listing, for a workgroup that keeps black stocked from the ladder below.
Shop the 6-Color Set →
The biggest box on the page, sold as eight cartridges covering the four part numbers. Its listing never divides the eight among the codes — it asks buyers to read the individual labels on arrival — so this guide claims no saving and no blended rate for it. What is certain is the depth: a cabinet stocked in a single order.
Shop the 8-Color Set →
The family’s only black, sold on its own — the priciest single here per cartridge, yet the cheapest single per page, because its rating runs more than a third beyond any color’s.
Shop the Black Single →
A single cyan for the station the panel is reporting low. Price and rating match the other two colors exactly, so the choice is simply which station is empty.
Shop the Cyan Single →
Magenta by itself, at the same $57.83 and the same rating as cyan and yellow — deeper color stock lives in the sets further up the page, not in color packs.
Shop the Magenta Single →
The yellow station sold singly — one cartridge, one slot, the same flat color pricing as its two siblings beside it.
Shop the Yellow Single →
A pair of blacks in one box — one working in the machine, one waiting in the cabinet — for $16.09 less than the same two bought as singles.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →
Three blacks at $53.79 apiece — roughly 61,500 rated pages of document capacity banked while the color stations run on their own slower clock.
Shop the 3 Black Pack →
Five blacks at $51.64 each — the lowest per-page rate anywhere on this page, built for departments whose output is documents first and color a long way second.
Shop the 5 Black Pack →Two patterns run through the shelf. Color depth is sold only inside the sets — cyan, yellow and magenta exist as singles and within the multi-cartridge boxes, with no per-color packs between — while black depth arrives in steps, the per-page cost stepping down from 0.31¢ for the single to 0.25¢ inside the five-pack. The second pattern reverses HP’s own shelf. Here a color single undercuts the black by $6.68 yet loses on rate, since the black is rated for over a third more pages; at HP, a genuine color costs 39% more than the genuine black. On either shelf, the rate is the figure that decides.
Every rate on this page is worked from the sale price — the figure that actually leaves a buyer’s account. Open a product page and some of its in-text sums are instead worked from the higher list price, which is why a figure quoted there can sit above the one printed here; the note at the foot of the guide sets out the two bases.
The thirteen offers, side by side
HP’s ratings are declared averages, and real life moves them: a month of dense graphics drains a color station faster than a month of memos ever will. Where a set’s contents are fully stated, its page total is the sum of its cartridges’ ratings, and its blended rate divides the sale price by that sum. Two rows decline to play that game — their listings do not state everything inside the box, so their cost per page and saving read “Not claimed” rather than a number built on a guess. Fit gets no column of its own, because no row needs one: each offer fits all three printers named below.
| Offer | Sale price | What is in the box | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 654 4-Color Set — the flagship | $189.76 | Black, cyan, yellow and magenta, one apiece · ~65,500 pages | 0.29¢ blended | SAVE $48.24 |
| 652A + 654A 4-Color Set | $185.80 | 652A black plus cyan, yellow and magenta, one apiece · ~56,500 pages | 0.33¢ blended | SAVE $51.14 |
| 654A Tri-Color Set | $141.34 | Cyan, yellow and magenta, one apiece · ~45,000 pages | 0.31¢ blended | SAVE $32.15 |
| 654 5-Color Set | $238.19 | The four stations, plus a fifth cartridge the listing does not identify | Not claimed | Not claimed |
| 654A 6-Color Set | $266.59 | Two apiece of the three colors; no black · ~90,000 color pages | 0.30¢ blended | SAVE $80.39 |
| 654 8-Color Set | $363.45 | Eight cartridges across the four codes; the exact mix is not stated | Not claimed | Not claimed |
| 654X Black Single (CF330X) | $64.51 | 1 black · ~20,500 pages | 0.31¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 654A Cyan Single (CF331A) | $57.83 | 1 cyan · ~15,000 pages | 0.39¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 654A Magenta Single (CF333A) | $57.83 | 1 magenta · ~15,000 pages | 0.39¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 654A Yellow Single (CF332A) | $57.83 | 1 yellow · ~15,000 pages | 0.39¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 654X 2 Black Pack | $112.93 | 2 black · ~41,000 pages | 0.28¢ | SAVE $16.09 |
| 654X 3 Black Pack | $161.36 | 3 black · ~61,500 pages | 0.26¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
| 654X 5 Black Pack | $258.22 | 5 black · ~102,500 pages | 0.25¢ | SAVE $64.33 |
Read the table by its poles. At one end the flagship restocks the whole machine for $189.76 — less than half the price of one genuine HP color cartridge. At the other, the 5 Black Pack holds the shelf’s lowest rate, 0.25¢, because most pages these printers produce draw on black alone. Between them, the two “Not claimed” rows are not warnings; they are simply boxes whose contents their own listings leave partly undescribed, priced here without embroidery.
