Ten printers — the Color LaserJet Pro 4201 line and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301 line — draw on one family of eight cartridges. Four stations (black, cyan, yellow, magenta) each come in two sizes: the standard 210A, which HP rates at about 2,000 pages in black and 1,800 in each color, and the high-yield 210X, rated at about 7,500 in black and 5,500 per color. This store mirrors the family slot for slot: twelve offers, six per tier, each tier holding a four-color set, a two-black pack and the four singles. Colors are never packed on their own — depth for them lives inside the sets. Nothing on the shelf is a genuine HP cartridge: all twelve offers are compatibles, and all twelve are sale-priced as this page goes up.
Begin with the tier, not the box. Print a moderate amount and the 210A set at $201.87 restocks all four stations at 2.73¢ a page blended; print heavily and the 210X set at $268.66 — $66.79 more — more than triples the rated pages and pulls the blended rate down to 1.12¢. One pricing quirk shapes everything below: inside a tier, the black cartridge costs exactly what a color costs, even though HP rates it for more pages, which quietly makes black the cheapest page in both tiers. The pages that follow price all twelve offers side by side, lay out HP’s ratings and the smaller cartridges a new printer starts on, name the ten printers, and give the chip question the straight treatment this family demands — the listings say nothing about chips at all, while HP describes these printers in explicit dynamic-security terms.
Six slots, filled twice — the 210A shelf and its 210X mirror
Plenty of color families sprawl — a tri-pack here, a color pack there, a spare whose color nobody states. This one is a tidy mirror. Each tier stocks the same six configurations: a set of four, a pair of blacks, and the four singles. Choosing therefore reduces to two decisions — which tier, then which slot. The sets lead, because a full restock is the common purchase; the black pairs follow, for desks that burn through black between color changes; and the singles close the page for one-station top-ups.
HP’s own store prices the same four stations at $531.96 when its genuine singles are added together — $114.99 for the black and $138.99 apiece for the colors. This set undercuts that genuine basket by $330.09 at the same published ratings.
Shop the 210A 4-Color Set →ELEVEN MORE OFFERS COMPLETE THE SHELF
The mirror set in high yield: one box restocks every station and holds more than three times the flagship’s rated pages.
Shop the 210X 4-Color Set →
Two standard blacks for the printer that empties its black station long before the colors need any attention.
Shop the 210A 2 Black Pack →
Two high-yield blacks — roughly 15,000 rated pages of document printing, and the cheapest page anywhere on this page.
Shop the 210X 2 Black Pack →
The standard black on its own — the cartridge most of these printers ask for first, and the baseline the whole A tier is measured from.
Shop the 210A Black Single →
A single cyan for the station the printer is flagging, at the flat A-tier price every 210A single shares.
Shop the 210A Cyan Single →
Yellow sold singly, like its color siblings — color depth on this shelf comes from the sets, never from color packs.
Shop the 210A Yellow Single →
The magenta station on its own, priced identically to the other three 210A singles — one flat price across the tier.
Shop the 210A Magenta Single →
The high-yield black alone: about 7,500 rated pages at 1.06¢ — nearly four times the standard black’s run for $16.70 more.
Shop the 210X Black Single →
One high-yield cyan, rated about 5,500 pages — roughly three standard cyans’ worth of printing in a single cartridge.
Shop the 210X Cyan Single →
High-yield yellow on its own, at the flat X-tier single price all four stations share.
Shop the 210X Yellow Single →
The magenta station in high yield — about 5,500 rated pages before the printer asks for another.
Shop the 210X Magenta Single →Two patterns are worth carrying away from this shelf. First, the tier step is cheap: moving from A to X adds roughly 27% to a cartridge’s price while multiplying its rating more than threefold, so the X tier wins the per-page math in all six slots. Second, the flat pricing inside each tier quietly favors black — a black and a color cost the same money, yet HP rates the black for more pages in both tiers: 2,000 against 1,800 in A, and 7,500 against 5,500 in X.
All of the math on this page runs off sale prices — the amounts the checkout charges right now. Some of the product pages linked below instead work from list prices in their own text, so the per-page figures printed there land higher; the closing note at the foot of the page sets out which basis applies where.
