This is an old platform with a tidy shelf. The Color LaserJet 4600, 4610n and 4650 machines — eleven models wearing three series badges — all feed from the same four cartridges: C9720A black, C9721A cyan, C9722A yellow and C9723A magenta. HP badged every one of them 641A and stopped there: no high-yield tier, no second badge at the black station, nothing else in HP’s catalog fits these printers. The ratings are settled history, too — about 9,000 pages for the black and 8,000 for each color, the same figures in the store’s listings and in HP’s own datasheets — and the machines left the factory holding full-size cartridges, not reduced starters. Ten offers are carded below: the complete set, a colors-only set, four singles, a two-black pack, one set whose contents its own listing never quite finishes describing, and two singles sold under codes this store assigned itself, labeled for exactly what they are. One comparison is missing on purpose: HP no longer sells these cartridges through its US store, so there is no genuine price to set against the shelf — the contest here is between the compatible offers themselves.
The four-color set at $208.73 is the shelf’s center of gravity: its contents are spelled out on the listing, it trims $48.25 off the four singles bought separately, and it prices a full change at 0.63¢ a page. If only the color side is due, the tri-color set at $168.20 saves $32.17 against the three color singles. Singly, the black is $56.61 and each color is $66.79; the two-black pack at $97.14 holds the family’s cheapest page. Two listings need a careful read before they need a wallet — the “5 Color Set” at $249.26 never says what its fifth cartridge is, and the two singles wearing “641X” codes are this store’s own extended-fill variants, not HP cartridges. Both are carded below, flagged, and quoted without savings or per-page rates.
The 641A shelf: sets, singles and one black pack
The order below follows how these machines are actually restocked: the full four-cartridge change first, then the colors traveling together, the singles in code order, and black by the pair for the document-heavy printers. Where a listing states its contents outright, the saving printed on its card is arithmetic, not advertising — sale prices, counted cartridges. Where a listing leaves its contents unfinished, the card says so and prints no saving at all. Ratings throughout are the undisputed pair: about 9,000 pages from the C9720A black, about 8,000 from each color.
A machine of this age usually needs its stations renewed together, and this is the box built for that moment: every position refilled in one order, at the same blended rate the black single manages on its own. Nothing in the set is a house variant or a mystery cartridge — four standard 641A units, counted on the listing itself.
Shop the 4-Color Set →THE REST OF THE 641A SHELF
Cyan, yellow and magenta traveling as a trio while the black still has life in it — a common pattern on this platform, where the colors tend to fade together. The bundle takes $32.17 off the three singles and brings the color page from 0.83¢ down to 0.70¢.
Shop the Tri-Color Set →
Read this one closely before buying. The name promises five cartridges, yet the FAQ accounts for the four named 641A codes slot by slot and never identifies a fifth — which cartridge is doubled, if any, is stated nowhere. Until the listing says, this guide quotes no saving and no per-page rate for the box; the fully documented four-color set above is the safer full change.
Shop the 5 Color Set →
The family’s hardest-working unit and its cheapest single: $56.61 buys the highest-rated cartridge of the four, which is why black is the least expensive page on the shelf even bought one at a time. It is also the cartridge both black packs and the big set are built around.
Shop the Black Single →
Cyan by itself, at the price every color carries in this family. A single faded station is the usual reason to buy it — the cartridge that runs out mid-job while its two color neighbors still have pages left in them.
Shop the Cyan Single →
The standard yellow — HP’s real C9722A code, the cartridge the genuine label carries. Keep this one in mind when the store-variant yellow further down catches your eye: same shelf price, but this is the documented 641A cartridge.
Shop the Yellow Single →
Magenta completes the color row at the same $66.79 and the same ~8,000-page rating as cyan and yellow. With parity this exact, a refill budget written for one color holds for whichever station calls next.
Shop the Magenta Single →
The black ladder in this family has exactly one rung, and it is a good one: two blacks for $16.08 less than the pair bought singly, pulling the black page down to 0.54¢ — the cheapest rate anywhere in this guide. Its FAQ states the contents in so many words: two black C9720A cartridges.
Shop the 2 Black Pack →Step back and the shape of the family is plain: HP built one tier, the store priced the colors in lockstep, and the only real decisions are how many cartridges to take home at once. The two cards below are the exception to that tidiness, and they get their own block so the exception cannot be mistaken for the rule.