What a page costs on this shelf
Running costs here divide by habit. Document pages pull almost everything from the black station, and the ladder prices that habit rung by rung: 0.31¢ a page from the single, 0.28¢ in the two-pack, 0.26¢ in the three-pack, 0.25¢ in the five-pack. Color pages pull from all four stations at once, so their honest measure is a blend — 0.29¢ across the flagship set, 0.30¢ across the six-cartridge color box — rather than the 0.39¢ a lone color single carries against its own rating.
In monthly terms: 10,000 mostly-text pages cost about $31 in black toner bought at the single’s rate, and about $25 bought at the five-pack’s. The gap is worth roughly $70 over a year — and that is before the sets’ color savings are counted. On machines built for volume, one early choice of box size sets the running cost long after the invoice is forgotten.
Ratings split by station — and a starter black from the sibling line
HP’s declared figures, measured under ISO/IEC 19798 with the colors stated as a composite, are about 20,500 pages for the CF330X black and about 15,000 for each color. Regard them as averages to plan around rather than guarantees: coverage decides how a given cartridge actually lasts. Unusually, there is no disagreement to untangle in this family — every one of the thirteen listings repeats HP’s numbers exactly, so the guide and the product pages cannot drift apart.
The split itself deserves a plain statement, because buyers go looking for tiers that do not exist. HP builds no standard-yield 654 black and no high-yield 654 color: the black station is X only, the three color stations are A only, at HP and on this shelf alike. Every multi-cartridge set built from this family’s own cartridges therefore mixes the two lines by construction. One neighboring cartridge does fit these printers and is worth naming so it causes no confusion: the sibling 652A black, CF320A, rated at about 11,500 pages. It belongs to a different HP line, and the cartridge itself is not sold singly on this page — but one set carded above is built around it, pairing it with the three 654A colors, so a CF320A does stand on this page after all, inside that one box.
A new M651 does not begin life on cut-down starters — at least, not on the color row. HP’s page for the machine describes the three preinstalled colors as full retail-size 654A cartridges at their full rating of about 15,000 pages each. The preinstalled black is a different story: it is rated at about 11,500 pages, and that is the rating of the sibling 652A CF320A — the black in the box is not a 654 cartridge at all. The first black swap is therefore a step up whichever replacement is chosen, and the 654X, at roughly 20,500 pages, nearly doubles the starter black.
For scale, HP’s US store prices the genuine CF330X black at $413.99 and each genuine color at $576.99, all in stock when checked; the four genuine singles total $2,144.96. No genuine four-pack was found — HP offers the family as singles — so the set comparison on this page is built from those four prices.
Beyond toner, the platform asks for almost nothing. The imaging drum lives inside each cartridge, so no drum unit exists for these machines as a separate purchase. The one remaining consumable is a toner collection unit, HP part CE265A, good for roughly 36,000 pages; a new printer arrives with one fitted, and this store carries no replacement — when the machine finally calls for a fresh one, it will come from HP’s own parts channel.