The twelve offers, priced as sold
The yields quoted in the table come straight from HP — ISO/IEC 19798 averages that move with how much of each page is covered. Totals for a set add up the ratings of the cartridges inside the box, and a blended rate is that box’s sale price divided by its total. Fit needs no column of its own: every row fits every one of the ten printers named further down, in both tiers.
| Offer | Price (sale) | Box contents | Cost per page | Saving against singles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 210A 4-Color Set — the flagship | $201.87 | One of each station · ~7,400 pages | 2.73¢ blended | SAVE $48.21 |
| 210X 4-Color Set | $268.66 | 1 of each station, high yield · ~24,000 pages | 1.12¢ blended | SAVE $48.22 |
| 210A 2 Black Pack | $108.97 | 2 black · ~4,000 pages | 2.72¢ | SAVE $16.07 |
| 210X 2 Black Pack | $142.37 | 2 black, high yield · ~15,000 pages | 0.95¢ | SAVE $16.07 |
| 210A Black Single (W2100A) | $62.52 | 1 black · ~2,000 pages | 3.13¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 210A Cyan Single (W2101A) | $62.52 | 1 cyan · ~1,800 pages | 3.47¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 210A Yellow Single (W2102A) | $62.52 | 1 yellow · ~1,800 pages | 3.47¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 210A Magenta Single (W2103A) | $62.52 | 1 magenta · ~1,800 pages | 3.47¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 210X Black Single (W2100X) | $79.22 | 1 black, high yield · ~7,500 pages | 1.06¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 210X Cyan Single (W2101X) | $79.22 | 1 cyan, high yield · ~5,500 pages | 1.44¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 210X Yellow Single (W2102X) | $79.22 | 1 yellow, high yield · ~5,500 pages | 1.44¢ | Bought one at a time |
| 210X Magenta Single (W2103X) | $79.22 | 1 magenta, high yield · ~5,500 pages | 1.44¢ | Bought one at a time |
The row to study is the 210X 2 Black: at 0.95¢ it posts the cheapest page on the page, and it is a black-only box — a reminder that even on a color machine, most pages are still documents. The quieter story sits in the two set rows: the X set costs $66.79 more than the A set and returns more than three times the rated pages for the difference.
Flat pricing inside each tier — and why black wins it
A shelf like this would ordinarily price its colors above its black, because that is what HP itself does: genuine colors run $24.00 dearer than the genuine black in the A tier and $50.00 dearer in X. This store does the opposite of differentiating — every 210A single is $62.52 and every 210X single is $79.22, whichever station it feeds. Because HP rates the black higher in both tiers, identical prices turn the black into the bargain: 3.13¢ a page against 3.47¢ for a color in A, and 1.06¢ against 1.44¢ in X.
What that means month to month depends on the mix coming off the printer. A documents-first office lives on the black ladder, where stepping up to the 210X 2 Black pack cuts the rate to 0.95¢ — under a cent a page at rated output. Color work rides the sets, where blending across four stations brings the A set to 2.73¢ and the X set to 1.12¢. Either way, the tier decision outweighs the box decision: every X offer on the shelf beats every A offer on a per-page basis.
HP’s ratings, the smaller cartridges in a new printer, and no drum to chase
HP rates the 210A black at about 2,000 pages and each 210A color at about 1,800; the 210X black at about 7,500 and each 210X color at about 5,500 — all declared under ISO/IEC 19798 with continuous printing. Read them as planning averages rather than guarantees: a run of photo-heavy pages will pull a color station well short of its rating, while plain documents can carry past it. Every listing on this shelf states these same figures, so no correction between the product pages and this guide is needed.
Nor does a new 4201 or 4301 begin life on the cartridges sold below. HP’s datasheet box contents and its store specification line both describe preinstalled introductory cartridges in all four colors: black at about 1,200 pages, and cyan, magenta and yellow at about 1,000 apiece. HP publishes those numbers itself, so they are stated here rather than guessed at — the first replacement order will come due well ahead of the retail ratings, and everything on this shelf is a full retail cartridge.
Budgeting holds no drum surprise on this platform: drum and toner live inside the same cartridge unit, so swapping the cartridge is the entire job. Set against genuine pricing, HP’s US store charges $114.99 for the genuine 210A black and $138.99 for each genuine color; the genuine 210X black is $218.99 and each X color $268.99, all in stock on the date checked. Building a full genuine set from those singles comes to $531.96 in the A tier and $1,025.96 in X, against $201.87 and $268.66 for the two sets at the top of this page.