Two singles wearing codes HP never issued
This needs saying in plain words. HP sells no 641X tier — there is no C9720X, C9721X, C9722X or C9723X anywhere in HP’s catalog, and no genuine cartridge label has ever carried those codes. The two singles below are extended-fill cartridges that this store sells under codes it assigned itself, presented on their listings as if an HP 641X line existed. They are carded here because they are real, purchasable cartridges for these printers — but they are carded as what they are: store variants. Their listings claim roughly 9,600 pages apiece, about a fifth more than the 641A rating; no source outside this store’s own catalog supports that figure, so this guide prints no saving and no per-page rate for either one. They cost exactly what the standard 641A singles cost, and the practical rule is simple: if you buy one, match it to your printer model — the 4600, 4610n and 4650 machines listed further down — never to a code on an old cartridge’s label, because no genuine label reads C9722X or C9723X. There is no black or cyan variant on sale; the black “641X” listing is not currently sellable and is not carded.
The same $66.79 as the standard 641A yellow above, wearing a code HP never printed. The claimed extra fill costs nothing extra — which is itself a reason to treat the claim cautiously. The documented C9722A single is the straightforward buy; this one is for buyers who understand exactly what it is.
Shop the Yellow Store Variant →
Magenta’s version of the same arrangement: a store code, a store yield claim, and the standard single’s price. HP’s magenta for this platform is the C9723A carded above, full stop — anything wearing an X after 641 belongs to this store’s naming, not HP’s.
Shop the Magenta Store Variant →Every carded offer, side by side
Ten rows cover the shelf, and two of them carry asterisks of a kind a table rarely needs. The “5 Color Set” row has no rate because its contents are not fully documented; the two store-variant rows have no rate because their yield claim cannot be checked. Everything else is plain division: sale price over rated pages, ratings being the agreed 9,000 for black and 8,000 per color. No fit column appears, since all ten rows serve the same eleven printers.
| Offer | Sale price | What is in the box | Cost per page | Saving vs singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 641A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $208.73 | Black, cyan, yellow and magenta, one each · ~33,000 pages | 0.63¢ blended | SAVE $48.25 |
| 641A Tri-Color Set | $168.20 | Cyan, yellow and magenta · ~24,000 pages | 0.70¢ | SAVE $32.17 |
| 641A “5 Color Set” | $249.26 | Named as five cartridges; listing text accounts for the four standard ones only | Not quoted — contents not fully stated | Not quoted |
| 641A Black Single (C9720A) | $56.61 | 1 black · ~9,000 pages | 0.63¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 641A Cyan Single (C9721A) | $66.79 | 1 cyan · ~8,000 pages | 0.83¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 641A Yellow Single (C9722A) | $66.79 | 1 yellow · ~8,000 pages | 0.83¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 641A Magenta Single (C9723A) | $66.79 | 1 magenta · ~8,000 pages | 0.83¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 641A 2 Black Pack | $97.14 | 2 black · ~18,000 pages | 0.54¢ | SAVE $16.08 |
| “641X” Yellow Single (C9722X) — store variant, not an HP code | $66.79 | 1 yellow, extended-fill variant · listing claims ~9,600 pages | Not quoted — claim unverified | Same price as the 641A yellow single |
| “641X” Magenta Single (C9723X) — store variant, not an HP code | $66.79 | 1 magenta, extended-fill variant · listing claims ~9,600 pages | Not quoted — claim unverified | Same price as the 641A magenta single |
Notice how narrow the honest part of the table is: every documented offer sits between 0.54¢ and 0.83¢ a page. The three “not quoted” cells are not gaps in this guide’s homework — they mark the exact spots where the listings themselves stop documenting what they sell.
What each page costs on this shelf
Black is the bargain page here, for two stacked reasons: the C9720A is the cheapest single on the shelf and it carries the family’s highest rating. Bought singly it runs 0.63¢; from the two-black pack, 0.54¢. A color page costs 0.83¢ as a single and 0.70¢ through the tri-color set, and a complete four-station change from the flagship set blends to 0.63¢ — the set prices the whole machine at the black single’s rate. In round monthly terms, 10,000 black pages cost about $63 in singles or about $54 from the pair pack; 10,000 color pages cost about $83 singly or about $70 through the tri-color set.
What this section cannot do is hold a genuine cartridge up beside these numbers. HP has discontinued the family at its US store — none of the four codes carries a US listing or price there any longer — so there is no genuine figure to quote honestly, and this guide quotes none. Buyers cross-shopping elsewhere should know that any “genuine 641A” price they meet today comes from remaining reseller stock, not from HP’s current US line.
The store variants deserve one honest sentence in a cost section: at the same $66.79 as the standard singles, their claimed extra pages would lower the color rate if the claim held — but a rate printed here has to rest on more than the seller’s own say-so, and for these two cartridges nothing else exists. They are therefore priced in this guide, and rated nowhere in it.