Three printers take the family, and every cartridge fits all three
HP’s compatibility documents for the 654 family cover a single printer line, and the arrangement could hardly be simpler: HP names all four cartridges as replacements for every model in it. There is no machine here that takes the colors but not the black, or the reverse — if your printer is one of the three, every offer above fits it.
The three, in full: the Color LaserJet Enterprise M651n, the Color LaserJet Enterprise M651dn and the Color LaserJet Enterprise M651xh.
Names and membership on this page come from HP’s documents, not from fit lists elsewhere. If there is ever any doubt about a machine in front of you, pull the spent cartridge and read its label: CF330X, CF331A, CF332A or CF333A on the label means the shelf above holds its replacement.
The chip question, kept to what is actually claimed
Each of the family’s own twelve listings mentions a chip in exactly one place: a sentence listing the parts a cartridge is built from, which names a smart chip alongside the OPC drum and wiper blades among its all-new components. The thirteenth listing carded here — the combination set built around the sibling 652A black — is the exception: its description makes no chip statement at all, and the exception is worth stating rather than smoothing over. Read the twelve for what they are — statements about a cartridge’s physical contents. No listing says anything beyond them: how a printer responds to the cartridge, and anything touching firmware or security, goes entirely unmentioned.
HP’s pages for the platform are equally restrained. The M651 line dates from 2014, ahead of the dynamic-security era in HP’s marketing, and its pages carry no language of that kind; this guide will not borrow such language from newer families where it does appear. So the record, kept deliberately narrow, is this: the listings claim a chip among the parts, and nobody — maker or seller — promises anything about recognition. The commitment a buyer can actually hold in writing is the one printed on every listing: twelve months of warranty and twelve months of free returns.
The cover behind every offer
Matching the box to the workload
Questions from the M651 supply cabinet
Because that is how HP builds the family: split by station rather than tiered by station. The black exists only as the high-yield 654X (CF330X, roughly 20,500 pages); cyan, yellow and magenta exist only as the standard 654A (CF331A–CF333A, roughly 15,000 pages each). No standard black and no high-yield color exist to look for — every set built from this family’s own cartridges pairs the X black with the A colors for that reason, and the one combination set pairs the colors with the platform’s starter black instead.
Only on the black station, and by substitution rather than shrinkage. HP’s page for the M651 describes preinstalled colors that are full retail-size 654A cartridges at their full rating of about 15,000 pages each — but the preinstalled black is rated at about 11,500 pages, which is the rating of the sibling 652A CF320A, not a 654 cartridge. The first black replacement is a step up either way, and the 654X nearly doubles it.
Its listing never says. The set is built on the four-station row, and its own FAQ defers the fifth cartridge’s identity to the labels on the box when it arrives. That is why this guide attaches no saving and no per-page figure to the set — and why it is worth knowing the box also prices $0.19 above the four singles bought separately. Buy it for depth, and let the labels settle the mix.
The listing does not divide them. It describes eight cartridges covering the four part numbers and asks buyers to read the individual labels on arrival to log exactly what the set contains; it states no split and no total page figure. A blended rate built on an assumed split would be a guess, so this guide prints none — the box is sold on depth, and its contents are confirmed from the labels.
No. The imaging drum is part of the cartridge itself, so swapping the cartridge renews it too. Apart from toner, the platform’s only consumable is the CE265A toner collection unit, rated at roughly 36,000 pages; the printer arrives with one fitted, and no replacement is stocked here.
Not per color, no. A single color can be bought only as a single; beyond that, colors come combined — one round of all three in the tri-color set, two rounds without black in the six-color set, and the eight-color set for the deepest stock of all. Multiples of one cartridge are a black-only arrangement here: packs of two, three and five.
Three models, all from one line: the Color LaserJet Enterprise M651n, M651dn and M651xh. HP lists the same four cartridges as the replacements for each of the three, with no model taking a subset — a machine on that list can use every offer on this page.
Every listing on this page carries the same written terms — a year of warranty cover and a year of free returns — and a failed or refused cartridge goes back under them. Support can help arrange it, Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central; keep the packaging until its replacement has printed a clean page.