Ten printers, two series — and all of them take both tiers
HP’s compatibility list for this family names ten machines across two series, and the fit is uniform: HP’s 4201 datasheet lists all eight cartridges — both tiers, all four stations — as the platform’s replacement cartridges. No model is limited to the standard tier or fenced off from the high-yield one, and the “e” variants, HP’s HP+ models, take the same cartridges as their plain counterparts.
The print-only series: the Color LaserJet Pro 4201dn, the Color LaserJet Pro 4201dne, the Color LaserJet Pro 4201dw and the Color LaserJet Pro 4201dwe.
The multifunctions: the Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301dw, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301dwe, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdn, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdne, the Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw and the Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdwe, each built on the same four-cartridge print engine, with scanning and copying added.
The practical test never changes: read the cartridge that comes out of the machine. If its label carries any code from W2100 through W2103, with either the A or the X suffix, the offers on this page are its replacements — the station color is printed on the same label.
Chips: the listings are silent — HP is not
Run a search for the word chip through all twelve listings on this shelf and it returns nothing. Firmware and security are equally absent. These product pages make no statement of any kind about how their cartridges are recognized by the printer — and this guide will not put words in their mouths.
HP’s position, by contrast, is stated in the open. HP describes these printers as dynamic-security machines: in its own words, the printer “is intended to work only with cartridges that have a new or reused HP chip”, it “uses dynamic security measures to block cartridges using a non-HP chip”, and periodic firmware updates “will maintain the effectiveness of these measures and block cartridges that previously worked”. Read plainly, HP is reserving the ability to stop a non-HP cartridge that works today. Nothing on this shelf contradicts that statement — and nothing here should be read as a promise that any compatible cartridge carries an HP chip, because the listings claim no chip at all.
So the protection a buyer actually holds is the cover the listings do state: a one-year warranty and a year of free returns on every offer on this page. That is the honest basis for buying here — the wide price gap against genuine cartridges, with a full year to send back any cartridge that disappoints.
Warranty and returns: the cover behind all twelve
Twelve offers — matching the box to the printer’s appetite
Questions the 4201 and 4301 platform raises
Either, in any of the ten printers — HP lists both tiers as replacements for the whole platform, and the two can be mixed station by station. The arithmetic favors X wherever volume is real: an X cartridge costs about 27% more than its A counterpart and returns 3.75 times the black pages and about three times the color pages, so X posts the lower per-page rate in all six slots. The A tier’s case is the upfront bill — a full A restock is $201.87 against $268.66.
No — and this time the figures are on the record. HP’s datasheet box contents and its store specifications both put preinstalled introductory cartridges in all four colors: black at roughly 1,200 pages, cyan, magenta and yellow at roughly 1,000 each. Because HP publishes those numbers, they are printed here as fact: the first full set will be ordered earlier than the retail ratings suggest, and every cartridge sold on this page is a full retail-fill unit.
Because that is how this store prices the family: every 210A single is $62.52 and every 210X single is $79.22, station regardless. Genuine HP pricing runs the other way — its colors cost more than its black in both tiers. Pair the flat shelf price with HP’s higher black ratings and the black becomes the per-page bargain of each tier: 3.13¢ against 3.47¢ in A, and 1.06¢ against 1.44¢ in X.
That deserves a straight answer rather than a reassuring one. The listings on this shelf claim no chip of any kind — the word does not appear in them. HP, for its part, states that these printers use dynamic security measures to block cartridges using a non-HP chip, and that periodic firmware updates maintain those measures and can block cartridges that previously worked. Nothing on this page can promise recognition the sellers themselves do not claim. What stands behind every offer instead is cover: a one-year warranty and a year of free returns.
No. In both tiers the three colors exist as singles only. Color depth is carried by the two four-color sets instead: the 210A set for a standard round of all four stations, the 210X set for a high-yield round. Black is the family’s only cartridge with a pack of its own.
Return it. Every listing here carries the same cover — warranty protection plus free returns for twelve months, counted cartridge by cartridge, so the last unit out of a set is covered from its own fitting date rather than the day the box arrived. Support is available on weekdays, 9 AM to 5 PM Central, while a return is arranged; hold on to the box until the new cartridge has run cleanly.