Yields with nothing to argue about
Guide math often has to choose between what a listing declares and what the manufacturer currently publishes. This family spares it the choice. The black is rated at about 9,000 pages and each color at about 8,000 under ISO/IEC 19798 — in the listings’ descriptive text, in their structured page-yield fields, and in HP’s own datasheet for the platform, three sources in exact agreement. Every 641A listing in the store tells the same story, so every rate printed above stands on all of them at once. The only yield numbers in the family that rest on a single voice are the store variants’ claims, and those are labeled as such wherever they appear.
New machines started at full strength as well. HP’s datasheet for the 4650 series lists the box contents as the printer plus black, cyan, yellow and magenta print cartridges, with no introductory or reduced-yield qualifier anywhere — and this platform predates HP’s starter-cartridge practice on machines of its class. The first set of cartridges a 4600 or 4650 ever held was a full retail set, so the ratings above describe the platform’s whole life rather than everything after a smaller first act.
There is also no second consumable hiding in the budget. These are all-in-one print cartridges — the imaging drum is built into each unit, so every toner change renews the drum with it, and HP’s documentation for the platform lists no separate drum to buy. The remaining service parts for these printers, transfer and fuser kits, are not stocked here and are not part of a toner decision.
Eleven printers across three series badges
HP sold this one platform under three badges — the 4600 series and the 4650 series, five equipment levels apiece, plus the single 4610n between them — and covered all of it with one joint service manual. The cartridge answer never changes across the range: every model below takes the same four 641A cartridges, with no model-specific restrictions.
The 4600 series: the Color LaserJet 4600, Color LaserJet 4600n, Color LaserJet 4600dn, Color LaserJet 4600dtn and Color LaserJet 4600hdn. The middle badge is a single network machine, the Color LaserJet 4610n — HP never sold a non-network 4610, so where a listing prints “4610” on its own it is using the series label, not naming a twelfth printer. The 4650 series: the Color LaserJet 4650, Color LaserJet 4650n, Color LaserJet 4650dn, Color LaserJet 4650dtn and Color LaserJet 4650hdn.
If the front panel is out of sight, the cartridge that slides out answers instead: a C9720A, C9721A, C9722A or C9723A belongs to this family and to no other — which is also why the two store-variant singles must be matched by machine, since the codes molded for them exist nowhere outside this store.
A platform from before the chip era
Search all twenty-eight listings in this family — names and full texts — and the word “chip” does not appear a single time. That silence is accurate reporting, not an omission: these printers were designed in 2002 to 2004, more than a decade before HP’s dynamic-security program existed, and there is no cartridge-blocking machinery in the platform for a listing to make claims about. This guide follows the listings’ lead and makes no chip claim of its own.
What a buyer can rely on instead is the cover in the next band — warranty, returns and support — which applies to every cartridge carded above, the two store variants included.
The cover behind every cartridge on this page
Matching the box to the workload
Questions the 4600, 4610n and 4650 platform raises
No. HP’s family for these printers is 641A only — C9720A through C9723A — and no X version of any of the four codes exists in HP’s catalog. The two singles in this store wearing C9722X and C9723X are extended-fill variants sold under codes the store assigned itself; their listings claim about 9,600 pages, a figure no outside source supports. There is no cyan variant at all, and the black variant listing is not currently sellable. If you buy a variant, match it by printer model, not by the code on your old cartridge.
Eleven: the Color LaserJet 4600, 4600n, 4600dn, 4600dtn and 4600hdn; the Color LaserJet 4610n; and the Color LaserJet 4650, 4650n, 4650dn, 4650dtn and 4650hdn. All four cartridges fit all eleven models — there are no exceptions by model.
The listing does not say. Its own FAQ walks through the four standard cartridges position by position and never names a fifth or identifies a doubled code. Because the contents cannot be confirmed from the listing, this guide prints no saving and no per-page rate for that box; the four-color set, whose contents are stated outright, is the documented full change.
No. HP’s datasheet for the platform lists full black, cyan, yellow and magenta print cartridges in the box, rated at the same ~9,000 and ~8,000 pages as the cartridges sold here. There was no reduced introductory cartridge in this platform’s life.
No. The drum is built into each all-in-one print cartridge, so replacing the cartridge replaces the drum. HP’s documentation lists no separate drum unit for the 4600, 4610n or 4650, and none is sold for them here.
Not from HP’s US store, which no longer lists any of the four codes — the family is discontinued there. That is why this guide prints no genuine prices: anything sold as genuine 641A today is reseller stock, priced by the reseller, and no figure from HP exists to compare against.
It falls under the store’s compatible terms — a twelve-month warranty, free returns across the same year, and weekday support from 9 AM to 5 PM Central to sort out the exchange. Keep the carton until the replacement is printing cleanly.
